What's new

India may be able to use water as weapon of war (water terrorism?)

Kabira

BANNED
Joined
Jul 12, 2014
Messages
14,383
Reaction score
-20
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
ISLAMABAD:

As India continues to build dams and hydropower projects in pursuit of acquiring capability to manipulate the flow of water, experts have warned that New Delhi may be able to use water as a weapon of war against Pakistan.


They expressed these concerns at a seminar on “Water Security and Emerging Threats in Pakistan” organised by the Centre for Global and Strategic Studies (CGSS) on Thursday.

The seminar brought together water experts, climatologists, specialists, government representative, students from across the country and individuals from public and private entities.

In his opening remarks at the event, Chairman CGSS Lt-Gen (retd) Muhammad Zahirul Islam said, “Water was once our biggest asset – the blood to the agricultural backbone of our economy – [but] now it is our biggest threats.”

He added, “Our dams remain empty, and there is less and less clean water to drink each year” and “this shows the amount of mismanagement and ignorance we show to this vital commodity”.

The CGSS chairman called India the biggest threat to Pakistan’s water security.

Former WAPDA chairman Shamsul Mulk presented a paper on “Political, Economic and Social Issues faced by Pakistan in Securing Water Resources”, and highlighted the importance of water resources management.

Describing proper management as mandatory, he spoke about the loopholes in the bureaucracy, hampering the implementation of various projects, and stressed the need for reforms.

Chairman Gomal Damaan Area Water Partnership Brigadier (retd) Muhammad Aslam delivered a speech on “Realistic Appraisal of Indus water Treaty”.

He said that India’s Kishanganga Hydel Project could interfere with Neelum-Jhelum Power Plant. “India, an upper riparian, is not doing responsible watershed management,” he stressed.

Vice President CGSS Babur Suhail spoke about “Growing Indian Threats to Cut Water Supply: Analysis of IWT”.

He shed light on the IWT (Indus Water Treaty), its implications for Pakistan and India as well as water terrorism and threatening statements by India to turn Pakistan into a water-scarce country.

He stated that right after the independence, there was friction on water sharing between Pakistan and India. He said the IWT is based on ‘division’ instead of ‘sharing’.

Chairman, Pakistan Council of Research in Water Resources (PCRWR) Muhammad Ashraf presented his views on water management loopholes and elaborated the essence of water for human life.

He also discussed the impact of mismanagement of water resources and its repercussions on the economy.

Further highlighting the impacts of mismanagement of water, he briefed that ground water depletion is a major cause of loss of water in Pakistan. Notably, he also gave certain precautions and offered recommendations for effective water storage in Pakistan.
https://tribune.com.pk/story/1457423/india-may-able-use-water-weapon-war/
 
.
other than releasing water and flooding land water is not a good weapon
 
. .
When in Israel, Modi visited a desalination plan. They have turned Israel from a water scarce country to one with abundant water in the middle of desert. If only we can learn something from them, India is atleast trying whereas Pakistan is just bickering and abusing Juice
 
.
Lol

India ain't that stupid. They have their own major water problem.

And Pakistan ain't Bangladesh

And India can't control Pakistani water by force due to geography
 
. . . .
That's right. India is 'messing' around with water.

Pakistan should ask for immediate dissolution of the IWT and open negotiations for a new treaty. :sarcastic:

Forget about new treaty. Its about time to follow international water laws. IWT favour India to the point its not even funny.
 
.
Forget about new treaty. Its about time to follow international water laws. IWT favour India to the point its not even funny.

NO it does not ; read this

https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/215952-Scorecard-at-seventy

Let us proceed chronologically. The Indus Waters Treaty 1960 that guaranteed the supply of water in the three western rivers – Indus, Jhelum and Chenab – can be viewed as a success.

However, it is only a marginal one as this was not the best deal that we could have struck.

We have seen countries like Israel often denying waters to lower riparians. Eugene Black, a former president of the World Bank, is reported to have told former president Ayub Khan, that the treaty was the best arrangement that Pakistan could get under the circumstances.

If it wanted more water, Pakistan would need to go to war with India, win it and subsequently demand access to water. If we have not followed up to secure more reservoirs, it is entirely our fault.
 
. .
When in Israel, Modi visited a desalination plan. They have turned Israel from a water scarce country to one with abundant water in the middle of desert. If only we can learn something from them, India is atleast trying whereas Pakistan is just bickering and abusing Juice

Israel GDP per capita is $40k and receive $5 billion aid from US per year. Population of just 8 million. They can afford water desalination plants but we can't.

NO it does not ; read this

https://www.thenews.com.pk/print/215952-Scorecard-at-seventy

Let us proceed chronologically. The Indus Waters Treaty 1960 that guaranteed the supply of water in the three western rivers – Indus, Jhelum and Chenab – can be viewed as a success.

However, it is only a marginal one as this was not the best deal that we could have struck.

We have seen countries like Israel often denying waters to lower riparians. Eugene Black, a former president of the World Bank, is reported to have told former president Ayub Khan, that the treaty was the best arrangement that Pakistan could get under the circumstances.

If it wanted more water, Pakistan would need to go to war with India, win it and subsequently demand access to water. If we have not followed up to secure more reservoirs, it is entirely our fault.

India couldn't use water from 3 western rivers, what was it going to do with it? Irrigate mountains? While Pakistan leaders back then sold 3 eastern rivers and now these mostly receive water in summer. India also funded anti-Kalabagh dam lobby.

Pakistan should have negotiated fair share of water from eastern rivers. India knows they got great deal in IWT. Now they are just going to play around water from western rivers by building dams and releasing when they want it. Water war will be another low and Pakistan should have all options on table to deal with it.
 
.
India couldn't use water from 3 western rivers, what was it going to do with it? Irrigate mountains? While Pakistan leaders back then sold 3 eastern rivers and now these mostly receive water in summer. India also funded anti-Kalabagh dam lobby.

Pakistan should have negotiated fair share of water from eastern rivers. India knows they got great deal in IWT. Now they are just going to play around water from western rivers by building dams and releasing when they want it. Water war will be another low and Pakistan should have all options on table to deal with it.

Even if you drag us to ANY damned court ; ultimately what matters
in international affairs is the Good will and image that a country has

We can always turn around and say that what ever we are doing
is because of your support to terrorism

Ever since last year ; we have simply refused all talks on IWT

Who will support you ; China which does not respect any Treaty what so ever
or USA which has many grievances against you

This issue cannot be looked at in isolation

It is directly related to the relations between two countries
 
.
Even if you drag us to ANY damned court ; ultimately what matters
in international affairs is the Good will and image that a country has

We can always turn around and say that what ever we are doing
is because of your support to terrorism

Ever since last year ; we have simply refused all talks on IWT

Who will support you ; China which does not respect any Treaty what so ever
or USA which has many grievances against you

This issue cannot be looked at in isolation

It is directly related to the relations between two countries

Son we are not Bangladesh. Once its established India is playing with our water all options will be on table. No point in dying slow death. We are not looking for world to bail us out, we know how to deal with India.
 
.
Son we are not Bangladesh. Once its established India is playing with our water all options will be on table. No point in dying slow death. We are not looking for world to bail us out, we know how to deal with India.

We shall see what can you do ; the game has just begun
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom