What's new

If the Pakistan Navy succeeds in signing a MILGEM/-G deal with Turkey (STM hopes to ink a contract)

Major d1

BANNED
Joined
Jun 4, 2016
Messages
1,721
Reaction score
-2
Country
Bangladesh
Location
United Kingdom
If the Pakistan Navy succeeds in signing a MILGEM/-G deal with Turkey (STM hopes to ink a contract in 2017), what would be the chances of the Navy also buying the T-70 (i.e. Turkish S-70i)?

Relative to all other modern naval utility helicopters (besides the Harbin Z-9), the T-70 is the most affordable platform.

The Navy had requested 6 surplus SH-60s from the U.S., but it dropped the offer when the US refused to provide the FFG-7s.

The all-in unit cost of a S-70B is about $21m.

The all-in unit cost of a Leonardo AW-159 is $40-50m.

Moreover, the S-70, while an American design, benefits from an expansive third-party user base and distributed supply chain, second only, perhaps, to the Russian Mi-8/Mi-17. The massive commercial and civilian user base is helpful too.

In other words, if embargoed, it wouldn't be insanely difficult to keep operating the helicopter. Spare parts are available in a lot of places.

Turkey will also manufacture the Black Hawk in its entirety, including the turboshaft engines and transmission. TAI was even given export licenses for the purpose of getting Sikorsky into the door of countries with a "weaker" relationship with the U.S.

The TAI T-70 will assuredly be compatible with Western and, in the context of the MILGEM/-G, Turkish anti-surface and anti-submarine munitions. TAI will be sourcing the electronics from Aselsan.
 
This is what Turkey can offer for T-70 self protection suite.
jX12Gg.jpg
 
For PD, Turkey, China, Russia, Ukraine, Romania, Czech & Italy are the right choice. Although we are yet to see major deals with Russia but much has been offered by Russians to Pakistan.

Pakistan should completely shut its door on US & stick with its new partners for good. With the help of CPEC Pakistan will be offered a lot, just like Russia who has offered Pakistan defence hardware.
 
Pakistan must learn to live without US hardware what will make us to be wiser. Have we not left any respect for ourselves. US is a new partner of India and those hardware can be nothing more then a junk of metal without spare parts and those parts pipeline can be easily curtailed. Buyers are the kings not the suppliers so as long as we got the resources we can get the equivalent from elsewhere. so lets move on from those good old times of 80's and more recent drama of 8 F-16. Why limit ourselves when we are paying for it.
 
Pakistan must learn to live without US hardware what will make us to be wiser. Have we not left any respect for ourselves. US is a new partner of India and those hardware can be nothing more then a junk of metal without spare parts and those parts pipeline can be easily curtailed. Buyers are the kings not the suppliers so as long as we got the resources we can get the equivalent from elsewhere. so lets move on from those good old times of 80's and more recent drama of 8 F-16. Why limit ourselves when we are paying for it.
I think we should assess each case on its own merits. The Black Hawk helicopter, for example, is a very popular and widely used platform, so it benefits from many different suppliers (for parts at least) and even multiple production lines (e.g. the new one being built in Turkey). In case of sanctions, one might have an easier time finding Black Hawk parts than they would say NH-90. Also, the OP is saying that the Black Hawks would bought from Turkey as the T-70.
 
What I hope is that we sign deals on ToT basis whether we do with China, Turkey or anyone other nation for at least two reason one is economic and second embargoes and political turmoil.

We should sign the deals with those partners that are 100% open for ToT otherwise Pakistan's taxpayer's money isn't for waste.
 
Pakistan prefer China because defence equipment supply can t face any embargo or sanctions in the time of war. But Turkish equipment has many major parts from West and they always need third party permission to sell. Plus, pricing and embargo issues. Turkey should stay with NATO and learn much as possible.
 
Last edited:
Turkish National utility helo will be on air by 2018. National turbo-shaft engine (If It is succeeded) project will power up this helo !

 
Last edited:
Pakistan prefer China because defence equipment supply can t face any embargo or sanctions in the time of war. But Turkish equipment has many major parts from West and they always need third party permission to sell. Plus, pricing and embargo issues. Turkey should stay with NATO and learn much as possible.
Another reason, during the war time, india navy will block the arms replenishment from sea. except china, no other pakistan partner can repensih arms to pakistan.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom