Dwarka : Myth or reality?

[Major Ram]

india is the ganges based civilization while Pakistan is based on the IVC.

---------- Post added at 09:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:05 PM ----------

I'm asking you again, do you have a credible link to prove that Pakistan was even existed before 1947??? If it is true then it should be all over the internet. Why you're taking hours to find that link?

 

[Dharmachakra]

You know people of the Indus are Pakistanis, right? And dont you feel the slightest bit of shame that your country is named after a river which flows through the heart of Pakistan?

And dont your feel shame that your people are using water from the river that originates in India?

I'm asking you again, do you have a credible link to prove that Pakistan was even existed before 1947??? If it is true then it should be all over the internet. Why you're taking hours to find that link?

No. they wont be able to provide a link at all.

I know where this thread is leading to...... End up with the same fate just like chankya quotes....



Many people (most non-Indians and especially present day pakistanis) fail to realise is that, India is a name coined by west. We call it Bharat( if country) and Bharata Kanda( if sub-continent). No matter whatever name you call it, truth is always the same. The same Bharat was united under a single empire as many times so is divided as many times. Yet the religious feeling kept the whole united and every Bharat vasi feels proud about their ancestors and their history.

Hence anything that has to do with ancient history is all part of every Bharatvasi life.

 

[Truth Teller]

The point is the person who gave your country it's name believed it was part of India & you don't

Muammad Iqbal was refering to India as a geographic location under the British Raj. He was not refering to modern-day India.

 

[Shak_ed]

You know people of the Indus are Pakistanis, right? And dont you feel the slightest bit of shame that your country is named after a river which flows through the heart of Pakistan?

why would we be ashamed of India?? we are proud of it and its time Pakistani should be proud of their Pakistani identity (I know its difficult to live with this identity in west )

even paksitanis are proud of India, see this

Pakistanis pose as Indians after NY bomb scare | Reuters

 

[Rafi]

I'm asking you again, do you have a credible link to prove that Pakistan was even existed before 1947??? If it is true then it should be all over the internet. Why you're taking hours to find that link?

An animal that lived in Pakistan millions of years ago has been named after the country, proves that Geographic Pakistan and Ancient Pakistan has always existed.

 

[Major Ram]

You know people of the Indus are Pakistanis, right? And dont you feel the slightest bit of shame that your country is named after a river which flows through the heart of Pakistan?

I'm asking you a very simple question. Do you have any credible source to prove that Pakistan existed before 1947??? I'm waiting from last 15 Pages but you're not able to do that. Its quite evident who should be shameful.

 

[Fireurimagination]

Muammad Iqbal was refering to India as a geographic location under the British Raj. He was not refering to modern-day India.

So at least you agree you were part of modern-day India? so do you agree Pakistan part of the Maurya Empire?

 

[Rafi]

why would we be ashamed of India?? we are proud of it and its time Pakistani should be proud of their Pakistani identity (I know its difficult to live with this identity in west )

even paksitanis are proud of India, see this

Pakistanis pose as Indians after NY bomb scare | Reuters

That is a fallacy Pakistanis never have claimed to be indian's.

 

[Truth Teller]

The Indus river flows from China to Kashmir into Pakistan. Kashmir is not part of Bharat.

 

[Fireurimagination]

An animal that lived in Pakistan millions of years ago has been named after the country, proves that Geographic Pakistan and Ancient Pakistan has always existed.

Ancient Pakistan?? Can you please list few kings, culture, religion of Ancient Pakistan?

 

[Shak_ed]

repeated post

 

[Rafi]

The Indus river flows from China to Kashmir into Pakistan. Kashmir is not part of Bharat.

Your killing them TT bro

 

[Major Ram]

An animal that lived in Pakistan millions of years ago has been named after the country, proves that Geographic Pakistan and Ancient Pakistan has always existed.

That animal was found in 2001. I'm looking for a link which clearly says that Pakistan existed before 1947. Is it too hard to prove???

 

[Shak_ed]

 

[Truth Teller]

So at least you agree you were part of modern-day India? so do you agree Pakistan part of the Maurya Empire?

Where did I state Pakistan was part of modern-day India?