India:Muslims want curbs on Hindu procession

[apolitical]

They aren't out citizens but clearly there is a clash of culture going on there.

Luckily in Pakistan despite communal incidents and injustices against minorities - on a larger part you will never hear about such things. Even in my native Peshawar the Sikhs and Muslims live side by side, speak same language and go freely to their gurdwaras

In fact even though there is a mini Sikh enclave many Muslims living there as well

Are you actually serious? Your minority population has already been killed off, you barely have 3% left, not to mention non-Islamic religions are not violent. Comparing that to a violent 13% Islamic population is very biased...

 

[Abu Zolfiqar]

Are you actually serious? Your minority population has already been killed off, you barely have 3% left, not to mention non-Islamic religions are not violent. Comparing that to a violent 13% Islamic population is very biased...

That number is completely incorrect.

By the way, you conveniently "forgot" also that Muslim populations birth rate is considerably higher than that of our Parsi/Christian/Sikh/hindu ones

 

[INDIC]

We are communal not doubt but better than the two pieces divided on communal lines.

These Muslism and thier ardent supporters across the border cannot even bear our processions, they lecture us

They pretend to care about Indian Muslims but abuse their own Muhajir population all the time even asking them to go back to India.

 

[SamantK]

They pretend to care about Indian Muslims but abuse their own Muhajir population all the time even asking them to go back to India.

There is no end to Pakistani double standards.

 

[apolitical]

That number is completely incorrect.

By the way, you conveniently "forgot" also that Muslim populations birth rate is considerably higher than that of our Parsi/Christian/Sikh/hindu ones

Yes, but that doesnt make your population decrease so wildly. We are talking about a country (Pak) here which was very multi-religious pre-1947 (significant Hindus, Sikhs, Christians). You guys have less Sikhs in Pakistan than UK, and Lahore to Sikhs is supposed to be like Mecca to Muslims (in the sense that it was the birthplace fo Sikhism and it spread from there) .

Like it or not, there is no comparison between the minorities of Pakistan and India. In India, elected Muslim leaders in Hyderabad get to openly talk about how Hindu idols are false Gods and Hinduism is a dumb religion, and still not get attacked because we believe in the Freedom of Speech and civil liberties. Can you imagine what a Hindu in Pakistan will go through if he says similar things about Islam? When already (despite being completely innocent) the condition of Hindus in Pakistan is so bad that they are leaving Pak by the trainloads, quite literally? Same goes for Sikhs and Christians.

 

[INDIC]

There is no end to Pakistani double standards.

Yesterday, they were talking about Stranded Pakistanis. One guy even wrote a comment that giving asylum to them in Pakistan would be agitating hornet's nest. And look they are sheding crocodile tears for Indian Muslims but bomb and badmouth their own Pashtun and Baloch civilians.

 

[Nitin Tomer]

If their concern is legitimate then yes their should be ban. All VHP RSS chaddis try to bait muslims using these processions

 

[PlanetWarrior]

^^^ C'mon man..play along with their delusions about the land of paradise. We beat up our minorities whilst theirs sleep safe and sound. All our minorities (including lower caste Hindus) want to emigrate to Pakistan but we forcibly hold them back to torture them.

 

[KingMamba]

Never said all Muslims are the same but my post which you've quoted does show my opinion pertaining to the fact that all Hindus the world over are jahilya and kaffir- and as such are prone to trying to cause injury to the true children of god. Keep up yaara.

Since you know the gist of the problem, help Indian Muslims solve it.

Are you actually serious? Your minority population has already been killed off, you barely have 3% left, not to mention non-Islamic religions are not violent. Comparing that to a violent 13% Islamic population is very biased...

Most of the Hindus of Pakistan were in East Pakistan and so naturally their numbers dwindled when Bangladesh was made, the rest migrated to India as the economic opportunities there are more than Pakistan currently. The Hindus in Sindh region are quite wealthy.

 

[INDIC]

That number is completely incorrect.

By the way, you conveniently "forgot" also that Muslim populations birth rate is considerably higher than that of our Parsi/Christian/Sikh/hindu ones

Most of them fled the country. Even your Turi people along with Hazaras are fleeing to Australia.

 

[Agnostic_Indian]

If their concern is legitimate then yes their should be ban. All VHP RSS chaddis try to bait muslims using these processions

their concern is illegitimate, so no ban on that grounds.

 

[cyphercide]

They aren't our citizens but clearly there is a clash of culture going on there. It's kind of like that song vatam de mataram or whatever you guys call it; Muslims refuse to sing it because it involves idolatry. These are nuances you would have no choice to accept.

Luckily in Pakistan despite communal incidents and injustices against minorities - on a larger part you will never hear about such things.

Really? I hear many schools in Balochistan and Karachi refuse to sing your national anthem.

The restive Balochistan province is not the only place where the national anthem remains barred from many of its educational institutions. Several leading elite schools of Karachi have also stopped following the tradition in their morning assemblies, calling it a "waste of time and energy."

Karachi elite schools say no to national anthem

 

[Emmie]

Yes, but that doesnt make your population decrease so wildly. We are talking about a country (Pak) here which was very multi-religious pre-1947 (significant Hindus, Sikhs, Christians). You guys have less Sikhs in Pakistan than UK, and Lahore to Sikhs is supposed to be like Mecca to Muslims (in the sense that it was the birthplace fo Sikhism and it spread from there) .

Minority population (religious) in today's Pakistan has always been close to 3! Figures of 12% or 17% are not valid because B'desh, home to 80% of combined minority population is now an independent country.

And in second part if you are referring to Mr. Awais then I reckon you need to update yourself! However I do agree minorities in Pakistan are not in very good condition.

 

[MilSpec]

It's fascinating... defence discussion on the forum wont amount to more than a 5 pages.. religion will go on for 50 pages

 

[INDIC]

Most of the Hindus of Pakistan were in East Pakistan and so naturally their numbers dwindled when Bangladesh was made, the rest migrated to India as the economic opportunities there are more than Pakistan currently. The Hindus in Sindh region are quite wealthy.

General Niazi gave written order to his troops to massacre Hindus in 1971 war. They have continuosly fleeing Pakistan and Bandladesh. Pakistani Hindus are still coming to India.

Recently some 480 Hindus fled Pakistan to India.