India Is A Monster That Needs To Be Kept In Check

[Figaro]

Give J&K back to Pakistan, give AP back to China, split Ladakh both ways, give independence to the rest of Northeast India and Sikkim, give Bhutan independence from its protectorate status, and divide the rest of India between north and south. Problem solved. Ensures peace and prosperity in South Asia for the next 200 years .

 

[American Pakistani]

Historical anachronism. China was an ally of the West prior to 1949. India was already an "artificial creation by British" two years earlier.

Pakistan was also ally of the west. So your point is not logical.

Before 49, Chinese major interests were similar to the west's major interests of that current time.

 

[Cherub786]

Pakistan was also ally of the west. So your point is not logical.

Before 49, Chinese major interests were similar to the west's major interests of that current time.

You claimed the British created India to contain China. It's your point that is illogical. Why would the British create an ally to contain another ally? Did the British foresee China would go red two years in advance?

 

[redgriffin]

I understand where you coming from, and perhaps also why you coming from where you coming from.
Punjab liberation is done to create an alternative monster.
Because of that monster District of Gurdaspur was excluded from Pakistan as Muslim majority district.
If it had included in Pakistan , it would have been impossible for India to capture and keep Kashmir.
Nope, that was not a favour to the Muslims. It was actually pre-planned by the British to punish the Muslims of India and later of Pakistan.

Gurdaspur, Jallandhur, Zeera & Ferozepur. All muslim majority districts, all given to India despite being contiguous with the rest of Pakistani Punjab allowing overland access to Kashmir (esp Gurdaspur).

 

[American Pakistani]

You claimed the British created India to contain China. It's your point that is illogical. Why would the British create an ally to contain another ally? Did the British foresee China would go red two years in advance?

Even Soviet was the ally of British during ww2 but British were always sceptical about them.

And like I said Britain and China had common interest of that current time because Japan was fighting against China and Germany against British region. West plan ahead and they always see others with suspicion, so the artificial India was created because that in British eye was the only similar country that could contain China of future. Read about anti imperialists movements in China before 49 such as wusa yundong, may 4th etc. Even Japan was British ally in the beginning of 1900s. But the time you are talking about was because British wanted China to succeed against Japan so that cities like Hong Kong and Singapore stay safe.

British never really see China as their ally, just like currently in recent times the west never really see Pakistan as their ally even though they called it major non NATO ally. Similarly currently the west only see India a milking cow and a tool to contain China add to that list a nuclear Pakistan now.

 

[R Wing]

india needs to be Balkanized

support Khalistan movement...

Sorry, too busy enjoying plots, getting extensions and maintaining the status quo.

 

[SecularNationalist]

India is like a slutty wife who needs to be checked . If not checked she will sleep with isreal and other men and cause problems for us.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

It was an artificial creation by British to contain rising China. Today that strategy is being used by entire west. India have problems and issues(major or minor) with entire South Asia.

Indian expansionist Hindutva nazi ideology is threat to not only the region but entire world. At first we only thought it will affect South Asia but now we see Indian support to terror organization in Afghanistan and Syria. Plus the Hindutva nazis who were recently pinned by Middle Eastern Authorities like Emirati, Saudi, Kuwaiti etc.

Indian nazi Hindutva expansionist ideology is evident by India occupying South Tibet(China), Hyderabad(independant country) , Junagadh(Pakistan), Manvadar(Pakistan), Sir Creek(Pakistan) , Goa(Portugal) , Kashmir(independent/Pakistan), Sikkim(independent country) , parts of Bhutan, and countless issues with Nepal, Srilanka and Bangladesh. Akhand bharti is true.

The reason why the West and the British have ALWAYS supported india against the Chinese and Pakistanis is due to the hindutwa ideology. The key belief of this ideology is the worship and reverence of those with White skin. That is, the worship of the White European races. Hence the West has always known that the indians can be willingly used as tool against those they hate e.g. Pakistanis, Muslims, Chinese people etc. However the problem for the West regarding this is that the indians don't have the capability, courage and intelligence to carry out their designs against those whom they hate the most.

 

[Muhammad Qaswar]

I think India need proper treatment by a well experienced Physician like Pakistan

 

[crankthatskunk]

Gurdaspur, Jallandhur, Zeera & Ferozepur. All muslim majority districts, all given to India despite being contiguous with the rest of Pakistani Punjab allowing overland access to Kashmir (esp Gurdaspur).

I didn't respond to that poster purposefully. I gave a hint, where he is coming from.
Gurdaspur was given precisely for Kashmir passage. Everything was planned by Mountbatten, i.e. G Britain.
But there is no point engaging with agenda drive people. I can shut him up, but then this forum is not for such discussions. We all have to recognise our enemies.

 

[TheGreatMaratha]

Gurdaspur was given precisely for Kashmir passage.

Gurdaspur had an even split. Calling it Muslim majority is plain absurd.
Anyway, there were plenty of Hindu majority districts that were given to Pakistan as well. This is not some toy sharing among kids lol.

 

[TheGreatMaratha]

Everything was planned by Mountbatten, i.e. G Britain.

Be happy with the chunk of land you got instead of crying for more.

 

[Bengal71]

india needs to be Balkanized

support Khalistan movement...

Won't work. The status quo will remain for now.

 

[ghazi52]

 

[ghazi52]