Gujarat riots not an issue that should keep Modi from becoming PM: Narayana Murthy

[Echo_419]

Shivraj Singh Chauhan was always there, as was Nitish Kumar. Naveen Patnaik isn't too bad either.

So what if our economy grows at 1-2% less, chances of events that we can't reconcile with even after 20-30 years of them occuring(like Babri Masjid demolition or 1984 riots) are what we must look to avoid at all costs henceforth.

Oh really 1-2% less what happens
Ya we gel from some 9+% to 5% so what
& regarding your constant modi bashing Do please tell me why there hasn't been a single riot in Guj since 2002

 

[bronxbull]

There are others who do what Modi does, but somewhat less controversially. So now at least you do agree that as long as someone who can give/heed to good advice is around, Modi is indeed expendable.

And I am saying what I expect my Government to do, is not turn a selective blind eye when riots are occuring!

Good advice is always there,everyone has a viewpoint.Our bureaucrats are amazing(not cause of my father,just giving a general opinion) but it is the political leader who convinces the masses of his policy implementation and that it is the right thing to do.

They fooled us for 44 years with licence raj and horrors of every kind,India learnt to fly after it got released from the cage of socialism,thats why today we see govt crowding out.

Even people Amartya Sen's intellectual fraud gets accounted,please dont under estimate the right wing.

 

[Indischer]

Oh really 1-2% less what happens
Ya we gel from some 9+% to 5% so what
& regarding your constant modi bashing Do please tell me why there hasn't been a single riot in Guj since 2002

Dude, Modi too has not guaranteed on a stamp paper that he'll ensure 9% growth. India's growth is firmly tied with the World economy's health nowadays, and things can go either way.

So, no riots since 2002 automatically absolves him of anything that happened before, is it?

I repeat, I have nothing against Modi, at least for now. I am merely saying that there are other equally good administrators with very clean image who must have been given a chance ahead of Modi as PM candidate.

 

[Indischer]

So now you are quoting articles by wanna be rapist Tarun Tejpal ?

For the record, Haren Pandya refused to come before the SIT and make any comments on the riots. LOL.

Worse still, Yasin Bhatkal is ON RECORD admitting that the IM was responsible for killing Haren Pandya. Who much more low can you fall. Take a look in the mirror. Yasin Bhatkal's confession is far greater proof than any politically motivated witch hunt against Modi.

LOL...One wannabe writing about another wannabe...Who are we to come in between?

Please post the link where Yasin Bhatkal has accepted IM's role in killing Pandya. Funny, earlier, it was Mr Sohrabuddin Sheikh who was similarly accused!

 

[Echo_419]

Dude, Modi too has not guaranteed on a stamp paper that he'll ensure 9% growth. India's growth is firmly tied with the World economy's health nowadays, and things can go either way.

So, no riots since 2002 automatically absolves him of anything that happened before, is it?

I repeat, I have nothing against Modi, at least for now. I am merely saying that there are other equally good administrators with very clean image who must have been given a chance ahead of Modi as PM candidate.

I ain't taking that Siht world economy health
Ok
So how do you explain lack of reforms
Billions of dollars stuck in infra project
Not to forget the corruption

 

[Indischer]

I ain't taking that Siht world economy health
Ok
So how do you explain lack of reforms
Billions of dollars stuck in infra project
Not to forget the corruption

Again, Modi has not made any promises on anything so far. We have to merely go by BJP's vision as expressed in it's manifesto. NDA at the National level has been just as good(or bad) as UPA-1(UPA-2 was horrendous, I concur). I have a problem with people whose very character is under doubt ocupying the highest office of our Land. BJP could just as easily have fielded Shivraj Singh Chauhan.

Anyways, the next 2-3 years will be enough to show you how much of all this was true and how much was bombast. If we're both around till then, we can have a chat again.

 

[Joe Shearer]

We have a recent example for this.
Mujaffarnagar roits in august this year. Now they won't blame SP just cause they are secular.

Don't be silly.

Everybody knows that the SP (and the BJP) were up to their elbows in this particular piece of mischief-making, and everybody is pissed off with them.

 

[Joe Shearer]

How can Mr Murty support Mr Modi so openly? Modi is untouchable & I demand Indian govt to take back Padma Vibhushan & Padma Shri from Narayan Murty..

If you were not being so ponderously sarcastic, I would have appreciated it. Narayan Murty was a singularly fortunate man, who was at the right place at the right time. Nothing more. His views on the governance of the country matter just as much as any other citizen's. Nothing more. Nothing less. His national awards have been awarded. There is no point in post-mortem examination.

@Indischer

Thank you for a most distinguished series of posts. I wish I had written them. I particularly enjoyed the exchanges with @abhishek, although I don't agree with his TINA position.

However, I wish you had not fed the troll.

 

[Fawkes]

Don't be silly.

Everybody knows that the SP (and the BJP) were up to their elbows in this particular piece of mischief-making, and everybody is pissed off with them.

You misunderstood my post. I was giving example for advityagrata' post it was like roits will happen if there is a situation, modi or no modi.
Anf fyi only bjp mla's are convicted for roits, and not sp.

 

[Abhishek_]

Thank you for a most distinguished series of posts. I wish I had written them. I particularly enjoyed the exchanges with @abhishek_, although I don't agree with his TINA position.

TINA position?

 

[Indischer]

Thank you for a most distinguished series of posts. I wish I had written them. I particularly enjoyed the exchanges with @abhishek, although I don't agree with his TINA position.

However, I wish you had not fed the troll.

Thanks Joe. Just doing my bit to look 'anti National' and 'sickular'.

I often used to look back at events preceding WW2 and wonder on how could some men fool entire Nations...fortunate enough to get a good demo in my own country now.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Mr Genius, heard of Haren Pandya? The man was an RSS cadre and BJP legislator who publicly spilled out Modi's role and complicity in the riots to the ‘Citizens tribunal’ headed by retired Justice Krishna Ayer and Justice P.B.Sawant. He was murdered soon after in March 2003. Silencing whistle-blowers is definitely one way to escape conviction!

Tehelka - India's Independent Weekly News Magazine



I believe you will have no problems in accepting that Jagdish Tytler too is innocent. Just a problem though, the riots DID occur under their respective watch and hundreds DID die. Though Tytler has at least apologised to save his a$$, Mr Modi hasn't even done that. A man who is so arrogant that 1200 deaths under his watch isn't even something to be sorry about, will no doubt lead our Nation to new highs!

So now you have started quoting Tehelka(India's Independent Weekly News Magazine! ) about a 'Citizen's Tribunal' and consider Tytler better. Enough said. We know where we stand and let's leave it at that.

 

[Android]

Who the fck says its an issue in the first place???

 

[Joe Shearer]

You misunderstood my post. I was giving example for advityagrata' post it was like roits will happen if there is a situation, modi or no modi.
Anf fyi only bjp mla's are convicted for roits, and not sp.

Oops.

You are right, and I feel like an idoit.

BTW, what happened to your spell-checker? :-D

TINA position?

//To be uttered in tones of great gloom//

There Is No Alternative.

 

[Indischer]

So now you have started quoting Tehelka(India's Independent Weekly News Magazine! ) about a 'Citizen's Tribunal' and consider Tytler better. Enough said. We know where we stand and let's leave it at that.

I have no issues with you rejecting whatever Tehelka has written. Their brand of investigative journalism is respected by many though. I also request you to be just as unscrupulous while reading articles that praise Modiji.
I merely highlighted the similarity in their misdeeds and the differences in their approach to reconcile with what they've done. If you consider Tytler became a better person by asking an apology, so be it.