What's new

India-made Dhruv choppers restricted from flying in Equador after mishaps

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
India-made Dhruv helicopters sold to Equador have suffered accidents recently, prompting an order of "restricted" operations on the remaining ones, a development that could cause concern to the government which is planning expansion of export of military hardware.

Ecuadorian Air Force had bought seven Dhruv helicopters from state-run HAL in 2009 under a deal estimated to cost about USD 45 million.

Two of them had crashed earlier while two suffered accidents recently, in a span of about a fortnight. "Three aircraft have had their operations restricted because they are undergoing a complete check," Security Minister Cesar Navas was quoted as saying by El Universo newspaper after the accident on January 27.

Dhruv helicopter FAE 605 allegedly caught fire in Ecuador's Amazon region on January 27 after taking off at a military base in Tena, according to local media. Two people were injured in the mishap.

It was the fourth Dhruv to suffer an accident since 2009. Incidentally, this mishap occurred at a time when an Indian team was already there to probe the incident that took place on January 13.

"Our team is already there to investigate what has happened. The incident happened during training," HAL Chairman R K Tyagi told PTI referring to the January 13 accident.
Official sources said another General Manager (Repairs and Maintenance), has now being sent to the northwestern South American country following the second accident.

They said the joint probe team will look into all angles including technical and human error. A major accident happened in February 2014 when a Dhruv, assigned to the Air Force and sometimes used to transport President Rafael Correa, crashed on a flight from Guayaquil to Quito, killing three of its four crew members.

Earlier in October 2009, one helicopter crashed while making a low pass during a military ceremony in Quito, injuring the pilot and co-pilot. Dhruv helicopters were inducted into the Indian military in 2002.

HAL has grand plans for the helicopter and has already exported it (inlcuding civil and military variants) to few countries including Maldives, Mauritius and Nepal.
The development is likely to cause concern to the government which has intention of expanding export of military hardware as there can questions on quality.

India-made Dhruv choppers restricted from flying in Equador after mishaps
 
why didn't they just buy some Mi-8/17s?

corruption and 1 ecuador guy who opposed was shot dead

Then you dont have any idea of its performance during Uttarakhand tragedy or its recent performance during the Kashmir floods and how many sortie its done under extreme conditions.

dhruv was grounded during j&k floods
 
HAL makes low quality products. The frequent crash of Su-30MKI and incidents such as these are a clear example.

You are either a total moron and full of ignorance or a wizzard to know the reasons for the crash before ANY kind of investigation.

Now chose one of the options.

High altitude requirements were met only by Dhruv. Are you suggesting Mi 17 is better than Dhruv ?

Depends on the required role

Well Germany crashed their F16 ... So its up to the country which maintain it.

Germany never used F16s...
 
All these news about Dhruv will only discourage others from consider this chopper. Whether what/who is at fault. Even if this is pilot error, this chopper certainly has lots of pilot errors.
 
It was a Greek F 16

My bad ! There resemblance did not helped the case.

So Greek lost F16 so it doesn't mean it a problem with Dhruv. Latest druv is more advanced and matured . HAL should look into the glitch (if it's so) and offer upgrading them with less price. It will be confident building measures .
 
HAL makes low quality products. The frequent crash of Su-30MKI and incidents such as these are a clear example.

Of course, especially if the Su 30 in IAF has a track record of 5 accidents in roughly 17 years of service, or by the fact that most of the crashes were caused by pilot errors, or the fact that most of the problems happend with fighters and systems delivered directly by Russia compared to the fighters and systems HAL produced and implemented. :disagree:
 
Back
Top Bottom