India lower caste still removing human waste

[Spring Onion]

Apart from your usual stupidity, there was nothing much to see there. Both Baajey and me are from Dalit communities.

congrats for climbing a level up.

BTW you being from low cast Hindu community means whatever is said in the opening post about condition of low cast hindus in India is a LIE?

aapaa jaan,
daliton ko rights to diye huey hai, par .....
most of them are playing ostrich at the cost of their uplifment.....n morever there are always some biased ppl, who for their own ends, exploit the system.

The issue here is NOT th poverty neither unemployment in my opinion as people in every society from every status may face these at some point in their life BUT The main issue with Indian Hindu cast system is that even today the educated Indians still have this biased mentality towards low casts.

Thats what need to change

 

[Indrani]

congrats for climbing a level up.

BTW you being from low cast Hindu community means whatever is said in the opening post about condition of low cast hindus in India is a LIE?

There is no need to congratulate me. My entire community have been urban dwellers for a long time and most are very well to do. The article is a misrepresentation. No one goes looking for low caste people for those jobs. No one is forced to do that as well. It is these people who have volunteered for the job given their poor circumstances.

A lot of upper caste people go abroad and get into cleaners or janitorial jobs. Would you then say that cleaning shit abroad is a upper caste enterprise while cleaning shit at home is due to lower caste?

 

[possumlot]

Who does the manual scavenging in pakistan ? .........

I just found one picture ..

 

[Indrani]

Who does the manual scavenging in pakistan ? .........

I just found one picture ..

They get the lower caste Christians to do that job. Also while it is rare to see an Indian call anyone bhangi or chamar, the Pakistani folks on PDF never miss a chance to call someone that.

 

[harpoon]

Ever heard of septic tanks.

 

[baajey]

The issue here is NOT th poverty neither unemployment in my opinion as people in every society from every status may face these at some point in their life BUT The main issue with Indian Hindu cast system is that even today the educated Indians still have this biased mentality towards low casts.

Thats what need to change

unfortunately, for me n india as a whole in this case, u are correct.
but when u touch a sensitive issue as mentality, u have to wait for 1 to 2 generations to go by before u can expect some change (for good)

There is no need to congratulate me. My entire community have been urban dwellers for a long time and most are very well to do. The article is a misrepresentation. No one goes looking for low caste people for those jobs. No one is forced to do that as well. It is these people who have volunteered for the job given their poor circumstances.

A lot of upper caste people go abroad and get into cleaners or janitorial jobs. Would you then say that cleaning shit abroad is a upper caste enterprise while cleaning shit at home is due to lower caste?

bang on target

 

[Spring Onion]

They get the lower caste Christians to do that job. Also while it is rare to see an Indian call anyone bhangi or chamar, the Pakistani folks on PDF never miss a chance to call someone that.

yes we do along with Muslims and its a lucrative job with alot of govt leaves along with the sweepers dont carry their duties for days

oh by the way chamar is not a bad word its just a shoe maker or the one who stitch shoes or repair . bhangi is used for water career here in Pakistan atleast ib my province. There used to be bhangis who used to deliver water buckets at door step and charge you for the same. now it has been replaced by sarkari nul :p oh by the way i call politicians as bhangiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii.

so who is a bhangi in India?

 

[ShivajiBhosale]

Also while it is rare to see an Indian call anyone bhangi or chamar, the Pakistani folks on PDF never miss a chance to call someone that.

They will deny or justify it as usual

 

[Spring Onion]

They will deny or justify it as usual

what does it mean in India?

 

[GURU DUTT]

what does it mean in India?

well jana ji in india its a criminal non bailable offence if you call a chamar a chamr , nai a nai , bhangee a bhangee or use words like shoodr or malaich which pakistanies regularlly use in there lingo and we can see that on almost all the pakistani programs and specially on PDF

well caste system is almost a thing of the past in india rather now the so called "higher casts like kshatria, baniya , brahmins" are facing a reverse caste system as they cant have indian govt jobs or admission into mediakl or enginearing or any other educational institution (even booking govt build flats) easily deu to "reservations for shedule caste/ shedule tribes"

kindli google "mandal comission"

 

[Indrani]

yes we do along with Muslims and its a lucrative job with alot of govt leaves along with the sweepers dont carry their duties for days

oh by the way chamar is not a bad word its just a shoe maker or the one who stitch shoes or repair . bhangi is used for water career here in Pakistan atleast ib my province. There used to be bhangis who used to deliver water buckets at door step and charge you for the same. now it has been replaced by sarkari nul :p oh by the way i call politicians as bhangiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii.

so who is a bhangi in India?

I know the word chamar or bhangi signifies the occupation of shoe maker and a sweeper, but what it conveys depends on its usage.

A bhangi in India is a sweeper.

 

[xyxmt]

aapaa jaan,
daliton ko rights to diye huey hai, par .....
most of them are playing ostrich at the cost of their uplifment.....n morever there are always some biased ppl, who for their own ends, exploit the system.

thats like breaking someone's legs then saying I didnt stop him from leaving.

 

[scorpionx]

Whenever a discussion goes on Caste system, its funny to see how conveniently saffron razakars try to explain the whole thing by class struggle which is a patent theory of the communists

 

[xyxmt]

well jana ji in india its a criminal non bailable offence if you call a chamar a chamr , nai a nai , bhangee a bhangee or use words like shoodr or malaich which pakistanies regularlly use in there lingo and we can see that on almost all the pakistani programs and specially on PDF

well caste system is almost a thing of the past in india rather now the so called "higher casts like kshatria, baniya , brahmins" are facing a reverse caste system as they cant have indian govt jobs or admission into mediakl or enginearing or any other educational institution (even booking govt build flats) easily deu to "reservations for shedule caste/ shedule tribes"

kindli google "mandal comission"

one thing is making laws, implementing them is a totally different issue.

 

[GURU DUTT]

one thing is making laws, implementing them is a totally different issue.

well in india when a law means vote bank politicks then things get realli serous and most of the caste based politikal parties like BSP , SP and many others this law is there bread and butter to survive and come to india i will be happy to show you how relegeouslli and sincearlli owr politicans use this law for there caste based politicks