What's new

Freakonomics on India

So far is rural development of India is concerned...an example of achievement.....


India to brief G-20 on its successful NREG scheme
Top officials from the US Department of Labour, organisers of the event, said the innovative 100-day rural employment guarantee scheme has been successful beyond the expectations of almost every one. "India has learnt and has refined the strategy. So there is a great deal of anticipation to hear from Minister Kharge about these policies, how they have worked, and are there lessons that are transferable to other countries at low and middle income levels," Deputy Under Secretary for International Affairs Sandra Polaski told foreign journalists.

"The employment minister from India, who is attending the conference, has been asked to speak about that as one of the key innovations that India has made, a policy which has been challenging to implement but at the end of the day very successful. I think successful beyond the expectations of almost everyone," Polaski told reporters. Labour and employment ministers from top 20 economies of the world are scheduled to attend the conference being convened at the instance of President Barack Obama. Recommendations of the conference would be submitted to the next G-20 Summit meeting in Toronto later this year.

"This meeting, as you know, comes at a time of tremendous challenge for workers in the G-20 countries. The prompt actions of many of our governments last year prevented a true global depression. The ILO, estimates that 20 million jobs were saved or created by collective stimulus plans and our social safety nets in 2009 and 2010," US Labour Secretary Hilda Solis said. The unemployment rates were still high, unacceptable in the US and across the globe, she said, adding there was the need for creating more jobs.

"I will take up this mandate, along with the other G-20 ministers, with the hope to accomplish two main goals. The first is to prepare a set of recommendations for measures that countries should consider in order to tackle the job crisis," she said. It would help to set the stage for a sustainable balanced recovery that would create good jobs for all those who want to work or are underemployed, the secretary added.

"The second goal is to develop an understanding among the ministers of the range of labour market conditions and challenges faced by the G-20 countries in order to build a foundation for future discussion and cooperation, so we can in fact learn from each other's experiences," Solis said.

Recommendations and strategies would allow greater progress on employment in each of the countries and at the global level, she said, adding this was a historic opportunity to come up with a concrete set of recommendations. While all the countries are to be represented by their Labour and Employment Ministers, those from France, Germany, Britain and the European Commission were unable to attend because of the current air-travel disturbances.

"However all of the countries that are not able to make it either had already sent senior officials who were in place, vice-ministers or under-secretaries who carry the relevant portfolios. And in other cases, they are sending their ambassadors to the US to represent the country," Polaski said. It was a meeting for the ministers to discuss, among other topics, how they can be sure that the crisis does not lead to a lowering of working conditions and how it does not lead to violations of labour laws, she added.


Source

This is going to be yet another success story of India.We,Indians believe in letting our actions speak....
The old man is doing a great job though,showing concern for Indians while his own country is in fire..Anyways I cant help thinking that his concern goes a bit too far...
As for Mr.Riaz Haq,I have a quote for him...

"A great many people think they are thinking when they are merely rearranging their prejudices."--
--William James

I think NREGA is a good idea but the jury is still out on its success.

It might just turn out to be too little too late, given the depth and breadth of rural poverty in India.

India now has 100 million more people living below the poverty line than in 2004, according to official estimates released recently, according to Reuters.

100 million more Indians now living in poverty | Top News | Reuters

The poverty rate has risen to 37.2 percent of the population from 27.5 percent in 2004, a change that will require the Congress-ruled government to spend more money on the poor.

The new estimate comes weeks after Sonia Gandhi, head of the Congress party, asked the government to revise a Food Security Bill to include more women, children and destitutes.

"The Planning Commission has accepted the report on poverty figures," Abhijit Sen, a member of the Planning Commission told Reuters, referring to the new poverty estimate report submitted by a government panel last December.

India now has 410 million people living below the U.N. estimated poverty line of $1.25 a day, 100 million more than was estimated earlier, officials said.

India calculates how much of its population is living below the poverty line by checking whether families can afford one square meal a day that meets minimum nutrition needs.

Farmer suicides are just the tip of the iceberg. Last year, 1500 farmers took their own lives in a mass suicide in the state of Chattisgarh, according to media reports. Over 200,000 farmers suicides have been reported in India in the last ten years.

Chowk: Personal: Indian Farmer Suicides, Hunger Deaths Fuel Rural Insurgency
 
I think NREGA is a good idea but the jury is still out on its success.

It might just turn out to be too little too late, given the depth and breadth of rural poverty in India.
It might not be...I posted some sources in relation to this.

India now has 100 million more people living below the poverty line than in 2004, according to official estimates released recently, according to Reuters.

100 million more Indians now living in poverty | Top News | Reuters

The poverty rate has risen to 37.2 percent of the population from 27.5 percent in 2004, a change that will require the Congress-ruled government to spend more money on the poor.

The new estimate comes weeks after Sonia Gandhi, head of the Congress party, asked the government to revise a Food Security Bill to include more women, children and destitutes.

"The Planning Commission has accepted the report on poverty figures," Abhijit Sen, a member of the Planning Commission told Reuters, referring to the new poverty estimate report submitted by a government panel last December.

India now has 410 million people living below the U.N. estimated poverty line of $1.25 a day, 100 million more than was estimated earlier, officials said.

India calculates how much of its population is living below the poverty line by checking whether families can afford one square meal a day that meets minimum nutrition needs.

Farmer suicides are just the tip of the iceberg. Last year, 1500 farmers took their own lives in a mass suicide in the state of Chattisgarh, according to media reports. Over 200,000 farmers suicides have been reported in India in the last ten years.

Chowk: Personal: Indian Farmer Suicides, Hunger Deaths Fuel Rural Insurgency
The first and foremost thing necessary for development is proper idea about the real scenario and not being in the state of denial.The reality is quite grave,which must be accepted.But,the situation is changing rapidly.We have seen massive infrastructure development in the recent years.A massive amount of 40100 crores INR was allocated for NREGA.The money will be used to provide employment to the unemployed and in turn using the workforce for rural infrastructure development..In total,around 5.25 crore people have been provided employment by the scheme.Developmental work includes various fields-Rural connectivity,Flood control and protection,water conservation,micro irrigation,Land development,renovation etc...

Information about NREGA can be found from this site::

NREGA

Details about NREGA

Though the system has not been as successful as it was expected to be,still it has done a pretty good job so far,and I expect this trend will be intact in the future..

The situation may entirely change with the entry of private players into the scenario.Many companies of India have their own policies aiding in rural development.But,things may happen in a bigger and more organized fashion...
India Inc to lend help in rural uplift
NEW DELHI, May 11, DH News Service:

The India Inc bandwagon is keen to join hands with the government to improve amenities in rural areas to city standards.

The Union Ministry for Rural Development’s plan is to invite the corporate sector under the PPP (public private partnership) model for Provision of Urban Amenities in Rural Areas (PURA), the dream scheme of former President A P J Abdul Kalam.

Though the “expression of interest” was invited for just 10 pilot projects, over 95 companies, from both public and private domain like Tata, Jindal, IDFC, NEPC, IL&FS, IVRCL Infrastructure and Reliance Energy, have applied for bidding.

As per the guidelines, the government will allow a company to select a cluster of villages, each having 25,000 to 40,000 population.

The company then has to submit a master plan to improve the villages, including instituting water and sewerage facilities, maintenance of streets and solid waste management projects.

The selected company will get 35 per cent of the total funds to improve a village from the Centre, and it will have to pump in the rest of the money. As per the ministry’s preliminary estimation, the average investment for each project may be Rs 100 crore.

The concession period, during which the company will run the villages, will be 13 years, including the three-year construction period. During the period, the company, apart from maintaining the facilities, will be allowed to collect user fee for its services at a government-fixed rate. The companies can also build cold storage, set up mini power plant using agricultural waste, rural tourism, rural market and skill development training centres, Sinha added.

“Before signing the MoU, the company has to take the approval from the state government as well as local panchayat,” B K Sinha, secretary, Ministry of Rural Development told Deccan Herald. Initially, 10 village clusters will be selected under the pilot project.
 
Some highlights from the latest Superfreakonomics text:

A baby Indian girl who does grow into adulthood [i.e., who doesn't fall prey to selective abortion or infanticide] faces inequality at nearly every turn. She will earn less money than a man, receive worse health care and less education, and perhaps be subjected to daily atrocities. In a national health survey, 51 percent of Indian men said that wife-beating is justified under certain circumstances; more surprisingly, 54 percent of women agreed — if, for instance, a wife burns dinner or leaves the house without permission.

And:

Unfortunately, most [government and non-government aid] projects have proven complicated, costly, and, at best, nominally successful. A different sort of intervention, meanwhile, does seem to have helped. … It was called television.

And:

Rural Indian families who got cable TV began to have a lower birthrate than families without TV. (In a country like India, a lower birthrate generally means more autonomy for women and fewer health risks.) Families with TV were also more likely to keep their daughters in school, which suggests that girls were seen as more valuable, or at least deserving of equal treatment. (The enrollment rate for boys, notably, didn’t change.) … It appears that cable TV really did empower the women of rural India, even to the point of no longer tolerating domestic abuse. Or maybe their husbands were just too busy watching cricket.

Introducing the SuperFreakonomics Virtual Book Club: Meet Emily Oster - Freakonomics Blog - NYTimes.com
 
Here's a PRB report that conflicts with Jensen and Oster:

A new study in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences reports on a sex ratio that favors boys among U.S.-born children in Indian, Korean, and Chinese families. Using the 1990 and 2000 decennial censuses, the study found that the ratio of male to female births is much higher if the first child is a girl and even higher, by as much as 50 percent, if the first two children are girls. The normal ratio of males to females at birth is 1.05:1. However, if the first child is a girl, the ratio increases to 1.17:1, and if the first and second children are girls, the ratio increases more dramatically to 1.51:1 in favor of boys. The authors note that this is not evident with white parents and that the trend among the base group was not evident in the 1990 census.

The phenomenon is not unique to Asian immigrants in North America. In 2007, an Oxford University study suggested a similar phenomenon among Indian-born mothers in both England and Wales. It found that the proportion of male to female newborns increased from 103 male births per 100 female births in the 1970s to 114.4 by the end of 2005.

The authors expect the sex ratio to move upward given the recent surge in immigration from Southeast Asia and the availability of new technology that makes sex determination possible within the first five weeks of pregnancy. New reproductive technologies used for sex selection such as embryo screening, sperm sorting, and blood tests have been marketed to Indian expatriates in the United States and Canada in recent publications such as India Abroad and The Indian Express.

Given the small size of the Asian-born population relative to the total U.S. population, the practice is unlikely to have major consequences on the national sex ratio at birth in the short term. However, the implication of such practices might have a profound effect beyond U.S. borders. Since 1994, laws have been in enacted in India banning the use of embryo screening, sperm sorting, and other methods for sex selection, although these are not always strictly enforced. Canada, the UK, China, and the Council of Europe's Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine have all outlawed and condemned any type of sex selection method. However, the U.S. fertility industry remains largely unregulated and American Society of Reproductive Medicine recommendations on the ethical use of the technology are largely ignored by practitioners.

Sex Ratio at Birth Deteriorating Among Asian Immigrants in the United States - Population Reference Bureau
 
The PRB report does conflict with Jensen and Oster to the extent of selective abortions and son preference which appear to cut across all castes and classes in India and China.

The situation is particularly alarming among upper-caste Hindus in some of the urban areas of Punjab, Rajasthan, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, specially in parts of Punjab, where there are only 300 girls for every 1,000 boys, according to Laura Turquet, ActionAid's women's rights policy official.

The Indian diaspora is not immune from the cultural bias against female children, either. The male-female ratios of British Indians are also getting increasingly skewed in favor of male children. Since the 1970s, the at-birth male-female ratio of British Indians has dramatically change from 103:100 to 114.4:100, excluding the birth of the first or the second child.

Haq's Musings: Female Genocide Unfolding in India
 
India now has 410 million people living below the U.N. estimated poverty line of $1.25 a day, 100 million more than was estimated earlier, officials said.
India calculates how much of its population is living below the poverty line by checking whether families can afford one square meal a day that meets minimum nutrition needs.
I dont know how they are calculating the income.
According to the records in my ration card our house hold income per month is Rs 300. That means just $0.22 per day. I guess expect Gov employees 80% of the people will never reveal their proper income to the Gov for fear of income tax problem and all.. and to get max gov benefits people use to show their income very low..
 
Development is an on going process.While there are many impediments to it,be rest assured that progressive changes are being made day by day..

A little insight....
Lighting up their lives
N. Madhavan
March 3, 2010

"Our days have become longer. Earlier, we slept soon after sunset. Now, we remain awake till 10.30 p.m."
—Moopan Raghavan, Thalikakal settlement, Palakkad district.

"We're happy we can watch TV now. But there is a problem. Kids don't sleep at 7 p.m. anymore. They watch TV late into the night"
—Lakshmi, Moolaganga settlement, Palakkad district.

Before you start wondering what Raghavan and Lakshmi are talking about, these are reactions from the beneficiaries of an innovative project in Kerala that has, for the first time, brought electricity to people (mostly tribals) in far-flung areas of Palakkad district. Conceptualised on January 1, 2009, the total electrification project sought to make electricity available at the door step of all residents of the district.

What is novel about the project is the manner in which it was implemented — 91 gram panchayats, 13 block panchayats, one district panchayat, four municipalities, 11 MLAs, two MPs and the Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) came together and chipped in with money to fund it. In fact, but for the cooperative initiative, this project would not have been possible. Consider this: Thalikakal and Kadapara are two tribal settlements with a total of 63 families, located deep in the mountains some 70 km south of Palakkad, the district headquarters.

To bring electricity to these settlements as part of the total electrification project, distribution lines were laid from Ponkandam (the nearest electrified town) to Thalikakal over a distance of 10 km at a cost of Rs 65 lakh. On its own, KSEB could not have connected these settlements for two reasons—investing that amount of money for supplying electricity to 63 families who come under the non-paying group (in Kerala power consumption up to 20 units every month is free) was just not feasible. In fact, a project to supply power to Thalikakal was drawn up as early as 1980, but remained on paper as it was not found viable. Also, according to KSEB rules, the power utility cannot provide supply connections to houses that are more than 235 metres from the existing distribution line unless the consumers who want electricity are willing to pay the cost of extending the line. There was no way the tribals could raise such funds.
Similarly, KSEB could never have spent over Rs 1 crore to connect Vachchapati and Moolaganga settlements in Attapadi area, over 100 km north of Palakkad, housing 400 poor tribal families (who also come under the non-paying group) by drawing power lines for over 20 km. It all began in 2007 when Kannadi panchayat in the Kozhalmannam assembly constituency in Palakkad became the first gram panchayat to become fully electrified in Kerala. That was made possible through funds made available by elected representatives, local bodies and KSEB.

"The success of the participative effort at Kannadi panchayat gave us the confidence to try it at a larger scale. We then successfully electrified an assembly constituency — Irijalakuda in the Thrissur district using the same model before taking it up at district level in Palakkad," explains A.K. Balan, Minister for Electricity and Welfare of Scheduled Castes/ Scheduled Tribes and Backward Classes, Kerala. "Involvement of various local bodies and elected representatives has been crucial for the success of the project and the dual portfolio that I handle helped me to optimally tap the tribal development funds for this project." On February 16, a little over 12 months from the start of the project, Union Power Minister Sushil Kumar Shinde announced to the world that Palakkad had become India's first fully electrified district— in effect, every home has electricity.

To achieve this distinction, 907 km of low tension single phase line and 78 km of three-phase line were laid, 18,000 new service connections were given (including 2,500 SC/ST households) and 26 transformers were installed—all at a cost of Rs 23.26 crore. "The project cost would have been much higher had we not spent Rs 520 crore over the last three-and-a-half years to upgrade the transmission and distribution network in the district," points out M.B. Rajesh, an MP representing Palakkad Lok Sabha constituency. Almost all households in the district today have electricity at their door step with a very few exceptions such as those awaiting forest department permission (Balan says those approvals have since come in, too).

KSEB faced many a unique challenge to make this electricity-for-all initiative a reality. "We had to overcome very difficult terrain, especially in Thalikakal and Kadapara area. At many places, we had to physically carry the concrete poles and cables as there were no roads," says P. Rajan, Executive Engineer, KSEB (Alattur Electrical Division). Then, there are places in Parambikulam area which are not accessible from the Kerala side at all. For such places, KSEB chose to draw power lines from Tamil Nadu and buy the required electricity from the neighbouring state.

Permission of the forest department was another challenge and where it was not forthcoming, KSEB had no choice but to take the power lines on a detour through private lands. And as if these challenges were not enough, the Kurumba tribe in Attapadi region put the project managers in a piquant position—how to make electricity available at the doorstep of a tribe that shifts its dwelling place every few weeks!

At some places where KSEB did bring electricity to the doorstep, people did not have the money (about Rs 2,000) to wire the house. "We are looking at ways to help people below the poverty line wire their households. Gram panchayat can use the development funds for the purpose with government approval. There are also plans to get the people to fund at least part of the cost from their NREG earnings," says K.V. Mohan Kumar, Collector, Palakkad district, referring to the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme.

The project, however, has caused a great deal of excitement among the people, most of whom are enjoying the benefits of electricity for the first time. "We had no hope that electricity will come in our lifetime. We can't believe it," says Veeran, 60, a resident of the Moolaganga settlement in a language that appeared to be a mixture of Malayalam and Tamil.

His views are shared by many people who are eagerly anticipating a better quality of life. There are already signs of change in the lives of these tribals. Rama Moopan (moopan means leader of the tribe) of Vachchapati village is impatient to build a pucca house. "I don't want to do the wiring in this old house," he says pointing to his ramshackle hut. In fact, the availability of power, in a way, has accelerated rebuilding of many tribal homes. It has also rekindled the hopes of Moolaganga residents to return to farming.

"We are blessed with a fertile black soil, which is ideal for growing cash crops such as toor dal, horse gram and ragi, but elephants from the nearby forests repeatedly destroyed our crops in the past. Frustrated, we ultimately quit farming. Now, with electricity, we can look at the possibility of ‘putting earth' (electric fence) and restart farming," says Veeran. They are also eagerly looking forward to using mobile phones as availability of electricity paves way for setting up towers, thereby extending mobile coverage into their area.

"It will take at least two years to determine the socioeconomic impact of electricity on the lives of tribals. I expect it to have the most beneficial impact on women and children," says Rajan Pullenkattil, Assistant Executive Engineer, KSEB, Mannarkad, who is also doing a project on the Role of Energy on Sustainable Development of Tribals as a part of a PhD he is pursuing.

Some experts consider absence of decentralised power source or off-grid power as one of the shortcomings of this project. Palakkad district has a good potential for wind energy, solar power and biomass-based electricity generation. "We are looking at solar energy and mini wind mills to supplement grid power. These projects take time. We did not want to wait that long," explains Rajesh, the MP.

Success at district level has emboldened Minister Balan to now replicate the project at the state level. About 25 of the 140 assembly constituencies have been fully electrified so far. "Our aim is to cover 100 assembly constituencies in the next one year and the rest of the state in two years," says a confident Balan. If he has his way, Kerala could soon become India's first fully electrified state.

The Project

Total electrification of the Palakkad district involved:

* Laying 78 km of three-phase line.
* Drawing 907 km of LT single phase line.
* Installing 26 transformers.
* Offering 18,000 new service connections.
* Lighting up 502 far-flung tribal families.

Source
 
Over 40% of all child marriages in the world take place in India, making it the child marriage capital of the world. Nearly half of all the Indian marriages involve a child bride, ranking it at number 11 among 68 nations where child marriages are reported. Child marriages account for nearly a quarter of all marriages in Pakistan, according to UNICEF.

Earlier this year, the Hindu newspaper reported on an Indian study, prepared by the Population Council of India, which concluded that child marriage continues to be rampant in India with nearly one-fifth of Indian women being married off before turning 15 and around 50 per cent before reaching the legal marriageable age.

In April 2007, the International Center for Research on Women (ICRW) published the results of a study on child marriage in the world, "New Insights on Preventing Child Marriage: A Global Analysis of Factors and Programs" (pdf). The ranking included 68 countries. Topping the list was Niger, where 76.6% of women were found to have married before age 18, followed by Chad, at 71.5%. The proportion of child brides was above 60% in Bangladesh, Mali and Guinea, and above 50% in Nepal, Mozambique, Uganda, Burkina Faso and India. Pakistan, with 31.6% child marriages reported in 1991-92, is ranked at 32 in the middle of this list of 68 nations.

Haq's Musings: India Leads the World in Child Marriages

Haq's Musings: Female Literacy Lags Far Behind in India and Pakistan
 
Here's a report on the rape of a 5-year-old girl in India:

A five year old girl who was raped and left in a critical condition has been abandoned by her parents at India's leading hospital, an opposition leader has revealed amid growing anger over sexual assaults on children.

Sushma Swaraj, parliamentary leader of the main opposition Bharatiya Janata Party, was visiting another five year old rape victim in a critical condition whose case had sparked protests throughout the capital when she was told by nurses of the abandoned girl and other victims they had treated.

The discovery of more child rape victims at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS) has revived the intense debate and national introspection over the scale of sexual violencein the country which followed the gang rape of a 23 year old student on a Delhi bus in December. She died two weeks later from chronic internal injuries.

Mrs Swaraj said she had believed that debate would lead to improvemed public safety for women, but Indian women are now more at risk than before. "I had thought that after Damini case thinking will change. Unfortunately, the situation has worsened," she said.

Human rights campaigners said there had been a 336 per cent increased in child rapes in India since 2001, from 2,113 cases to 7,112 in 2011. But even this figure is likely to be an underestimate because only a minority of cases are reported to the police, they said.

In this latest case, the family had reported their daughter missing soon after she disappeared but the police were reluctant to investigate and later offered them 2000 rupees, around 25 pounds, to remain silent about it, the family said. When the family and their friends demonstrated over their treatment, one officer, who has since been suspended, was seen slapping a young female protestor.

Their daughter had been kidnapped on April 15th and raped and object-raped in an hour long ordeal before she was locked in a room and left to die. She was found 40 hours later and was rushed to hospital where doctors said she had suffered chronic internal injuries and that they had found a bottle of hair oil inside her. She has since had a colostomy operation and may face further reconstructive surgery, but is now in a stable condition, doctors said....

5-Year-Old Victim Abandoned In Hospital As India Faces Child Rape Crisis - Business Insider
 
The following report is from 2007. Today it's 2013. What has changed?


Indian parents are silent witnesses of child abuse
Saturday, April 14, 2007

NEW DELHI: Parents are often silent witnesses to abuse of their children due to conservative views about sex in India, a government official said on Friday.

A study earlier this week revealed that two-thirds of children in India are physically abused while more than half have faced some form of sexual abuse.

The study - which questioned almost 12,500 children and parents across 13 of India’s 29 states - found that half the cases of sexual abuse were committed by persons known to the child or in a position of trust and responsibility.

“I think the study is like heaving a sigh of relief because it’s something that parents knew but they wouldn’t voice as the culture doesn’t permit this,” Renuka Chowdhury, India’s minister for women and child development, told Reuters in an interview.

“A lot of them have been silent witnesses to a lot of things. It’s more like drawing the curtain aside.”

She said parents often did not know how to confront a family member who was sexually abusing their child.

“Parents are also in denial as they don’t know how to remove the uncle, for example, as perhaps he’s contributing to the family coffers or he has a dominant role in the family.” Chowdhury said sex was still a taboo subject in many family homes. “I don’t understand why we shouldn’t talk about sex when we have a one billion population ... obviously everyone is occupied with it. That’s just hypocrisy,” she said.

Chowdhury criticised the decision by three Indian states, Gujarat, Maharashtra and Madhya Pradesh, to ban sex education. “Sex education does not mean you are encouraging sex which is how it’s interpreted,” she said. “Sex education is an insurance for your child. It will protect your child.

“It’s creating awareness of a child of the physical transitions that happen when they enter their reproductive years and so they will also know how not to be exploited or misguided by some pervert standing outside their school.” reuters

Daily Times - Leading News Resource of Pakistan
 
Back
Top Bottom