I agree so how could the French Ops be a failure? My comment is aimed at the Fanboys here who think SSG is wholey grail and all other Special Ops people are failures.
Calm down. Putting the light banter aside, no one here believes that French Special Forces are a bunch of push overs. I would argue that they are right up there on the top with the best of the best. They are highly trained, motivated and some of the toughest guys out there in the field. Over the years, SSG has held several exercises with the French and they they have the highest amount of respect for them. I think a lot of the banter the French receive is due to their performance in WW1 and WW2. They forget that before the rise of Prussia, French Armies dominated continental Europe and were the undisputed masters of land warfare.
The SSG has had its share of failures, no doubt about that. But one needs to look deep into the history of Pakistan Army to understand why. Initially, SSG never received the attention as it should have as PA believed in the doctrine of massive infantry and armoured attacks. Not much focus was given to the special forces, this is why the performance of the SSG was quite substandard during the 65 and 71 war. It is only in the last 2 decades that SSG has gotten the attention that it deserved, and you can see that the performance of the SSG has improved by leaps and bounds since than.
Black Hawk 3 was when the TTP bomber blew up a SSG Mess killing 20.
Sir please, this is a very unfair remark. One needs to understand the compulsions, one cannot do much when a coward disguises himself and attacks you from the behind.
Black Hawk 4 was TTP beheaded 4 SSG soldiers brutally.
Again Sir not a very good example. TTP tricked those men, they assured them off safe passage because the Swat peace deal had been signed, but due to their imbedded nature they engaged in duplicity. But you forgot to mention the latter part of the story, how the SSG hunted down that TTP commander and those men responsible and slaughtered them like dogs.
Black Hawk 5 was Lal Masjid Ops where the SSG lost their brave Commanding Officer.
Sir, again a very poor example. One needs to look at the constraints that SSG was facing at the time, this operation was highly politicized and that is why we lost men. SSG during the initial stages were under strict orders not to engage in any sort of fire fight, this is why we lost Lt Col Haroon ul Islam in the initial stages as the firing from the terrorists came out of no where. But overall if you look at the operation, considering the size of the mosque and the constraints faced by the SSG, the operation was executed with amazing efficiency. We would have not have taken any casualties if SSG request of conducting the raid at night time would have been accepted, and keep in mind that the SSG had to differentiate between the civilians and the militants inside the mosque. Not a single civilian was killed by SSG fire, now that is a feat that the SSG can be proud off.
One only needs to look at the performance of the SSG during the Rah e Nijat and Rah e Rast operations to see how they have improved by leaps and bounds.
Special Ops People all over the world are brave. Respect them as PA has itself lost many in ops. 17 terrorists died in this ops.
No doubt about that, i have my highest respect for all Special Ops folks.