It's not worth replying to for you because I was making a point which simply went above your head....or its 'inconvenient'. Your intent under the cover of pseudo-intellectualism is trying to paint Bangladesh as a destitute country where brothel girls originate and are 'hungry' for a better future in 'Golden India', when reality belies this view. That is why you cherry-pick points to reply to. Those kind of 'Bhartiya' tricks are well-known over here.
I have proven in my post below (with sources) that there are just as many 'destitute' Indians working in menial jobs in Bangladesh and they are getting paid better. Then what was the point of kick-starting this two year old thread? If you were genuinely interested in solving this problem then go join the Mumbai NGO's who are rehabilitating these girls and do something about it. Trying to resolve this in PDF is pointless.
Job seekers will go where they can be hired and payed. If Bengal today started construction on mega projects, migrant workers from around India would come, as well as migrants whom may be illegal to make a living. India isn't nessearily the greener pasture, but jobs are being created on a much larger scale, and has demand plus considering the muslims are willing to do jobs that strick hindus will not, ie butcher or leather industry, theres a lot of money to be made like wise prejudiced and racism will exist as well. You can not deny that with BDs population, a small perceent can accumulate a very big number of illegal migrants. And you can not deny that India isn't progressing, jobs are being created as well as demand on volumes greater than what BD can do by itself. Its just numbers.
That being said, the reason why girls are trafficked to India via BD is not because they want a larger market for the flesh the sell, it is because these women most of whom are doing this against their will, its modern slavery and BD authorities, or the family of the girl can have a better chance of rescueing the girl if she is in BD, so if you sell her to a pimp in India, she will be less likily be traced, pimps hands get cleaned and the girl looses hope of escape in a foreign land that she is not familiar with. Its about isolated the girls and this is why girls from Nepal, end up in Mumbai or Dhaka and girls from Northern India end up in the South.
The illegal demand is originating in your country - resolve it there. If your BSF and your Mumbai police force are corrupt and filthy, then there is scarce little we can do. Reform initiatives need to start in your country.
See how bad the condition is in the Mumbai brothels - do something rather than pontificating to us. There are women from all areas of India in here, and nothing has been done for the last 100 years it looks like. Gives new meaning to the word 'H*ell-H*ole'.
Its illegal in both countries, and most countries but you can't stop men for paying women for sex. Oldest trade their is, and its hard wired in the DNA of every man and women to exploit this. BD has ghettos as well, full of prostitutes and this is in a Islamic nation, and you can find prostitutes out on the street even in Suadi Arabia but for obvious reason they are veiled. You don't think Indian, BD or Pakistan girls don't end up in Saudi Arabia as prostitutes or slaves?
The issue is simple. The solution is more complex than you could imagine expecially for developing nations.
I will agree the BSF on the BD border are not the brightist and infact lacking in morals and training let alone education, but they are what India has and despite that, they stop mojority or the easy pickings of trafficking. Its like a scarecrow tactic, you don't expect them to solve the issue 100 percent but even a 25 percent reduction or more is welcome. The BSF has been noted by GOI to be under performing and ill trained which is okay for the most part, and this is why their INSAS rifles where taken away from them for pump action shot guns. BSF on BD border are no better than the Indian Police and just as underpayed. I don't know the situation in BD of their BSF but i'd imagine manning a larger border as this is also a resource drain.
This kind of mentality only comes from a socially-backward country like yours where rapists go scott-free while the raped women are blamed for some supposed 'fault'.
And what happened to the 'invincible' fence you guys built on the border? All its doing it seems is lining the pockets of BSF personnel...
Are the big 'rape' problems in your country our fault too? You guys can't seem to get a handle on that either. Lackadaisical Indian treatment of a problem as usual.
Nothing surprising here...
Punishment for rape is not just an Indian problem but a BD problem as well. I've seen VICE news on it, same problem smaller story. India is still trying to understand the scope of rape, let alone reduce it.
Off topic, if you wanna know whats bad, is when you don't know even an estimate of rape ie Pakistan or Afghanistan.
The Social work done for women in BD is being done with the same approach in India given the similar customs and traditions. Because of this we can understand a little of scope of the problem, but vast majority of rapes are silent.
