Rusty
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2011
- Messages
- 8,563
- Reaction score
- 3
- Country
- Location
Thats actually interesting. I did some reading on this J&K issue as it is quite popular in the circles I move (mostly having Pakistan and Indian folks). So here are something I found...
1. Patell wanted Hyderabad (it was held by some local king who was muslim I guess) and was ready to let go Kashmir.
2. Patell suffered a setback and surprise in Junagraha (again held by a local Muslim king). The local king acceded to Pakistan and Patell expected Jinnha to turn him down based on Hindu population. This was September 1947. See this news paper article : https://www.thenews.com.pk/tns/detail/555860-junagadh-legally-pakistan
3. This gave Nehroo enough ammunition to shut Patell down. When in October 47, time came for Kashmir, this time the board was laid the other way round. It was a Hindu King wanting to join India with a massive Muslim population in the kingdom. It basically allowed Nehroo to argue that by the same token that Jinha used to defend Junagar's accession to Pakistan, he could seek Kashmir to join India. He also had some personal interest in the region as it was his native place or something.
So in all, it was Pakistan who broke this gentleman's agreement of letting Muslim regions join Pakistan and Hindu join India, in September '47. This lead to India playing the same game in October 47 in Kashmir.
Yep, you are Indian as your poo in the loo logic checks out.
"Jinnah wanted Junagraha so it's okay for us to invade Kashmir"
Did Jinnah launch a military invasion of Junagraha ? Hydrabad?
Of course not.
so your poo in the loo logic falls flat.
India, against all democratic, diplomatic, and agreed upon accords with Pakistan, just invaded Kashmir and caused 70 years of suffering for everyone.
Any neutral person can see that had India not done so, there were not be millions of troops and nukes pointed at each other in the subcontinent.
Pakistan made no moves to take Junagraha or Hydrabad, and to this day no Pakistani is claiming those places as Pakistani. They are Hindu majority and they rightfully belong to India.
Unfortunately, our advisory has poo not only in the loo, but also the brain and cannot accept that all the animosity is 100% due to their actions.