What's new

In favor of Hindutva; by a Pakistani muslim

The following Hindu religious laws cover more than 80% of India's population:

Hindu Marriage Act of 1956
Hindu Succession Act of 1956
Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act
Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act

These are all post-colonial acts of law based on the Anglo-Hindu law of 1772, which in turn has its origins in Classical Hindu Law.

I don't know how it is fair for Hindus to have their own religious laws in a secular democratic nation.

It is well understood that //a person unnamed who has been commenting on these matters in this thread// is a brainless wonder, and uses his cranial capacity to keep his ears apart. Point him towards this very peculiar situation and watch him wriggle:

A joint family or undivided family is an extended family arrangement prevalent throughout the Indian subcontinent, particularly in India, consisting of many generations living in the same household, all bound by the common relationship.[1]

Hindu Undivided Family (‘HUF’) is treated as a ‘person’ under section 2(31)[2] of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (herein after referred to as ‘the Act’)[1]. HUF is a separate entity for the purpose of assessment under the Act.[3]
Family structure[edit]
Historically, for generations India had a prevailing tradition of the Joint Hindu Family or undivided family. The system is an extended family arrangement prevalent throughout the Indian subcontinent, particularly in India, consisting of many generations living in the same home, all bound by the common relationship. A joint family consists of a husband and wife; their sons; their daughters, and so on up-to generations. Any number of these people may without impacting the legal existence of the family, be decreased.

The family is headed by a senior person called a 'Karta', is usually a male or a female, who makes decisions on economic and social matters on behalf of the entire family. The patriarch's wife generally exerts control over the household and minor religious practices and often wields considerable influence in domestic matters. Family income flows into a common pool, from which resources are drawn to meet the needs of all members, which are regulated by the heads of the family. However, with urbanization and economic development, India has witnessed a break up of traditional joint family into more nuclear-like families, and the traditional joint family in India accounted for a small number of Indian households.

A Hindu undivided family or HUF is a legal term related to the Hindu Marriage Act. The female members are also given the right of share to the property in the HUF. The term finds reference in the provisions of the Income Tax Act, but the expression is not defined in the act. There are various aspects of Hindu law relevant for the purpose assessment of income of HUF with Hindu Succession Act 1956 and Income Tax Act 1961 and wealth in the status of HUF, as well as the impact of the provisions of Hindu Succession Act 1956 as amended by Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act 2005 relevant for the purpose of assessment of income and wealth in the status of HUF under the Income Tax Act 1961.

In the case of Surjit Lal Chhabra 101 ITR 776 SC, joint family and undivided family are synonymous: "A joint Hindu family consists of persons lineally descended from a common ancestor and includes their wives and unmarried daughters. The daughter, on marriage, ceases to be a member of her father's family and becomes a member of her husband's family."

In 2016, a judgment of the Delhi High Court ruled that the eldest female member of a Hindu Undivided Family can be its 'Karta' (manager).
 
.
The following Hindu religious laws cover more than 80% of India's population:

Hindu Marriage Act of 1956
Hindu Succession Act of 1956
Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act
Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act

These are all post-colonial acts of law based on the Anglo-Hindu law of 1772, which in turn has its origins in Classical Hindu Law.

I don't know how it is fair for Hindus to have their own religious laws in a secular democratic nation.

They are just named Hindu act but it has nothing religious like islamic law which allows 4 wives or triple Tallaq 2which is based on sharia. On the name of Islamic laws, even today women are discriminated. Who is discriminated in the name of Hindu law.
 
.
They are just named Hindu act but it has nothing religious like islamic law which allows 4 wives or triple Tallaq 2which is based on sharia. On the name of Islamic laws, even today women are discriminated. Who is discriminated in the name of Hindu law.

Since Saffron Nazis have spent so much time obsessing over Islam and Muslims, and their laws that affect only 14% of the population, they conveniently forget about the laws that affect more than 80% of population. But let's not talk about that eh?

https://qz.com/india/224632/indian-...-as-long-as-these-9-laws-remain-on-the-books/
 
.
Since Saffron Nazis have spent so much time obsessing over Islam and Muslims, and their laws that affect only 14% of the population, they conveniently forget about the laws that affect more than 80% of population. But let's not talk about that eh?

https://qz.com/india/224632/indian-...-as-long-as-these-9-laws-remain-on-the-books/

This is already addressed by the wide support for the Uniform Civil Code a.k.a UCC by the entire Sangh Parivaar.

So why this deliberate artificial "confusion" ?
 
.
This is already addressed by the wide support for the Uniform Civil Code a.k.a UCC by the entire Sangh Parivaar.

So why this deliberate artificial "confusion" ?

All UCC talks about is that Muslims will have to abandon their personal laws. There is never any talk on the same for the Hindu personal laws. It can be safely assumed that such a UCC will take into account the Hindu personal laws and be primarily derived from it.
 
.
All UCC talks about is that Muslims will have to abandon their personal laws. There is never any talk on the same for the Hindu personal laws. It can be safely assumed that such a UCC will take into account the Hindu personal laws and be primarily derived from it.

To erase and nullify the identity and will of the Muslim community are the final goals.

When their back is broken, then the genocides can begin.

@xeuss I don't know why brother @fitpOsitive created this inflammatory thread, but it is definitely in poor taste.

Indian Muslims are the primary victims of Hindutva. According to them, Muslims and Christians do not even belong in India.
 
.
All UCC talks about is that Muslims will have to abandon their personal laws. There is never any talk on the same for the Hindu personal laws. It can be safely assumed that such a UCC will take into account the Hindu personal laws and be primarily derived from it.

LOL.... what Hindu "personal law" do you object to and should be removed from the UCC ? :lol:
 
.
LOL.... what Hindu "personal law" do you object to and should be removed from the UCC ? :lol:

I personally have no objection to Hindus following their own religious laws and customs. All I object to is the constant vilification of Muslims and their personal laws by Sanghis like you. Hypocrisy knows no bounds when the Sanghis spend much of their breathing moments obsessing of Muslims and their laws, while ignoring their own personal laws and its existence.
 
.
I personally have no objection to Hindus following their own religious laws and customs. All I object to is the constant vilification of Muslims and their personal laws by Sanghis like you. Hypocrisy knows no bounds when the Sanghis spend much of their breathing moments obsessing of Muslims and their laws, while ignoring their own personal laws and its existence.

LOL .... its too late to wuss out now :lol:

You were the one claiming issues with the "Hindu laws". Now stand your ground and state your case.

Which "hindu law" is the problem ?

Then give your support to the UCC if you are in agreement :devil:
 
.
LOL .... its too late to wuss out now :lol:

You were the one claiming issues with the "Hindu laws". Now stand your ground and state your case.

Which "hindu law" is the problem ?

Then give your support to the UCC if you are in agreement :devil:

You obviously don't understand my position, and did not care to read my posts carefully. It is common among Sanghis, who lack basic comprehension skills.
 
.
You obviously don't understand my position, and did not care to read my posts carefully. It is common among Sanghis, who lack basic comprehension skills.

Yeah, we are idiots.
So, please explain to us. use as many words as you want pls. :chilli:
 
. .
You obviously don't understand my position, and did not care to read my posts carefully. It is common among Sanghis, who lack basic comprehension skills.

Now repeat with me.

I SUPPORT THE CAA and UCC.
 
.
Idiots will never understand, so it is no use wasting valuable bytes.

So, you are caught in your lies & all you have is abuse as way of explaining your point.
And some old farts here are obviously impressed with your Senile logic - makes sense since that old fart is completely senile anyway..
 
.
Didn't know that. Yes those who have migrated to tend to stick to their faith.

Yes. Future fights in South India would be primarily between Christians and Muslims. This is already happening in Kerala. Hindus are no longer significant in South India.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom