How Kashmir was stolen from Pakistan by Mountbatten

[Panjabi Tiger]

I find it extremely disturbing that India got no part of sindh . The 4 million sindhis of India lost their native state . Each state that was partitioned - Punjab , Bengal , Jammu & Kashmir has been divided between both Pakistan and india but India got no part of Sindh . India should have got atleast a small part of Sindh .

In your dreams lol

 

[Pakistanisage]

Mountbatten ki kya galti ? who asked you to send in your lashkars to grab kashmir by force ? thoda patience dikhaya hota to Raja Hari singh may have joined you only . Pakistan lost Kashmir due to complete lack of soft skills which they haven't learnt even after 65 years of indipendence .

Sir, the manipulations of Mountbatten preceeded the Lashkar attack by at least a year. Infact, had Mountbatten not manipulated the partition results against the unbiased logic and decision of Radcliffe, the Raja of Kashmir would not have gone to India as it would have made it difficult for India to attack. The attack came about because of the Injustice of the situation in 1948, more than a year later than the manipulations of Mountbatten.

Well going by your logic, Lahore and Karachi were non-Muslim majority cities, so they should have gone to India. Lahore had many Sikhs and also a sizeable number of Hindus, and Karachi was filled with Hindu Sindhi businessmen. You are providing only the half truths of the Radcliffe commision. India lost more in the Radcliffe commision than Pakistan.

You guys only got Lahore because otherwise you would not have had a major city in Pakistan. Karachi, your other major city, has been built by the Indian Mohajirs who migrated there post 1947.



Source: The Sunday Tribune - Spectrum

Pakistan got Lahore because this city was predominantly Muslim. Please check your facts.

 

[zip]

It is frightening to think what would have been the condition of kafirs ie pandits,buddists in islamic republic of pakistan if you got all the land .. In india kashmiris are less than 10% of our muslim population .. If more than 90% can live happily then kashmiri muslims should have no probs

 

[kumarkumar1867]

In your dreams lol

Yes just like dreams you have about kashmir. Only difference is we accept having sindh is impossible while you can understand that same goes with possibility of your dream

 

[Pakistanisage]

So Pakistani leaders were bad negotiators from day 1 it seems...

Let us just say, Pakistani leaders were Gentlemen and not as devious and immoral as the Indian ones.

Everybody knows about the affair Nehru was having with Mrs. Mountbatten ( a married woman).

 

[INDIC]

Pakistan got Lahore because this city was predominantly Muslim. Please check your facts.

Lahore was half Muslim-half Hindu-Sikh city and majority of the business in the city was owned by Hindus and Sikhs.

 

[neutral_person]

Sir, the manipulations of Mountbatten preceeded the Lashkar attack by at least a year. Infact, had Mountbatten not manipulated the partition results against the unbiased logic and decision of Radcliffe, the Raja of Kashmir would not have gone to India as it would have made it difficult for India to attack. The attack came about because of the Injustice of the situation in 1948, more than a year later than the manipulations of Mountbatten.

Pakistan got Lahore because this city was predominantly Muslim. Please check your facts.

Source? You guys really didnt know that Lahore and Karachi were Hindu/Sikh majority?

I just provided you a source of the Radcliffe commission that says that these cities were given because otherwise you would not have had a major city. The Radcliffe commission was responsible for doing national surveys and finding out which places had what religions, and they made the boundaries accordingly.

 

[lightoftruth]

wrong title it was never with Pakistan ,how can it be stolen?

 

[Pakistanisage]

They don't wish to join you guys . They want indipendence . check out the latest opinion polls

Maybe there is a small minority of kashmiris who may be ambivalent about joining Pakistan or may want to become an Independent country, but most want to be with Pakistan. However there is no ambivalence about leaving India amongst Kashmiris. Every Kashmiri who introduces himself/herself says they are from Kashmir. They NEVER introduce themselves as Indians. That should tell you something.

 

[NeutralCitizen]

Pakistani Kashmir has actually been worse off now suffering from energy and water problems the best option for pakistan is lease or sell off kashmir to china this is the only option unless they want it to go to India.

 

[zip]

What wonders you would have done to improve lives of kashmiri people if you had all of kashmir ?
We only saw those mushrooming terrorist camps in your part of kashmir ..or is it only for the land called kashmir ?

 

[neutral_person]

The kashmiris are ambivalent about joining Paksitan or becoming an Independent country. However there is no ambivalence about leaving India amongst Kashmiris. Every Kashmiri who introduces himself/herself says they are from Kashmir. They NEVER introduce themselves as Indians. That should tell you something.

You are never getting Kashmir. If you really want it, come get it. We are not giving it up until all 1.2 billion of us Indians are dead. This thread is pretty useless if its the usual thread of Pakistanis crying and whining about Kashmir.

 

[Pakistanisage]

Kashmir was never been pakistani territory.Pakis attacked it just to secure their water life line.
Its the jackass indian leaders who couldnt get their territory back ..
Bring modi.

Be careful what you ask for because you might get it....

Modi might make you lose few more states of India..

 

[NeutralCitizen]

What wonders you would have done to improve lives of kashmiri people if you had all of kashmir ?
We only pay those mushrooming terrorist camps in your part of kashmir ..or is it only for the land called kashmir ?

Kashmir is actually worse off now in pakistani control they suffer from water and energy problems.

 

[R-DB]

Be careful what you ask for because you might get it....

Modi might make you lose few more states of India..

i guarantee you for this..do u want written agreement? lol