Dwarka : Myth or reality?

[Rafi]

Based on the comments of Pakistanis on this thread....One thing is clear....

The Palestinian-Israeli conflict can be easily resolved....
What this means is that since Israel has been the current resident/owner of the lands that they also lived on 1000s of years ago and continue to do so for the last 60, the Palestinians have no connection or history with that land and should simply roll over and integrate with other arab nations which may be willing to take them....

So history belongs to whoever is the current owner of the land.....whether their religion, culture and lifestule was no way similar to the people they are claiming to be connected to has no bearing on this....

Isnt that right Pakistanis?

But the Pakistanis have lived on this land for thousands of years, whereas the majority of Israelis moved there once the state of Israel was founded.

 

[Truth Teller]

I just came back home and started going through the thread and i cannot stop laughing at the way members from both sides are posting childish posts .The thread has been derailed completely.As i can understand there is only one Pakistani member here (Rafi) who has taken on a plethora of Indian members.I posted this thread to put more light on Dwarka as it is one of India's greatest secrets.But here too people have brought IVC and ruined the thread.Pakistani members here must understand that the IVC in no way belongs just to Pakistan .It is a heritage shared by both the countries.Just because physically the location is in modern day Pakistan does not make it Pakistani.No matter how much you guys jump up and down in this forum one cannot change the reality.Similarly the lost city of Dwarka is something that even Pakistanis can be proud of.It's all joint heritage.Always do remember that both nations were formed in 1947 , before that there is at least 5000 years of joint heritage.

Exactly, by jumping up and down you cannot change reality.

IVC also spread into parts of modern-day Iran, Afghanistan, Central Asia. But the main sites of IVC are found in Pakistan.

 

[Rafi]

aapka pakistan aapko mubaarak, we want link for your claim that Pkaistan existed since ages. and BDW there is nothing called Pakistani Civilization, dare to prove me wrong with a link

While Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the people of Pakistan inhabited the land for thousands of years and like most civilisations in the world, Pakistan has been known by different names throughout history.

We aim to provide information about Pakistan from Ancient times to more recent times.
The Empires which were created by the Pakistani people
Pakistani Ancestors who made their mark on the world.
And the events the Pakistani people have been through for the past 9000 years.

History of Ancient Pakistan

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

MOST LOGICAL REASON!

Yes indians can claim IVC........... see the green part in the map...... this was IVC guys ............... now some of these guys went to parts of india like UP,Trivandam,Bombay and other cities of india and populated........... after a few thousand years two countires were created.......... 1 was where these guys were originally from! the other where they made populated but never lived ............. Now their own areas became Pakistan the other where they made babies became india.......... hence india as a whole today can claim IVC!

Thts so logical.

NOW THANK ME....... I JUST SOLVED THE MYSTERY!

 

[Rafi]

Exactly, by jumping up and down you cannot change reality.

IVC also spread into parts of modern-day Iran, Afghanistan, Central Asia. But the main sites of IVC are found in Pakistan.

Exactly right, in fact there are more sites in Iran, Afghanistan and Central Asia than in modern india. Ancient Pakistanis must have been very good warriors, traders for this to have spread so far.

 

[Major Ram]

But the Pakistanis have lived on this land for thousands of years, whereas the majority of Israelis moved there once the state of Israel was founded.

There was no Pakistan before 1947.. so the words "Pakistani" and "thousand years" just don't go together..

 

[Truth Teller]

Pakistanis are native of the Indus valley, whereas majority of Isrealis are of European, or North African (Berber) descent.

 

[Masterchief]

Why do indians feel connected to IVC, its because it was a cradle of sanatana dharma, many locations of IVC find mention in our epics.why do pakistanis take pride in IVC,well because the consider themselves decendants of the people who lived there,and with majority of IVC location is in pakistan, so why should people fight over it, we can share it.

 

[Rafi]

MOST LOGICAL REASON!

Yes indians can claim IVC........... see the green part in the map...... this was IVC guys ............... now some of these guys went to parts of india like UP,Trivandam,Bombay and other cities of india and populated........... after a few thousand years two countires were created.......... 1 was where these guys were originally from! the other where they made populated but never lived ............. Now their own areas became Pakistan the other where they made babies became india.......... hence india as a whole today can claim IVC!

Thts so logical.

NOW THANK ME....... I JUST SOLVED THE MYSTERY!

You cracked the puzzle LoL bro.

 

[Dalai Lama]

Okay, IVC belongs exclusively to Pakistanis but since IVC was a Hindu civilization, the Pakistanis can no longer consider themselves to be pure Muslims. Logic dictates that the word Pakistan ( means "pure") should be changed to 'Hindustan'.

 

[Rafi]

While Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the people of Pakistan inhabited the land for thousands of years and like most civilisations in the world, Pakistan has been known by different names throughout history.

We aim to provide information about Pakistan from Ancient times to more recent times.
The Empires which were created by the Pakistani people
Pakistani Ancestors who made their mark on the world.
And the events the Pakistani people have been through for the past 9000 years.

History of Ancient Pakistan

This is the truth, however unpalatable for indian's.

 

[Major Ram]

While Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the people of Pakistan inhabited the land for thousands of years and like most civilisations in the world, Pakistan has been known by different names throughout history.

We aim to provide information about Pakistan from Ancient times to more recent times.
The Empires which were created by the Pakistani people
Pakistani Ancestors who made their mark on the world.
And the events the Pakistani people have been through for the past 9000 years.

History of Ancient Pakistan

That's a Pakistani BS website.. we're looking for a credible link from last 2 hour's.. don't you feel shame that you couldn't prove your nation's history???

 

[Fireurimagination]

MOST LOGICAL REASON!

Yes indians can claim IVC........... see the green part in the map...... this was IVC guys ............... now some of these guys went to parts of india like UP,Trivandam,Bombay and other cities of india and populated........... after a few thousand years two countires were created.......... 1 was where these guys were originally from! the other where they made populated but never lived ............. Now their own areas became Pakistan the other where they made babies became india.......... hence india as a whole today can claim IVC!

Thts so logical.

NOW THANK ME....... I JUST SOLVED THE MYSTERY!

And this is prior to partition of India, there was no Pakistan prior to 1947

 

[Shak_ed]

provide me any link which says something called Pakistani civilization existed !!

i can provide dozens of link saying Indian civilization is oldest civilization, can you??

There is a world outside PDF and Pakistan

 

[Masterchief]

Pakistanis are native of the Indus valley, whereas majority of Isrealis are of European, or North African (Berber) descent.

wrong, the indians, the pakistanis, the palestenians,the europeans,the whole world has a common ancestor the ape, we aren't different dude its our mentality which is.