What's new

Friend or Foe: Indian army kills its own

Windjammer

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Nov 9, 2009
Messages
41,319
Reaction score
181
Country
Pakistan
Location
United Kingdom
NEW DELHI: Last summer, a 42 Rashtriya Rifles patrol walked into a pre-dawn ambush prepared for militants by soldiers of the same unit close to the Line of Control in Pulwama district, Kashmir. Mistaking each other for insurgents, both groups opened fire, killing two of their own comrades instantly and injured three seriously.
The Indian Army, which has been engaged in counter-terrorism operations for the last 25 years, is fighting militants literally in the dark lacking the ability to recognise ‘friend or foe’. Recognising the need to prevent such incidents, the Army proposes to give smart vests to soldiers to prevent friendly fire casualties; 2019 is the deadline. An internal report of the Directorate General of Infantry admits to this flaw, causing ‘fratricide’.

Indian soldiers are being killed by friendly fire in regions where they are fighting militants in counter-terror ops. Last month, a BSF constable was shot by jawans of 46 Rashtriya Rifles, who mistook him for a terrorist attacking their camp in Baramulla. In another incident, troops from 35 RR and an elite Special Force unit came face to face in Sophian, but thankfully no casualties happened.

To prevent deaths from friendly fire, the Army will develop a smart vest with built-in codes and GPS to auto-identify its troops, who often encounter each other in hostile situations. “At present, the Army has no equipment to identify friend from foe. Ad hoc measures are not fool-proof and chances of error resulting in fratricide are many,” a Directorate General of Infantry report stated.
Military strategists believe that in a departure from traditional tactics, the new breed of militants is donning Army uniforms. This has made it difficult for both villagers and Army personnel to distinguish between them and genuine soldiers. Earlier, terrorists wore civilian clothes to blend with the population in Kashmir. The new militants even know the call signs of units involved in operations.

“As the Army is involved in counter-insurgency operations over the last two-and-a-half decades, rapid identification and engagement of terrorists are crucial to prevent casualties,” the report further stated, adding that since terrorists have started using combat outfits, it is difficult to immediately tell him apart from a regular soldier, especially in poor weather conditions.

Notwithstanding, thousands of friendly fire incidents in recorded military history, accounting for an estimated 2 per cent to 20 per cent of all casualties in battle or counter-terrorism ops, no major army has an infallible mechanism to address the critical issue. Neither does the world’s third largest army. The Army report points out, “Using local tools like a piece of white cloth on helmet or torch light etc are prone to errors and may result in killing of own soldiers.”
Officials believe that such incidents happen from lack of coordination and adequate communication. Recently, the Army has started to equip its soldiers with wireless radios to improve communication between units to avoid such incidents.
http://www.newindianexpress.com/the...or-foe-indian-army-kills-its-own-1574762.html
 
. .
It is always good to discuss the draw backs of your own armed forces, as it allows you to correct yourself.... Better to look inwards and work on the draw backs rather than looking for similar weakness of your adversaries.....
Neither can you do anything for the Indian armed forces neither can my voice reach the power corridors of our HQs so let's just discuss the topic as arm chair generals.
 
.
It is always good to discuss the draw backs of your own armed forces, as it allows you to correct yourself.... Better to look inwards and work on the draw backs rather than looking for similar weakness of your adversaries.....
when did you ever discuss drawbacks of our arms forces.. thats just does not happen... same with other nationalities.
anyway on topic, one can understand the confusion, we got army, bsf, crpf and god know which other force operating there..
 
.
Neither can you do anything for the Indian armed forces neither can my voice reach the power corridors of our HQs so let's just discuss the topic as arm chair generals.

Well the very idea of a forum like this is to discuss.... How much it affects the respective militaries is anybodies guess.....

Edit: Discussion doesnt mean PDF alone...... In internal circles which has its affect on our govt....
 
Last edited:
.
Such incident happens when multipal forces from different units working very closely even they most adavanc force "technically" kills their own allies many times in Afghanistan.
 
.
when did you ever discuss drawbacks of our arms forces.. thats just does not happen... same with other nationalities.

Ultra nationlists which we all are....

on topic, one can understand the confusion, we got army, bsf, crpf and god know which other force operating there..
Add the terrain, and lack of coordination among the forces.....
 
.
Well the very idea of a forum like this is to discuss.... How much it affects the respective militaries is anybodies guess.....
No certainly no but would improve kniwledge oh youngsters about the dificulties arned forces face.
 
.
when did you ever discuss drawbacks of our arms forces.. thats just does not happen... same with other nationalities.
anyway on topic, one can understand the confusion, we got army, bsf, crpf and god know which other force operating there..

True my Muslim brother.
 
.
The events like above hard to avoide especially in counter insurgency what we need to put all forces operating in these areas under one centeral command whi sanctioned operation to each force only this way we can avoide accidental friendly fire.
 
Last edited:
. .
Reminds Me of this incident:
Friendly fire killed 13 Pakistani soldiers: Lieutenant General Malik

Troop deaths earlier blamed on militants were actually caused by friendly fire, commander says.

 
. .
Reminds Me of this incident:
I could give you even better figures on the Indian army, however let me ask you, do you remember how many fake IDs you have adopted this month alone, that's your reality and credibility.
@Areesh , your bunny is back with another fake ID.
 
.
I could give you even better figures on the Indian army, however let me ask you, do you remember how many fake IDs you have adopted this month alone, that's your reality and credibility.
@Areesh , your bunny is back with another fake ID.

Abhi dheel daitai hain. Baad main kaatain gai. :D
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom