What's new

H-1B visa: Congressman seeks to kill OPT work permit for foreign students

TheBlackCoat

FULL MEMBER
Joined
May 30, 2017
Messages
609
Reaction score
0
Country
India
Location
United States
H-1B visa: Congressman seeks to kill OPT work permit for foreign students
OPT, widespread in Bay Area, used as path to H-1B

By ETHAN BARON | ebaron@bayareanewsgroup.com | Bay Area News Group
PUBLISHED: June 14, 2019 at 12:32 p.m. | UPDATED: July 20, 2019 at 2:55 p.m.



CLICK HERE if you are having a problem viewing the photos or videos on a mobile device

An Arizona Congressman plans to introduce a bill to end a federal government program — widely used as a pathway to the H-1B visa — that lets foreign students and graduates of U.S. schools work in this country for up to three years.

Republican Paul Gosar expects to introduce to the House of Representatives within two weeks the “Fairness for High-Skilled Americans Act of 2019” to kill the Optional Practical Training program, his office said Friday.


siliconbeat-logo-tech-news-blog.png


The OPT program grew 400 percent in the decade after the government in 2008 boosted the amount of time students and graduates in science, technology and math fields could stay in the U.S. and work, Pew Research reported last year. San Jose and San Francisco are among the nation’s top destinations for graduates in the OPT program, Pew found. In recent years, the OPT program surpassed the H-1B as the largest source of new temporary immigrant workers deemed to be highly skilled, according to Pew.

Gosar’s proposed bill — first spotted by Bloomberg Law — would amend the Immigration and Nationality Act to ban work under the OPT or any successor program without an act of Congress. His office said he also plans to send to President Donald Trump, within two weeks, a letter asking him to eliminate the OPT via executive order.

The title of Gosar’s proposed bill is a response to a bill introduced in February from the other side of the aisle, Gosar’s office said. California Congresswoman Zoe Lofgren (D-San Jose) sponsored the “Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act of 2019,” which would scrap the per-country cap on employment-based immigrants and increase the per-country limit for family-sponsored immigrants.

The OPT essentially extends F-1 education visas for foreign college and university students so they can work during or after school. The program’s base-level permit lasts a year, but a “STEM extension” allows participants to spend an additional two years working in the U.S.


Pew found that between 2004 and 2016, almost 1.5 million foreign graduates of U.S. colleges and universities have been allowed to work under the OPT, with 53 percent specializing in STEM fields.

Growth of the OPT program slowed in 2017, Pew said in a different report. Though a record 276,500 foreign graduates received work permits under the OPT program that year, up from 257,100 in 2016, enrollment in the program grew by 8 percent in 2017, compared to 34 percent the year before, the largest decline in growth rate since 2004, Pew reported.

Congressman Gosar’s push to cut the OPT program follows furor over the H-1B. That visa, intended for jobs requiring specialized skills, is heavily relied upon by major Silicon Valley tech firms, which lobby for an increase to the annual 85,000 cap on new visas. But critics point to reported abuses by outsourcers and argue that the H-1B is used to supplant American workers and drive down wages with cheaper foreign labor.

The Trump administration has dramatically increased the denial rate for H-1B visa applications, with outsourcers placing foreign workers in U.S. jobs appearing to bear the brunt of the rejections. The administration has also promised to scrap a program that allows employment for H-4 visa-carrying spouses of H-1B workers on track for green cards.



https://www.mercurynews.com/2019/06...to-kill-opt-work-permit-for-foreign-students/
 
. . . . . . . .
I’m in favor of killing this and on top of this also work permit for spouses of H1-B visas. These Pajeets just smooch of the system like leeches.
That would be sex discrimination stopping women from working and allowing mostly men to work.
 
.
He’s already limited those coming in — but this student loop hole needs a look into.

Where did he (Trump) limit anything? He limited immigration (as in green card and citizenship) not H1-B. OPT will not be limited because US universities and corporates will be up in arms against such a decision. He is just a poor senator and won't be able to take on corporates. Like the article itself said, there is another bill before congress removing per country cap (benefitting Indians majorly), there is more chance of that going through than this. Lol.

Over 150000 indians study their masters at major universities making up majority of student populace in their STEM courses annually. Who would replace the loss to these programs? Would senator support them financially? What about corporates? Indians make up 40% of staff in all major IT companies. If any such measure is taken up, it'll only make these companies shift their major operations to Canada and have Indians employed there.

Indians on H1-B are infact net positive for America. They pay their taxes and social security never actually getting any benefit back unless they become citizens themselves. It takes close to 16-20 years for an average Indian to even get a green card. 20 years of paying into social security without any expectation. Do you think an American would do that?

But I hope America does take up such a law it would be easy for India to throw out their corporates out of India based on similar argument. I don't think they would. Since India and America are in a mutual beneficial relationship. Trump is too smart to rock the boat.
 
.
Where did he (Trump) limit anything? He limited immigration (as in green card and citizenship) not H1-B. OPT will not be limited because US universities and corporates will be up in arms against such a decision. He is just a poor senator and won't be able to take on corporates. Like the article itself said, there is another bill before congress removing per country cap (benefitting Indians majorly), there is more chance of that going through than this. Lol.

Over 150000 indians study their masters at major universities making up majority of student populace in their STEM courses annually. Who would replace the loss to these programs? Would senator support them financially? What about corporates? Indians make up 40% of staff in all major IT companies. If any such measure is taken up, it'll only make these companies shift their major operations to Canada and have Indians employed there.

Indians on H1-B are infact net positive for America. They pay their taxes and social security never actually getting any benefit back unless they become citizens themselves. It takes close to 16-20 years for an average Indian to even get a green card. 20 years of paying into social security without any expectation. Do you think an American would do that?

But I hope America does take up such a law it would be easy for India to throw out their corporates out of India based on similar argument. I don't think they would. Since India and America are in a mutual beneficial relationship. Trump is too smart to rock the boat.

Approvals for H1-B Visas in 2015 was approx 95% down to 80% at the moment. This crisis will accelerate the need to stop these H1-B (and students) due to unemployment levels reaching the The Great Recession range and on top of this the anger of average Americans that form the Trump base. On top of this new graduates will be needing jobs in the millions. Trump will have a huge job to put the average American back to work.
Sajid Tarrar, Mir Ali and Talat Rashid who I’ve known personally and are close clients of mines — already drafting a proposal to give to Trump re-election campaign in regards to this issue; as they did before.
But slowly the numbers will come down — average American doesn’t give two shits if they pay taxes or not.
 
.
But I hope America does take up such a law it would be easy for India to throw out their corporates out of India based on similar argument.

easy? What do you mean - easy? How many Indians are directly or indirectly employed by US businesses?
How will India find alternate employment for these people?
 
.
Approvals for H1-B Visas in 2015 was approx 95% down to 80% at the moment. This crisis will accelerate the need to stop these H1-B (and students) due to unemployment levels reaching the The Great Recession range and on top of this the anger of average Americans that form the Trump base. On top of this new graduates will be needing jobs in the millions. Trump will have a huge job to put the average American back to work.
Sajid Tarrar, Mir Ali and Talat Rashid who I’ve known personally and are close clients of mines — already drafting a proposal to give to Trump re-election campaign in regards to this issue; as they did before.
But slowly the numbers will come down — average American doesn’t give two shits if they pay taxes or not.
Please come back when any such bill is passed. I have lived in US for 6 years before returning to India. I have a brother who lived in US till 6 months ago who relocated to Canada (with PR) by his own company bearing all expenses with his US salary intact. That's how companies are coping with uncertain regulations. A lot of my friends are looking at Canada as an option. These are all US educated highly qualified professionals. US companies can seldom let them go.

And let your friends draft a proposal, it'll fall flat on their face. Lol.

H-1B visa card holders exempted from Trump's immigration ban

easy? What do you mean - easy? How many Indians are directly or indirectly employed by US businesses?
How will India find alternate employment for these people?
Lol. They are not here to provide employment to Indians by the way. Of course we can find alternate employment. India is a market, if we don't allow American companies doesn't mean market is going to vanish. There'll be other players some local and some from other countries.
 
Last edited:
.
US has declined due to China and India stealing our jobs.

Automation is a bigger threat than immigrants. Nobody cares about automation. How many jobs do you think immigrants take? 10%? 20%? Automation will wipe out at least 50%.

Immigrants pay taxes and robots don't. The anti-immigrant sentiment excuse is so old and its such a cheap cop out. If America didn't have immigrants, it would be China ruling the world right now.

If you don't want others to be able to immigrate, then neither should you. Want for others what you want for yourself.
 
. .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom