What's new

Dwarka : Myth or reality?

Status
Not open for further replies.
.
Rafi, I'm still waiting for your link which clearly says that Pakistan existed before 1947. if you can't prove that then you're living in la la land.

The geographical region that is Pakistan has existed since time immemorial.

History of Ancient Pakistan

While Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the people of Pakistan inhabited the land for thousands of years and like most civilisations in the world, Pakistan has been known by different names throughout history.

We aim to provide information about Pakistan from Ancient times to more recent times.
The Empires which were created by the Pakistani people
Pakistani Ancestors who made their mark on the world.


And the events the Pakistani people have been through for the past 9000 years.
 
.
There was never a nation called india, till 1947 - Pakistan as a geographical entity has existed since time began.
 
.
Rafi, I'm still waiting for your link which clearly says that Pakistan existed before 1947. if you can't prove that then you're living in la la land.

Why dont you post a link proving a country cllaed "India" existed before 1947.
 
.
The geographical region that is Pakistan has existed since time immemorial.

History of Ancient Pakistan

While Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the people of Pakistan inhabited the land for thousands of years and like most civilisations in the world, Pakistan has been known by different names throughout history.

We aim to provide information about Pakistan from Ancient times to more recent times.
The Empires which were created by the Pakistani people
Pakistani Ancestors who made their mark on the world.


And the events the Pakistani people have been through for the past 9000 years.

lol what a link !! :lol: How dumb can a person be !!
 
.
Why dont you post a link proving a country cllaed "India" existed before 1947.

refer to post #197

---------- Post added at 08:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:57 PM ----------

There was never a nation called india, till 1947 - Pakistan as a geographical entity has existed since time began.

yeah pakistan existed in Pluto since time began :lol:
 
.
Why dont you post a link proving a country cllaed "India" existed before 1947.

Good one bro, there was no such thing as india before 1947, it was a bunch of regions.

---------- Post added at 08:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:28 PM ----------

lol what a link !! :lol: How dumb can a person be !!

Your the living proof that there is.
 
.
Asia's First Civilizations - India And China

asian.jpg


Introduction

Like Sumer, Egypt, and other early civilizations in the Middle East,
civilizations first developed in East and South Asia in the vicinity of great
river systems. When irrigated by the massive spring floods of the Yellow
River, the rich soil of the North China plain proved a superb basis for what
has been the largest and most enduring civilization in human history.
Civilization first developed in the Indus River valley in present-day Pakistan
in the middle of the 3d millennium B.C., more than a thousand years earlier
than it did in China. In fact, the civilization of the Indus valley, usually
called Harappan after its chief city, rivals Sumer and Egypt as humanity's
oldest. But like Sumer and its successor civilizations in the Middle East,
Harappan civilization was unable to survive natural catastrophes and nomadic
invasions. In contrast to the civilization of the Shang rulers in China around
1500 B.C., Harappa vanished from history. Until the mid-19th century it was
"lost" or forgotten, even by the peoples who lived in the vicinity of its
sand-covered ruins. Important elements of Harappan society were transmitted to
later civilizations in the Indian subcontinent. But unlike the Shang kingdom,
Harappa did not survive to be the core and geographical center from which a
unified and continuous civilization developed like that found in China. The
difference in the fate of these two great civilizations provides one of the
key questions in dealing with the history of civilized societies: What factors
permitted some civilizations to endure for millennia while others rose and
fell within a few centuries?

Between about 1500 and 1000 B.C., as the great cities of the Indus region
crumbled into ruins, nomadic Aryan invaders from central Asia moved into the
fertile Indus plains and pushed into the Ganges River valleys to the east. It
took these unruly, warlike peoples many centuries to build a civilization that
rivaled that of the Harappans. The Aryans concentrated on assaulting Harappan
settlements and different Aryan tribal groups. As peoples who depended
primarily on great herds of cattle to provide their subsistence, they had
little use for the great irrigation works and advanced agricultural technology
of the Indus valley peoples. Though they conserved some Harappan beliefs and
symbols, the Aryan invaders did little to restore or replace the great cities
and engineering systems of the peoples they had supplanted.

Eventually, however, many of the Aryan groups began to settle down, and
increasingly they relied on farming to support their communities. By about 700
B.C., their priests had begun to orally record the sacred hymns and ritual
incantations that had long been central to Aryan culture. In the following
centuries, strong warrior leaders built tribunal units into larger kingdoms.
The emergence of priestly and warrior elites signaled the beginning of a new
pattern of civilization in South Asia. By the 6th century B.C., the renewal of
civilized life in India was marked by the emergence of great world religions,
such as Hinduism and Buddhism, and a renewal of trade, urban life, and
splendid artistic and architectural achievements.

The early development of civilization in China combined the successive
phases of advancement of Mesopotamian history with the continuity of Egyptian
civilization. Civilization in China coalesced around 1500 B.C. Chinese
civilization emerged gradually out of Neolithic farming and potterymaking
cultures that had long been present in the Yellow River region of East Asia.
The establishment of the Shang kingdom at this point in time gave political
expression to a combination of civilizing trends. The appearance of a
distinctive and increasingly specialized elite supported by the peasant
majority of the Chinese people, the growth of towns and the first cities, the
spread of trade, and the formulation of a written language all indicated that
a major civilization was emerging in China.

Though the political dominance of the Shang came to an end in 1122 under
the new royal house of the Zhou, civilized development in China was enriched
and extended as the Chinese people migrated east and south from their original
Yellow River heartland. By the end of the Zhou era, which would last
officially until 256 B.C., many of the central elements in Chinese
civilization, one of humankind's oldest, were firmly established. Some of
those elements have persisted to the present day.
 
. .
Harappa, Punjab, Pakistan

The cities of Mohenjo-daro and Harappa marked the discovery of India's hitherto unsuspected prehistoric civilization - the 'Indus Valley civilisation'.

One of the largest of the world's early civilizations, it was unearthed by British and Indian archaeologists in the 1920s. Their finds produced buildings, tools, jewellery and sculpture dating back to 3000 BC. Standardised weights, measures and bricks from the Mature Harappan phase of around 2300 BC tell us just how sophisticated this culture was. Harappan seals found in Mesopotamia also attest to the fact that it was a culture engaged in overseas trade. The city plan, arranged in a grid like system with roads uniformly twice the width of side lanes, suggests that Harappan settlements were the first planned urban centres in the world.

The decline of the Harappan civilisation remains a source of speculation. The theory of an Aryan invasion has long since been discredited and it is now widely believed to be due to climate change and perhaps also to tectonic activities. Major changes took place in the northern part of the Indian subcontinent causing its rivers to change course. Resulting water shortages led to the abandonment of many of the settlements as people started migrating eastwards.

BBC - History - Ancient History in depth: The Story of India: Pakistan and North India

Before 1947, "India" was a term used to describe a geographic location, not a nation/country. Similiar to how "Middle east" is used to describe the geographic location of West Asian countires today.

Harappa was a Pakistani Punjabi civilization.
 
. .
Before 1947, "India" was a term used to describe a geographic location, not a nation/country. Similiar to how "Middle east" is used to describe the geographic location of West Asian countires today.

Harappa was a Pakistani Punjabi civilization.


Thanks mate, that was what we been also saying all along.

The name is always refered to a geographical region. like Russia is called to a geographical location east to Europe north to central asia.

Thanks again.
 
.
Before 1947, "India" was a term used to describe a geographic location, not a nation/country. Similiar to how "Middle east" is used to describe the geographic location of West Asian countires today.

Harappa was a Pakistani Punjabi civilization.

Exactly right brother, this is the truth there was never a nation called "middle east" and there was never a nation called "india" until 1947.
 
.
Before 1947, "India" was a term used to describe a geographic location, not a nation/country. Similiar to how "Middle east" is used to describe the geographic location of West Asian countires today.

Harappa was a Pakistani Punjabi civilization.


According to your logic there was nothing called 'pakistan' before 1971 ??
 
.
The geographical region that is Pakistan has existed since time immemorial.

History of Ancient Pakistan

While Pakistan gained independence in 1947, the people of Pakistan inhabited the land for thousands of years and like most civilisations in the world, Pakistan has been known by different names throughout history.

We aim to provide information about Pakistan from Ancient times to more recent times.
The Empires which were created by the Pakistani people
Pakistani Ancestors who made their mark on the world.


And the events the Pakistani people have been through for the past 9000 years.

You provided some Pakistani website. I requested some credible source. So I'm still waiting for a credible source of your claim that Pakistan was existed before 1947. Thanks. Hope you would reply.
 
.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom