If Vietnam can beat China, so can India. This is not 1962.

[skylance]

there is one thing in the world called "Indian logic"

 

[Kai Liu]

I hear you. So why didn't China unleash it's war machines against India ?

It is our army's tradition and doctrine to not fire the first bullet, And will not allow the enemy to fire the second bullet. After all, this is just an intrusion at this moment, but still we have got tons of options besides war: we can step to their territory as well, and we can dam the river and cut off the water, and they can not do a shit about it, as we already dam a bunch of rivers, and they can just bark.. This is why we are just watching these clowns jumping up and down, but not using our war machines yet, and they already rush to beg us. Lol

 

[Zsari]

Sure? Read more
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cao_Bang_(1979)

Don't see how Vietnam can claim victory in that battle as the city was captured, albeit delayed. Its like Italy to claim victory in WWII for delaying the US/British invasion.

 

[cnleio]

If China can beat U.N Army in 1952 and beat India Army in 1962, why China can't beat again in 2017 ? This is not 1962 China ! The same logic from today China ... LOL

 

[dez01]

not only 1962, any year is not a excuse for invading your neighbor.

 

[VALKRYIE]

I read clear
Aftermath
Although the Chinese had eventually captured Cao Bằng from the Vietnamese 346th Division...??who is Cao Bằng?why write his name ,he is a very important man???(I'm curious) and this article not said Vietnam did not beat China..Not enough to refute “ Vietnam did not beat China. Before starting the war, China had told the world it would be a punishment war. No intention of occupying Vietnam's land. PLA didn't lose any battle before retreat. And the retreat was also scheduled.”

Cao Bằng is North East Province of Vietnam. A lot of ethnic minorities live there.

China lost to Vietnam in 1979. Everybody in the world knows this.

 

[xiao qi]

Don't see how Vietnam can claim victory in that battle as the city was captured, albeit delayed. Its like Italy to claim victory in WWII for delaying the US/British invasion.

In Cao Bang, the Chinese force ( more than 10 times Vietnamese about troops) couldnt defeat only one Vietnamese contruction unit division and militia. At least, In Lang Son Chinese could capture the Lang Son city. In Cao Bang, They gained nothing. Cao Bang at that time was only mountainous region and full of ethnic Vietnamese in there. Maybe You dont agree for this battle, ok, read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Mong_Cai

 

[Mugwop]

What a moronic logic

 

[Zsari]

In Cao Bang, the Chinese force ( more than 10 times Vietnamese about troops) couldnt defeat only one Vietnamese contruction unit division and militia. At least, In Lang Son Chinese could capture the Lang Son city. In Cao Bang, They gained nothing. Cao Bang at that time was only mountainous region and full of ethnic Vietnamese in there. Maybe You dont agree for this battle, ok, read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Mong_Cai

It stated in the very beginning that it's a diversionary attack.

 

[xiao qi]

It stated in the very beginning that it's a diversionary attack.

So, It is not a battle?

 

[Hulk]

If China attacks it will simply prove they are misfit to dictate the world order. While Chinese are thumping their chest they do not realise this is disaster of a move for China. There was some improvement done on relationship between India and China. Just this dispute has pushed it back considerably. Think of repurcussion of war. Its definitely going to Impact China's trade. It will become impossible for major Chinese companies to do business in India. Companies owned purely bu Chinese will suffer the most.

Plus if war really happen India should take the war to impact CPEC.

First there is no huge military unbalance between China and India. Look at the Global Firepower ranking...China is ranked third while India fourth on Global military power. Second...China has no real fighting experience...India has been fighting Pakistan everyday since last 40 year on the some of the highest mountains in the world and has success fought 4 full time war with Pakistan. Third...you are fighting not in planes but on mountains and in Jungles...India's mountain and Jungle warfare in the best in the world...even US comes to India to learn the war tactics on those areas...

In addition defending force needs way less resources. 1962 was also big failure because of Nehru and situation in Mod. Nehru use to feel threatened by military and did everything possible to keep the generals weak. The decision on war were take by Mod more than generals as I read somewhere. We did not allow to use air force. It will be different war this time.

 

[Daghalodi]

If China attacks it will simply prove they are misfit to dictate the world order. While Chinese are thumping their chest they do not realise this is disaster of a move for China. There was some improvement done on relationship between India and China. Just this dispute has pushed it back considerably. Think of repurcussion of war. Its definitely going to Impact China's trade. It will become impossible for major Chinese companies to do business in India. Companies owned purely bu Chinese will suffer the most.

Plus if war really happen India should take the war to impact CPEC.


In addition defending force needs way less resources. 1962 was also big failure because of Nehru and situation in Mod. Nehru use to feel threatened by military and did everything possible to keep the generals weak. The decision on war were take by Mod more than generals as I read somewhere. We did not allow to use air force. It will be different war this time.

 

[Irfan Baloch]

What a moronic logic

If Vietnam can beat China then so can India
if Vietnam can beat USA then so can India

 

[Hulk]

If china can not do anything except issuing warnings, It will prove that they are paper tigers. If they do any mischief, they will be beaten badly. CHina is in a big fix. Neither go this way or that way. Slowly, tiny countries also stop taking chinese warning seriously.

That's their bigger concern.

http://edition.cnn.com/2017/07/24/asia/china-india-border-standoff/index.html

Really desperate it seems....not a single Chinese visited India.. They come begging like dogs.

Begging like dogs. Is this the way you grew up.

 

[vikata]

an

India couldn't win a Samoa race

and pakistan can't even make samosa