India to sell 'enemy shares' of people who fled to Pakistan

[Jackdaws]

Even 1 is too many

Of course it is. I am not the one who asked for numbers.

 

[Rusty]

Of course it is. I am not the one who asked for numbers.

It was retorical question.

End of the day Muslims in Pakistan are infinitely better off than Muslims in India.

Our leaders were smart enough to know that that this would happen

 

[Zibago]

Translation we are going to confiscate property of folks we dislike

 

[Jackdaws]

It was retorical question.

End of the day Muslims in Pakistan are infinitely better off than Muslims in India.

Our leaders were smart enough to know that that this would happen

An average Muslim stepping out of his home is safer in India than in Pak. Just compare the stats of sectarian violence. What's done is done. I don't see Indian Muslims making a beeline to emigrate. Pakistanis jump at the chance.

 

[Kamikaze Pilot]

I don't see Indian Muslims making a beeline to emigrate. Pakistanis jump at the chance.

It's because of scarcity of resources in Pakistan. Not because of some imaginary strife.

And when the opportunity was presented, Indian Muslims did make a beeline to emigrate in 1947.

 

[El Sidd]

An average Muslim stepping out of his home is safer in India than in Pak. Just compare the stats of sectarian violence. What's done is done. I don't see Indian Muslims making a beeline to emigrate. Pakistanis jump at the chance.

Forced to live in Ghettos. The gang violence has evolved into terrorism.

Muslim or not. An average Pakistani leads more a Content Life than an Indian.

 

[A.P. Richelieu]

Not from Hindu families who were living there. Do u not get that? The Hindus who remained in Pakistan(and thus became Pakistani citizens) did not have their homes taken away. The only homes Muslims took(alotted by the government) were the ones left abandoned. In order to compensate the ppl who had left everything behind(in India)...

Sounds like Israel after 1948.
I am sure someone will explain the difference.

 

[N.Siddiqui]

I don't see Indian Muslims making a beeline to emigrate. Pakistanis jump at the chance.

You need money, resources, connections to emigrate, Indian Muslims are the poorest, most marginalized group in India, holding onto the old Hindustan our land, the Mughals and all that historical background and so...people don't leave their own ancestral land often...

https://herald.dawn.com/news/1153473

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/stud...than-untouchables-and-falling-further.585691/


...a very large percentage of rich Muslims emigrated to Pakistan after independence and later years, that includes Memons, Bohris, Agha Khanis, Punjab Saudagarans, Patiala's, rich Biharis, UP, Rampur's and more.

 

[Jackdaws]

It's because of scarcity of resources in Pakistan. Not because of some imaginary strife.

And when the opportunity was presented, Indian Muslims did make a beeline to emigrate in 1947.

Imaginary strife?
They have issues with Ahmadiyas who are declared heretics. They have issues with Mohajirs. They have issues with Balochis. They have issues with Shias.

Only a tiny fraction of Indian Muslims emigrated to Pak. And a significant amount were forced from their homes in Indian Punjab.

 

[N.Siddiqui]

Only a tiny fraction of Indian Muslims emigrated to Pak. And a significant amount were forced from their homes in Indian Punjab.

Lol close to 10 million Muslims migrated to Pakistan from India...

 

[Jackdaws]

Forced to live in Ghettos. The gang violence has evolved into terrorism.

Muslim or not. An average Pakistani leads more a Content Life than an Indian.

I have no idea about Muslims living in ghettos in Pakistan, so I will take your word for it.

Maybe the average Pak is more content. Perhaps you need some discontent to kickstart your growth rate.

You need money, resources, connections to emigrate, Indian Muslims are the poorest, most marginalized group in India, holding onto the old Hindustan our land, the Mughals and all that historical background and so...people don't leave their own ancestral land often...

https://herald.dawn.com/news/1153473

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/stud...than-untouchables-and-falling-further.585691/


...a very large percentage of rich Muslims emigrated to Pakistan after independence and later years, that includes Memons, Bohris, Agha Khanis, Punjab Saudagarans, Patiala's, Rampur's and more.

Then they would emigrate to Pakistan or Bangladesh. But they don't.

Lol close to 10 million Muslims migrated to Pakistan from India...

6 million, many forced from Punjab and Bengal. So it would still be a fraction of the total population - those that voluntarily emigrated.

 

[El Sidd]

I have no idea about Muslims living in ghettos in Pakistan, so I will take your word for it.

Maybe the average Pak is more content. Perhaps you need some discontent to kickstart your growth rate.

Interesting opinion.

I keep suggesting war. They keep saying not now

 

[N.Siddiqui]

I have no idea about Muslims living in ghettos in Pakistan, so I will take your word for it.

Maybe the average Pak is more content. Perhaps you need some discontent to kickstart your growth rate.

...Just to give you one example, one of my first cousin family with 2 daughters and one son migrated to Australia from India, they were Indian nationals...way back in the 80's...recently 2 of the daughters got married, to Pakistanis, one is a doctor there in Sydney, the other one is an Engineer from NED Karachi, Pakistan, the reason they gave was there are hardly any educated Muslims from India in Australia, and from good cultured families as well...so they choose grooms from Pakistan.

It is a vicious cycle for Muslims in India, no education...no jobs and no jobs...no education, we all know the jobs and education quota's for Dalits, SC/OBC/ST caste in India and Muslims are left in the lurch.

 

[ohmrlobalobayeh]

I have no idea about Muslims living in ghettos in Pakistan, so I will take your word for it.

Maybe the average Pak is more content. Perhaps you need some discontent to kickstart your growth rate.



Then they would emigrate to Pakistan or Bangladesh. But they don't.


6 million, many forced from Punjab and Bengal. So it would still be a fraction of the total population - those that voluntarily emigrated.

How about Indians running to hongkong only to find themselves getting kicked out to Sydney?

 

[Jackdaws]

...Just to give you one example, one of my first cousin family with 2 daughters and one son migrated to Australia from India, they were Indian nationals...way back in the 80's...recently 2 of the daughters got married, to Pakistanis, one is a doctor there in Sydney, the other one is an Engineer from NED Karachi, Pakistan, the reason they gave was there are hardly any educated Muslims from India in Australia, and from good cultured families as well...so they choose grooms from Pakistan.

It is a vicious cycle for Muslims in India, no education...no jobs and no jobs...no education, we all know the jobs and education quota's for Dalits, SC/OBC/ST caste in India and Muslims are left in the lurch.

Buddy we all have such stories. I do as well. Cuts both ways.

How about Indians running to hongkong only to find themselves getting kicked out to Sydney?

But we always take Chinese destitute refugees in who beg us to let them in. We never say no.