What's new

Harvard studies Mumbai hotel staff heroics

Do you think a single professor decides what gets done at Harvard? You don't think that many other people decide whether students are taught a particular business study or whether a subject is of interest to the school?

Actually, a professor is solely responsible for what he teaches in his classes. As long as it stays within the general guidelines.

Since the most you could do was to mumble a humble oneliner quoting a select part, let me do the favour of posting the remaining part.

I addressed the relevant part. The rest of your post concerns the heroism during 26/11 which was never under doubt.

As for the mention of Pakistan then, absolutely, an anti-Pakistan agenda is not unexpected from a (Non-Resident) Indian.
 
.
As for the mention of Pakistan then, absolutely, an anti-Pakistan agenda is not unexpected from a (Non-Resident) Indian.

So you think the syllabi of the world's most reputed business school is formed by a single professor without any higher ups reviewing it, a panel discussing it and more importantly without significant interest from student bodies ?

We are talking about Harvard not a street corner university in Pakistan or for that matter India.

And no you did not address it, especially the part in which i explained why it is a fit case to be studied in a business school - how a business house inspires its employees with its ethics . - which every student who is a future CEO must learn.

And please dont whine (sorry for being blunt) - if you want educate a Pakistani to be the dean of Harvard and ask him to do a case study on how India produces terrorism in Pakistan. Till then live with this.
 
Last edited:
.
My point is that this choice is less about 26/11 and more about the professor's agenda. Once again, all professors have this tendency to push their agenda; it is not unique to Indians.

You have no idea about any agenda. His name is not enough to make an accusation.

As I mentioned, all professors push their agenda. In this case, the professor happens to be Indian, and you guys are reluctant to admit the obvious.

yeah man , all Indians have an agenda(why then can't Rajiv Shah?). If that is your starting point & you don't need any evidence to back that claim, then I guess we are on different tracks & therefore cannot have a meeting point. Prove an agenda & we will listen. His name is not proof!
 
.
I am using common sense, which always trumps political correctness.

Every individual is a product of his/her life experiences and background. Of course, they will affect the person's judgement.

Maybe agenda is a strong word. Subconcious leanings might be a more diplomatic phrase.

Fair enough!
In which case we can dismiss your opinion on this matter as a Pakistani who is a product of a particular background & has been subjected to endless horror stories about Indians & is therefore incapable of making a rational/legitimate point about India/Indians !
 
.
Having spent half my life living in hotels(my father is in hospitality).
It is really commendable how the hotel staff performed. Reflects upon the management. I have seen in first person not one but two hotel blast aftermath's and CCTV videos. And quite a few staff tend to panic, although they do try to protect the guests, they themselves are unaware of the Hotel's emergency exits and safety systems.

We have now started a training program for disaster management, which I think is foremost imperative for Hotels and schools.
Knowing what to do and when to do it can be the difference between life and death for your guests.
 
.
I think it is pertinent to mention here the work of the company head during the aftermath of the attack. I am reproducing a forward e-mail below and we can clearly see the kind of standards that the company sets when it comes to employee welfare.

What Ratan Tata did for the Mumbai Terrorist Attack Victims

Ratan Tata is the chairman of Indian Hotels who own the Taj Mahal Hotel Mumbai, which was the target of the terrorists on 26/11/08. Hotel President a 5 star property also belongs to Indian Hotels.

The following is really touching.

What Ratan Tata did for the Mumbai victims.... Don't miss!

SALUTE TO MR. RATAN TATA

A. The Tata Gesture

1. All category of employees including those who had completed even 1 day as casuals were treated on duty during the time the hotel was closed.

2. Relief and assistance to all those who were injured and killed

3. The relief and assistance was extended to all those who died at the railway station, surroundings including the Pav- Bhaji vendor and the pan shop owners.

4. During the time the hotel was closed, the salaries were sent by money order.

5. A psychiatric cell was established in collaboration with Tata Institute of Social Sciences to counsel those who needed such help.

6. The thoughts and anxieties going on people’s mind was constantly tracked and where needed psychological help provided.

7. Employee outreach centers were opened where all help, food, water, sanitation, first aid and counseling was provided. 1600 employees were covered by this facility.

8. Every employee was assigned to one mentor and it was that person’s responsibility to act as a “single window” clearance for any help that the person required.

9. Ratan Tata personally visited the families of all the 80 employees who in some manner – either through injury or getting killed – were affected.

10. The dependents of the employees were flown from outside Mumbai to Mumbai and taken care off in terms of ensuring mental assurance and peace. They were all accommodated in Hotel President for 3 weeks.

11. Ratan Tata himself asked the families and dependents – as to what they wanted him to do.

12. In a record time of 20 days, a new trust was created by the Tatas for the purpose of relief of employees.

13. What is unique is that even the other people, the railway employees, the police staff, the pedestrians who had nothing to do with Tatas were covered by compensation. Each one of them was provided subsistence allowance of Rs. 10K per month for all these people for 6 months.

14. A 4 year old granddaughter of a vendor got 4 bullets in her and only one was removed in the Government hospital. She was taken to Bombay hospital and several lacs were spent by the Tatas on her to fully recover her.

15. New hand carts were provided to several vendors who lost their carts.

16. Tata will take responsibility of life education of 46 children of the victims of the terror.

17. This was the most trying period in the life of the organization. Senior managers including Ratan Tata were visiting funeral to funeral over the 3 days that were most horrible.

18. The settlement for every deceased member ranged from Rs. 36 to 85 lacs [One lakh rupees tranlates to approx 2200 US $ ] in addition to the following benefits:

a. Full last salary for life for the family and dependents.

b. Complete responsibility of education of children and dependents – anywhere in the world.

c. Full Medical facility for the whole family and dependents for rest of their life.

d. All loans and advances were waived off – irrespective of the amount.

e. Counselor for life for each person



B. Epilogue

1. How was such passion created among the employees? How and why did they behave the way they did?

2. The organization is clear that it is not something that someone can take credit for. It is not some training and development that created such behaviour. If someone suggests that – everyone laughs

3. It has to do with the DNA of the organization, with the way Tata culture exists and above all with the situation that prevailed that time. The organization has always been telling that customers and guests are #1 priority

4. The hotel business was started by Jamshedji Tata when he was insulted in one of the British hotels and not allowed to stay there.

5. He created several institutions which later became icons of progress, culture and modernity. IISc is one such institute. He was told by the rulers that time that he can acquire land for IISc to the extent he could fence the same. He could afford fencing only 400 acres.

6. When the HR function hesitatingly made a very rich proposal to Ratan – he said – do you think we are doing enough?

7. The whole approach was that the organization would spend several hundred crore in re-building the property – why not spend equally on the employees who gave their life?

Unfortunately, This is not covered by any news channel!
 
.
I don't think the credibility is a problem. What others might question is whether this was something really required, and is perhaps being done to get attention on India and/or Pakistan. I don't know how often universities study stories of heroics, but I doubt it happens too often.

The case study is not about heroics. It's about offering the best service to one's customer's under even the toughest of circumstances.

I, though, won't be surprised if the reasoning just zings above your head.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom