Hunan: students beaten by military trainers in mass brawl

[BoQ77]

there's aggression from trainers.
there's also bad reaction from students.
Anything like they disagree the aggressive mental of the trainers ?

 

[shorver]

Let the brothers laughed this only shows that Chinese is an aggressive nation

 

[cnleio]

Let the brothers laughed this only shows that Chinese is an aggressive nation

Abuse is the abuse, "去他妈的" to those bad reservist trainers specially drinking wine during trainning time.

I wish local High school and local military office learn this lesson, i wish some reservists who abuse and beat students have good days in jail.

"去他妈的" to bad trainers.

 

[gambit]

What I see here is abuse and abuse gone too far. I also see people who have never been in the military but trying to act tough by talking tough about training.

Once over two weeks I trained the ROK Marines on SIGINT techniques against Osan and Kunsan air bases. Both American tenant forces. In return the ROK Marines showed me what it takes to be a Marine, ROK or American or British or whoever. Our mission was to record as much base EM emissions as possible over 12 hrs without being detected. It was in the winter and all of us, 10 ROK Marines and 2 USAF airmen, were buried in the snow outside the fence. I was told that if I have to empty my bladder, I had to do it while under cover in the snow. I had to use my body and the snow to mask all IR signature from the hot urine. So I pissed on myself. Everyone fantasize about being a badass sniper but no one know that while the sniper lies in wait over days for a single shot, he soiled himself over those days, if he ate/drank anything at all, but usually he does not eat and barely drink so that his human odor would not give him away. Army Rangers and Marine scouts routinely returned from the field reeked of human waste on themselves.

Beating trainees is sadistic. Nothing training about it. In the field, no one beats on you. It is only the elements and the load you carry that physically stresses you. Hazing tends to make the candidate resentful, not just towards his instructors but even towards the organization that he serves. The US military moved away from this yrs ago. Screaming and yelling insults are mental stresses and trainees, especially the ones trying for elite units, understand the need for mental conditioning. But even though they are tough men, they do not like being beaten for the pleasure of others, and they recognize sadism when they experience it.

So you guys go on admiring the Russians for being tough on their trainees and fantasize about the badass Spetsnaz. Just look at the sorry state of the Russian military and see how effective is that sadism.

 

[Aepsilons]

This is neither soldiery nor is this professional.

 

[BoQ77]

Students later vented their anger by smashing classroom doors and windows, cutting their hands and hurting themselves.

any terrible thing cause them did that ?

 

[Cossack25A1]

Maybe they believe in something similar to the "Spartan Way"

 

[NiceGuy]

What I see here is abuse and abuse gone too far. I also see people who have never been in the military but trying to act tough by talking tough about training.

Once over two weeks I trained the ROK Marines on SIGINT techniques against Osan and Kunsan air bases. Both American tenant forces. In return the ROK Marines showed me what it takes to be a Marine, ROK or American or British or whoever. Our mission was to record as much base EM emissions as possible over 12 hrs without being detected. It was in the winter and all of us, 10 ROK Marines and 2 USAF airmen, were buried in the snow outside the fence. I was told that if I have to empty my bladder, I had to do it while under cover in the snow. I had to use my body and the snow to mask all IR signature from the hot urine. So I pissed on myself. Everyone fantasize about being a badass sniper but no one know that while the sniper lies in wait over days for a single shot, he soiled himself over those days, if he ate/drank anything at all, but usually he does not eat and barely drink so that his human odor would not give him away. Army Rangers and Marine scouts routinely returned from the field reeked of human waste on themselves.

Beating trainees is sadistic. Nothing training about it. In the field, no one beats on you. It is only the elements and the load you carry that physically stresses you. Hazing tends to make the candidate resentful, not just towards his instructors but even towards the organization that he serves. The US military moved away from this yrs ago. Screaming and yelling insults are mental stresses and trainees, especially the ones trying for elite units, understand the need for mental conditioning. But even though they are tough men, they do not like being beaten for the pleasure of others, and they recognize sadism when they experience it.

So you guys go on admiring the Russians for being tough on their trainees and fantasize about the badass Spetsnaz. Just look at the sorry state of the Russian military and see how effective is that sadism.

I heard that during VN war, sometimes, US soldiers head-shot their own sergeant or killed him with grenade in battle field when he forced the soldiers to storm the Viet Cong's defenses, was that true ??

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

not surprised at all

getting verbally and physically abused over time makes you stronger
but them boys better start drinking some milk!! look like midgets compared to the bullys.

I dunno. it's probably common though just some hazing.
of course they don't dare move. move or fight back and you are going to some kicks to the head and ribs.

Russia does it as well.

It is astonishing from these videos more than the OP. It's horrible...

 

[BuddhaPalm]

At least they don't play with each other's peepee like the Japanese.

 

[BoQ77]

There's always cowards to hurt himself as attempt to move away from battlefield.
Vietnamese, US, Chinese, Russian ...

I heard commanders ever shot to cowards from Russian, Chinese stories.

But these students hurt themselves in peaceful phase as protest. It's so weird, I never heard before.