If Bangladesh can become independent in 1971 then why not Kashmir?

[gayMo]

No; Pakistan doesnt want land - it wants to see Kashmir free. For many Pakistanis this is a personal issue - since a quarter of Punjab's population is Kashmiri and a massive segment of our elite/military/government (including Nawaz Sharif) are Kashmiris.

When you hear news of your kinsmen being killed in the streets, rape incidents, harassment and overall oppression; it turns into a personal issue.

We'll let the Kashmiris decide what they want to do.

I think your intentions are good but you underestimate what politics of countries want. IF India says today that the pre requisite for Kashmir to be handed over to Pak is to have all Kashmiris migrate to India Pak will jump at the offer else they would not have closed the doors on Indian Muslims to move to Pakistan.
Likewise on the killing, when babri masjid came down Pakistan sponsored Dawkins to bomb Mumbai. There was no kinsman killed at that time. It's the nature of Pakistan to destroy India.

 

[BanglaBhoot]

How about you worry about your own country and let us worry about ours??

The thing is you Indians spend so much time worrying and interfering in my country you can expect some pay back ...

 

[Jana Assassin]

The thing is you Indians spend so much time worrying and interfering in my country you can expect some pay back ...

Nope we dont.. The only thing that does concern us is the rise in number of illegal immigrants from bangladesh into India...

 

[PDF]

Kashmir will become independent. The question is not whether it can but when? Anyway we need to be patient and wait...
now let the Indians troll...

 

[Jana Assassin]

Kashmir will become independent. The question is not whether it can but when? Anyway we need to be patient and wait...
now let the Indians troll...

Sure you can wait for all your life....

 

[GuardianRED]

Azad Kashmir in Peace??

What is this then? (Skip to 04:22)

 

[BanglaBhoot]

Nope we dont.. The only thing that does concern us is the rise in number of illegal immigrants from bangladesh into India...

You obviously don't know what your country is doing in the neighborhood and how it interferes in everything.

 

[Nilgiri]

If Bangladesh can be independent, why not Chittagong Hills Tract....and why not Sylhet?

Lets be perfectly clear, you mess with the bull you get the horns (and its been known to rip challengers apart).....so best to keep it as fantasies and dreams!

 

[Jana Assassin]

I think it is you my friend who isn't aware of what is going on in the neighbourhood...

Bangladesh has a lot to worry about in the recent days but KASHMIR is not one of them so why dont you guys focus on the problems of your country ...

 

[AMCA]

The original inhabitants were driven away by means of violence at the behest of foreign interest and that is the reason behind what we see today. Get them back, rehabilitate them and once the order is set, the valley will restore peace.

Bangladesh was a complete foreign Land, 2500 Kms away from each other. It was taxed more and cared less. Bangladesh is a result of bad governance.

 

[idune]

View attachment 316997

Very heated discussion going on this very dangerous post on facebook.

On topic: Kashmir is absolutely nothing like Bangladesh....we have very different history and geography....Bangladesh was one of the key fighters for two nation theory...so India would not annex it in its wildest dream (to have it break apart again at a more violent cost)...Kashmir is in literally in the middle of India and Pakistan...both parties can exert equal military force in that land...Pakistan could not exercise a force anywhere near what India could in 71....and Kashmir is politically divided....it has significant support for joining Pakistan...support of joining India and support for Independence at the same time...Bangladesh didn't have that problem....most of us wanted Independence and we got it.

WRONG!
Anubis - first, you DO NOT represent opinion of Bangladeshis. You are hindu has allegiance towards india and not Bangladesh. Your comments proved it many times. So you are representing indian mantra and that's how it should be read.

How about you worry about your own country and let us worry about ours??

Problem is Kashmir is not india, it is indian occupied land by installing and using puppet king/regime. Just like india did in Sikkim, and now in Bangladesh. There is not an iota of credibility in indian claim over Kashmir, period. So, Bangladesh should assist Kashmiris and and any other places like Assam, Nagaland etc. in their quest for independence.

 

[cerberus]

WRONG!
Anubis - first, you DO NOT represent opinion of Bangladeshis. You are hindu has allegiance towards india and not Bangladesh. Your comments proved it many times. So you are representing indian mantra and that's how it should be read.


Problem is Kashmir is not india, it is indian occupied land by installing puppet king/regime. Just like india did in Sikkim, and now in Bangladesh.

What Really major is name of the major cities of Kashmir valley SRinagar ,Anathnag

Which oldest and religious shrine in Kashmir Amarnath which almost old as 300BCE Islam was never even born yet

Is Kashmiri pandits who are one ethnic people of valley not forced leave there ancestral land based on sectarianism of Sunni Muslims population of valley and there women and children not raped and slaughtered what if India supported them just like mukti bahini

India has 6000 year old connection with Kashmir and its culture which multi-ethinic not one Sect related

State of J&K also constitute ladakh Jammu & kargil.area which peaceful and each has it cultural diversity

Unlike Bangladesh which was deprived from local leadership sheikh mujib , Kashmir has always seen Cheif minister who is Kashmiri ethinic and local

Sheikh abdullah family's

Mufti family

Hurriyat was not even a political force in valley not any more

 

[Stephen Cohen]

In Kashmir what matters is what INDIA wants

India wants status quo in Kashmir -- end of story

 

[Finer]

Yes it's as quiet as Tibet. The fact that people are demonstrating shows the leniency of India. Otherwise see the plight of pandits in Kashmir .

Does that explain the genocide + oppression never mind already reputation of rape capital? Thank you. You can add 'plight of pandits' in the list as Kashmir under Indian army. Basically, Indian army didn't spare anyone, did it?

They are oppressed by religion they are oppressed by the way they think,kashmir was peaceful till 89,the year USSR left Afghanistan.
Pakistanies thought they can do waht americans did to ussr can be done by Pakistan to India and tried,thats when the people started getting oppressed.and they will remain oppressed till they see the truth.

Peaceful? If that was the case, then why people are revolting against Indian army? Indian lives on blaming Pakistan all the times instead of acknowledging their own messes they have created. Kashmir has been facing oppression for years. It didn't happen overnight as in 89. Kashmir was invaded against their wills a long time ago.

 

[Talwar e Pakistan]

KINSMEN huh?? Well after all it was your countrymen in East Pakistan.. remember how that turned out?

Bangladesh does not share ethnic links with Pakistan other than the Bangladeshi immigrants in Pakistan.

You should look up the definition of 'Kinsmen'.