First woman Imam leading Friday prayer in India faces ‘death threat’

[SrNair]

Thats great.

But why is she facing death threats?

Death threats will deal through law and order agencies.

 

[El Sidd]

One has to prove forbiddance ... Any thing that isn't forbidden is Halal ...

What about alcohol? Like Fermentation

And and what about drugs? Hash and stuff.

Fascinating the religious debate

 

[Hamza913]

Saudi women were not allowed to drive, things change, perspective change

That's not based in scripture though, where as this rule is.

 

[Areesh]

Ahadith are time and context bound .. In medieval Arabia, women were not supposed to lead men in anything, including prayers.. So men leading prayers normally is nothing surprising... However, there were exceptions ... The point is, was it a cultural norm or was it a religious obligation?...If latter is true, there must have been enough evidence in the Holy texts in this regard , No ?

Nope.

Not everything forbidden isn't mention clearly. that is the reason we have Ijma and Qiyas for that after Quran and Hadeeth. Hadeeth are very clear about man leading prayers. In fact Hadeeth also said that it is better for a woman to pray at home. So yup it is clear that man should always lead prayers unless there is some real good reason for doing otherwise which here isn't the case.

 

[Hamza913]

He will speak for Keralites .
Who are you to question him ?

He can't speak for Muslims since he's not one.

 

[Sh@msu]

It's is your faith and you must follow that... But I have my opinion... Everybody has their own rights and faiths... No one have right to threaten others...
ISIS also raping its woman slaves saying it's in permitted under sharia... will you accept it???


I have my own opinion... Who you to threaten me???

you have your opinion about your own business,not about other's religion,when third person singular number exercise his "opinion right" about people who don't want it,it is called interference.

 

[El Sidd]

Death threats will deal through law and order agencies.

Is it a common thing in India?

Honor killing also a big thing there.

But Kerala ISIS chapter is fascinating.

Whose the government? Leftists?

 

[Areesh]

Actually you are none to pass comments on this .
We all are Indians .And she is an Indian citizen and has full protection of our system

This is a Pakistani forum. And I am a Pakistani.

So I can comment on any thread I want to. You have problem with that? Go take a hike and leave this forum.

Give her protection. But don't expect muslims to bring innovation to their religion.

 

[Sh@msu]

Saudi women were not allowed to drive, things change, perspective change

Rofl,saudi woman couldn't drive because of their own law,not because of religion.I asked this before and i ask this again,as hinduism is "way of life" why there is no representative of "modern life woman" or "homosexual right" in entire hinduism?

 

[Hamza913]

Which dress is allowed in Islam... umbrella style burqa, hijab, salwaar kameez with dupatta on shoulders as Muslims seem to follow different codes

Hijab with Loose-fitting clothing = Allowed
Burqa = Preferred
Dupatta and Shalwar = Generally impermissible (depends how you wear it, but most don't wear it in a way that's halal)

 

[Lil Mathew]

Agreed .
But cant completely agree.
She has full right under our constitution to do anything she want .And none has right to threaten her .
But insulting majority feelings is also inhumane .
This is also not good for Kerala

No one is insulting majority or minority sentiments here... It's again depend on mentality here... If we have the maturity to accept each other's... We see that problem in an another light... That's, Food is everyone's personal choice... no one have right to impose what to eat & what to not eat???

Not ours.

It's not yours... It's ours problem... Whole state of Kerala is supporting her no matter Hindu, Muslim, Christian here... Only some Muslim fundamentalists are opposing...

 

[Hamza913]

It's not yours... It's ours problem... Whole state of Kerala is supporting her no matter Hindu, Muslim, Christian here... Only some Muslim fundamentalists are opposing...

It is mine, as a Muslim. In Islam, religion trumps all, including ethnic groups.

I guarantee most of Kerala's Muslims would be backing me over you.

 

[Reichsmarschall]

All Indian muslims should convert to hinduism

 

[Sh@msu]

i predicted this before,these things will keep coming up,specially now when america is dying as so called protector of freedom,womna right flag bearer america is dying out as a global leader.
So much people in india giving up their "way of life" for being westernized, gurujis having tough time "interpreting" their "way of life".I doubt even 20% people of entire india now believe in "way of life" ,i can tell from my experience of meeting people both here and when i visited west bengal. In fact if indian gurus come out of their delusion of their way of life and try to see the truth, if they get rid of delusion that "atheism is also part of hinduism" they will see,it is already almost dead. Almost all hindu people i met are atheist.And guess whose fault is this? when ever other try to follow their religion strictly these people jump in shouting radicals and try to pose themselves as modern.Why do you think america is so passionate about making you "secular"?
They forgot whatever westerns do,they have hidden agenda. Indian people embraced "modernism" way too early.now they are feeling insecured about their way of life.
If you follow the pattern of conversion,you will see a particular pattern.In entire south asia there is a particular part of christianity is growing.The same part that originated in land of freedom.
As far as "woman leader" is concerned.
Once i asked am american
"why your army chief is not an woman"
"why your CIA chief is not an woman"
"Why none of strategic singular decision in your country never being taken by woman"
he simply blocked me.
They are never allow woman to take strategic decisions.
If you see how they are empowering woman,you will see almost all of it is hot air.
They are trying to create pure delusion.

All Indian muslims should convert to hinduism

probably 40-50 years ago,but now not possible,hinduism is almost dead,people doesn't buy "way of life" anymore.The theory is still alive because it's main core is you don't have to practice it"
only eastern philosophy that is growing even leaving it's mark among westerns is buddhism because it has originated from single source more like abrahamic religion and present clear view.Hinduism is more like a meshed up version of some old philosophy and mythical creatures.

 

[Ajaxpaul]

You communists are supporting Islamic radicals and slaughtering rss members to incite violence...so that Kerala remains under Vatican control...just watch...all the foreign funding for missionaries carrying out illicit activities will be blocked...Hindus and Muslim's will see through facade...and bjp will come to power to protect hindu faith...

The hindu faith does not need bjp to protect itself. Lol.

Yeah bjp will come to power.... Whatever floats your boat.