Girl killed in Pakistani-administered Kashmir acid attack

[Edevelop]

I don't see the problem with Mirpuris; .

Do you know what the word Kashmir originally means? Let me make this clear. Mirpuris are not from the Valley and on top of that they speak a different language called Potwhari, which is more closer to Punjabi. Don't agree with me what race they are? Look up what castes they belong to...

 

[rubyjackass]

Oh really?
Here is a picture of my ancestor on the far right. Maqbool on the left And yes i posted this on the internet in wikipedia...

Oh yeah?! What is his name then?

 

[Edevelop]

Oh yeah?! What is his name then?

Mir Mannan (not shown here). The other's name was Mir Qayyum (shown here)

 

[Kashmiri Nationalist]

Do you know what the word Kashmir originally means? Let me make this clear. Mirpuris are not from the Valley and on top of that they speak a different language called Potwhari, which is more closer to Punjabi. Don't agree with me what race they are? Look up what castes they belong to...

Feel free to create a separate thread and I'll be more than happy to discuss this with you, in the meantime, let's not deviate from the topic.

 

[RazPaK]

Do it CB4!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Abingdonboy]

 

[rubyjackass]

Mir Mannan (not shown here). The other's name was Mir Qayyum (shown here)

Good to know buddy. He(Mir Qayyum) has history with Butt and JKLF.

 

[S_O_C_O_M]

 

[Armstrong]

Also, I don't see what the big issue here is; I didn't say Bhutt's aren't Kashmiri, they're Kashmiri as long as they classify themselves as such. If you tell me you're Pakistani, then you're Pakistani. Pretty simple.

What a load of BS is that ? Just because we, the ethnic Kashmiris of Pakistan, identify with Pakitan that somehow changes my ethnic identity ? And who in God's good name are you to be handing out certificates of 'Kashmiriyat' classifying a person either as one or not !

I am an ethnic Kashmiri Butt, a Punjabi & a Pakistani ! Pretty simple.

 

[Kashmiri Nationalist]

What a load of BS is that ? Just because we, the ethnic Kashmiris of Pakistan, identify with Pakitan that somehow changes my ethnic identity ? And who in God's good name are you to be handing out certificates of 'Kashmiriyat' classifying a person either as one or not !

I am an ethnic Kashmiri Butt, a Punjabi & a Pakistani ! Pretty simple.

Then that's what you are. I didn't say Bhuts weren't Kashmiri; I'm of the view when you disregard your culture, heritage and no longer classify yourself, even at the minimum level as it, then you're no longer part of that race/ethnic group/culture.

I am vehemently against any sectarianism in Kashmir -- I believe in the unity of all, regardless of ethnicity, class or religion. These are all tools of tyrants, whether they be our own (Maharaja), Indian, or outsiders (i.e., British 'divide and conquer' strategy, religious extremists etc.).

 

[Kashmiri Nationalist]

What the **** are these biased corporate retards talking about? This was nowhere near the "tribal areas" and it wasn't an act of religion, isolated cult or other wise; it's an isolated, shameful incident as has been pointed out being the first of its kind. TYT just lost the basis respect I have for most media institutions, it's not religion at fault as they so like to claim, it's people being backward with hate and envy -- how many Christians have shot up cinema theatres?

 

[Kashmiri Nationalist]

I feel sorry for the young children the most. Both of these inhumane bastards should be hanged.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

Do you know what the word Kashmir originally means? Let me make this clear. Mirpuris are not from the Valley and on top of that they speak a different language called Potwhari, which is more closer to Punjabi. Don't agree with me what race they are? Look up what castes they belong to...

Correct . Kashmiris are people from the Kashmir valley.

People from Azad Kashmir are not Kashmiris, They are similar to Punjabis and Jammuites. The name itself is incorrect .

What a load of BS is that ? Just because we, the ethnic Kashmiris of Pakistan, identify with Pakitan that somehow changes my ethnic identity ? And who in God's good name are you to be handing out certificates of 'Kashmiriyat' classifying a person either as one or not !

I am an ethnic Kashmiri Butt, a Punjabi & a Pakistani ! Pretty simple.

Is it possible to be Kashmiri and Punjabi both? How ?

 

[Areesh]

^^^

Your post is amusing. When a Kashmiri(nationalist Kashmiri) might blow your head off for this post, a Pakistani gilgiti or balti might love your post.

 

[Kashmiri Nationalist]

Correct . Kashmiris are people from the Kashmir valley.

People from Azad Kashmir are not Kashmiris, They are similar to Punjabis and Jammuites. The name itself is incorrect .

There is nothing ethnically, or racially classed as Indian, nor Pakistani. Since Indian Punjabis share a cultural similarity with those in the bigger Pakistani Punjab, I guess they should secede to Pakistani Punjab? Or -- and I'm sure I'll receive a lot of flak from Pakistanis for this -- if 60% of Pakistanis are Punjabis, then how are Pakistani Pushtuns Pakistani?

The name 'Kashmir' derives from the name of the primary ethnic group in the valley -- 'Kashurs' -- India's name derives from the river Indus, in Northern Pakistan; so by that account, I guess only Northern Indians are truly Indian, no?

Is it possible to be Kashmiri and Punjabi both? How ?

How can one by Punjabi and Indian? I guess, by your logic, since people in Arunchal Pradesh have oriental facial features, they're Chinese? Oh wait, doesn't India pride itself on secularism -- that all are 'Indian' regardless of ethnicity, class or colour of skin? The great hypocrisy.

If Armstrong identifies himself as a Kashmiri from Punjab, and as a Pakistani national; then that it is his choice, and I support him. It's not your place to question whether we are Kashmiri, Pakistani, Chinese, Indian, Martian or British -- Indian boots on the ground doesn't mean you can impose the boot in our minds.