What's new

Dr Abdus Salam, forgotten but not forgiven by Pakistan

Pakistani E

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 8, 2013
Messages
7,059
Reaction score
27
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Dr Abdus Salam, forgotten but not forgiven by Pakistan
By Asad Mustafa Kahlon Published: November 22, 2016

43238-asdr-1479813165-438-640x480.jpg

It is fairly difficult for most of my compatriots to honour the services of a Pakistani if he happens to be an Ahmadi. PHOTO: FILE

The hush silence that marked Doctor Abdus Salam’s death anniversary this year was palpable. It is fairly difficult for most of my compatriots to honour the services of a Pakistani if he happens to be an Ahmadi.

However, there is a lot more to Salam than merely winning a Nobel Prize or being ostracised as a pariah for his religious affiliation. A befitting gesture on my part would be to clear some of the hazy aura and the lesser known Sisyphean struggle that makes him unique and inspirational.

Missed out on a Nobel Prize, but never gave up


Where the world is still in awe for Salam winning a Nobel Prize in Physics, the lesser known fact is that he would have won the coveted accolade twice in his lifetime, had it not been for the short-sightedness of the quantum Physicist, Wolfgang Pauli.

During the 1950’s, Salam presented his findings on ‘neutrinos’ to Wolfgang Pauli, who quizzically rejected the research as futile. Whereas two scientists, T D Lee and C N Yang won the Nobel prize over the exact research a few years later.

But that snub didn’t deter Salam. He bounced back even stronger to win the laurel in 1979 along with Steven Weinberg and Sheldon Glashow of the United States, for the unification theory.

Wrangler at college

Not only did Salam win a scholarship to study at Cambridge for an undergraduate degree in Mathematics and Physics, he finished his Tripos in two years with a distinction, hailed as an unprecedented feat by the institution. Due to that prodigious achievement, he was titled ‘the wrangler’ on campus.

Dreamer of symmetry

Salam yearned for symmetry and, as a student of science; the equilibrium in nature is what inspired him most. The International Centre for theoretical physics, Trieste celebrated this unwavering belief of his in a documentary titled The Dream of Symmetry. It was not only in academic research he followed that mantra, in fact he considered it a priority while selecting institutes for higher studies.

Upon graduating from Cambridge with high honours, he was privileged to get offers from both Cambridge and Oxford University simultaneously to complete his Master’s program on a full scholarship. But Salam opted to stick with Cambridge, primarily on the basis of the symmetry of trees on campus.

Connection with football

After completing his higher studies from abroad, Salam came back to imbue a culture of research and development in Pakistan. He joined Government College Lahore as the head of department, but his hopes were shattered upon discovering the research adverse culture. Reduced to a mere administrator, he preferred presiding over a football club over warden ship or post of a treasurer, during his brief stint at the institute before he flew back to Britain to pursue his dream.

Snubbed by premiers

Needless to say, most political leaders gave Salam a cold shoulder; unfortunately, his faith proved to be excess baggage in post 1974 Pakistan. Ziaul Haq for one, not only failed to honour him upon winning the Nobel Prize but also refused to endorse him as the candidate from Pakistan for the UNESCO leadership program.

Unmatched patriotism

As Abdus Salam won the Nobel Prize, the government of India unlike the state of Pakistan wasted no time to invite him. On his visit to India, he was given the state welcome. Five Indian universities offered him honorary PHD degrees, even the then Prime Minister of India, Indira Gandhi, seized the opportunity and gave him an offer of citizenship that the stalwart plainly refused.

It is interesting to note that despite living most of his life outside Pakistan, he rejected all offers of nationalities from various countries and died as a patriotic Pakistani in his homeland.

Strong faith in God

His fellows who had worked with him in Trieste, Italy, acknowledge the fact that his research on the Unification of Fundamental forces was inspired due to his sheer belief in the concept of wahdat or the ‘one-ness’ of God. This belief of Deism was quite unique for his foreign colleagues who predominantly espoused Atheist ideology.

Hallmark of altruism

A selfless man himself, Salam dedicated all of his Nobel Prize money towards the bettermentof underdeveloped countries. One scientist below the age of 35 has been selected every year from Pakistan since 1981 as the Abdus Salam scholar to carry out research at the International Centre for Theoretical Physics, Trestie. Interestingly, Pervez Hoodbhoy is the first scholar to win the Salam award.

Being a pioneer of the Higgs boson (God’s particle) research is just a small facet to the story of this man. Rather than shoving his name under the rug, hopefully one day the state of Pakistan will recognise his true struggle and honour him in letter and spirit.

http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/43238/dr-abdus-salam-forgotten-but-not-forgiven-by-pakistan/
 
. .
I don't think that being Ahmadi or any one else has to do with anything with the persons service to his/her country.

What ever conspiracies being associated with Ahmadis is altogether a different debate but in the end they are all Pakistanies and they shoud be treated accordingly.

I am very much fond of Mr. Abdus Salam and his work and I am taking proud to have him as my country men.

I hope the day is not to far when we celebrate our people without considering their religion.
 
.
I don't think that being Ahmadi or any one else has to do with anything with the persons service to his/her country.

What ever conspiracies being associated with Ahmadis is altogether a different debate but in the end they are all Pakistanies and they shoud be treated accordingly.

I am very much fond of Mr. Abdus Salam and his work and I am taking proud to have him as my country men.

I hope the day is not to far when we celebrate our people without considering their religion.




brother all Pakistan got in return by shunning Dr. Salam is dreaded mulvis that have only destroyed the name of Islam and pushed the country on a path to militancy for hundreds of years to come as new generations are now being fed lies.

I read this on a previous thread here; these were also Ahmadis;
Qudrat Ullah Shahab an eminent Urdu writer and civil servant from Pakistan said that

"At a time when Major (General) Akhtar Hussain Malik was to take over Akhnoor to pave the way to take Srinager, the capital of Kashmir, he was wrongly removed from the command, and General Yahya Khan was put in his position. Perhaps the aim was to deprive Pakistan success in Akhnoor, Yahya Khan accomplished this task very well."[2]

Zulfikar Ali Bhutto the ninth Prime Minister of Pakistan and its fourth President said

"Had General Akhtar Malik not been stopped in the Chamb-Jaurian Sector, the Indian forces in Kashmir would have suffered serious reverses, but Ayub Khan wanted to make his favorite, General Yahya Khan, a hero."[3]

another hero of Pakistan army General Abdul Ali Malik.

Indian Commander in Chief Gen Chaudri made a bet with foreign Journalists and invited them to have cocktails with him in Lahore Gymkhana on September 8, made another brilliant move, he attacked Sialkot with hundreds of tanks.

India's plan was to make a direct thrust towards Wazirabad to capture commonly known GT Road and divide West Pakistan into two.

GOC Sialkot lost his nerves and ordered withdrawal to Sambrial. However, he had an Ahmadi Brigadier, Gen Abdul Ali. He told the GOC he would meet enemy right here at Chawinda and would not yield an inch of Pakistan soil. This Ahmadi had faith in Allah and the courage of his soldiers.

It was the most crucial battle of the whole war, where Indian tanks battled with Pakistan tanks. Gen Abdul Ali gave no quarter to the enemy, the tenacity and the bravery and superior skill in deployment of his tanks triumphed. Indian tanks fell back.

According to some reports, two thousands tanks on either side took part in it.

Battle of Chawinda is considered as the greatest tank battle after the battle of El Alameen fought by Field Marshal Montgomery with Field Marshal Rommel (the top German General).

This battle captured such a wide attention in Pakistan that Majlis Ulema Islam in book "Maa'rika Haq-o-ba'til" (the Battle of truth and falsehood), it carried an urdu couplet:

When Abdul Ali was commanding the Ghazis, it appeared as if Abdul Ali was raging like a storm.
 
.
Unfortunately we got Zia-ul-Haq into power at that time and he did not value Dr Abdus Salam, an excellent scientist, and let him go. Instead he should have supported him and provided him land for ICTP in Pakistan

But I totally disagree with idiotic title of the thread....since it is totally against the reality. Most of the Pakistanis working in scientific area did not forget him and what do you even mean by not forgiven as if he is being persecuted?...Why Qadiyani community is always BS against Pakistan and then they claim people treat them as traitors?
 
Last edited:
.
The blog is bullshit and sans facts. Here are the true facts http://wiki.qern.org/ahmadiyya/myth-and-reality-of-dr-abdus-salam
Has Pakistan Honoured Dr. Salam?
Dr. Salam is well-regarded among students of physics and mathematics in Pakistan. His alma mater, Government College University, has established the highest post-graduate school of Mathematics in his name, as well as a chair in Physics. Here is an incomplete list of honours:
 
.
I think the majority of Pakistanis respect and adore this man, but the Mullah elite restricting government and society would not allow any kind of recognition to take place.
 
.
And the Zia government had many uses for him. After the nuclear Programme began in earnest, our scientists were ostracized, Salam was one of the main sources (actually only) source of latest research and developments that were being withheld from us. Indeed when this fact was revealed by the book Eating Grass in 2012, you might have noticed Western opinion of him dropped considerably since then he became what he was always, a patriotic Pakistani, not a persecuted genius.

I think the majority of Pakistanis respect and adore this man, but the Mullah elite restricting government and society would not allow any kind of recognition to take place.
I am sorry, did you NOT read the post above yours.
 
.
The blog is bullshit and sans facts. Here are the true facts http://wiki.qern.org/ahmadiyya/myth-and-reality-of-dr-abdus-salam
Has Pakistan Honoured Dr. Salam?
Dr. Salam is well-regarded among students of physics and mathematics in Pakistan. His alma mater, Government College University, has established the highest post-graduate school of Mathematics in his name, as well as a chair in Physics. Here is an incomplete list of honours:


@Aether , So I guess the source he is presenting there is not dubious at all and very neutral?

@sparten How many events were held yesterday in his honour?
 
. .
I just want to ask a simple straightforward question.
Are ahmadis considered muslim in Pakistan?
Do you have to sign on a paper that states Ahmadis are non muslim while getting passports?
I heard many things on tv, but I dont believe them. Some pakistanis here can enlighten me.
 
.
I just want to ask a simple straightforward question.
Are ahmadis considered muslim in Pakistan?
Do you have to sign on a paper that states Ahmadis are non muslim while getting passports?
I heard many things on tv, but I dont believe them. Some pakistanis here can enlighten me.
Mainstream Muslims consider Ahmedis to be outside the pale of Islam as their belief system includes a component which brings into doubt the finality of Muhammad (pbuh) as the last prophet of God. I have heard from my Ahmedi friends that they do not believe that, rather they believe in the finality of Muhammad as the last prophet but also believe that God will continue to send "reformers" to lead the Muslims. This is supposedly a point of contention.

Ahmedis, like all other religious denominations have to mention what religion they adhere to when filling out application for a passport.

Eventhough this issue exists at the official level and some of the extremist groups make a point of using violence, for most Pakistanis, mixing with Ahmedis, inter-marriages are very common. I have very many friends from this community and to me they look like any other Pakistani and generally have done well in Pakistan in all spheres of life. Personally speaking, for my friends, it was only when they disclosed they were Ahmedi that I came to know, otherwise I could care less to ask and never thought they were any different from the rest of what makes Pakistan.

I have prayed behind an Ahmedi (a good friend from the Air Force) and he has done the same behind me but many people, on both sides of the two communities, may not agree with this practice.
 
Last edited:
.
Mainstream Muslims consider Ahmedis to be outside the pale of Islam as their belief system includes a component which brings into doubt the finality of Muhammad (pbuh) as the last prophet of God. I have heard from my Ahmedi friends that they do not believe that, rather they believe in the finality of Muhammad as the last prophet but also believe that God will continue to send "reformers" to lead the Muslims. This is supposedly a point of contention.

Ahmedis, like all other religious denominations have to mention what religion they adhere to when filling out application for passport.

Eventhough this issue exists at the official level and some of the extremist groups make a point of using violence, for most Pakistanis, mixing with Ahmedis, inter-marriages are very common. I have very many friends from this community and to me they look like any other Pakistani. It is only when they disclose they are Ahmedi that one comes to know, otherwise I could care less to ask.
Thank you for your answer.:tup:
Cleared many misconceptions in my mind.
 
.
Mainstream Muslims consider Ahmedis to be outside the pale of Islam as their belief system includes a component which brings into doubt the finality of Muhammad (pbuh) as the last prophet of God. I have heard from my Ahmedi friends that they do not believe that, rather they believe in the finality of Muhammad as the last prophet but also believe that God will continue to send "reformers" to lead the Muslims. This is supposedly a point of contention.

Ahmedis, like all other religious denominations have to mention what religion they adhere to when filling out application for a passport.

Eventhough this issue exists at the official level and some of the extremist groups make a point of using violence, for most Pakistanis, mixing with Ahmedis, inter-marriages are very common. I have very many friends from this community and to me they look like any other Pakistani and generally have done well in Pakistan in all spheres of life. Personally speaking, for my friends, it was only when they disclosed they were Ahmedi that I came to know, otherwise I could care less to ask and never thought they were any different from the rest of what makes Pakistan.

I have prayed behind an Ahmedi (a good friend from the Air Force) and he has done the same behind me but many people, on both sides of the two communities, may not agree with this practice.
Iqbal puts it bluntly - 'you are syed, afghan ...., ask your self are you a muslim'. Regretfully his message of having a higher thought has been lost and will remain lost at least for next several decades. Not paying attention to education and giving everything prespective from a religious angle has proven it that Pakistan has become a basket case because the corruption of society by the religious political dogmatics who have fostered these radicalisation views. Anyone who says anything from the holy text is considered worth and others who try to foster a question and answer are under threats.

It is such a shame - your country could have been a leader but has been relegated to the anals of history and will remain so until there are those within the society who are will to stand up and demand justice, equality, education and human rights for all. the elite must step aside for the new era to begin.

I have one of salam's disertation which i had review and read for one of my post grad works; he was far ahead of his time and your country fails and will continue to fail seeing talent even if it was in front of them until the illiterate ruling elite or those wanting to squander money on defence procurements are not dealt with.

Pardon my long writing, i am passionate for education for uplifting people across the world.
 
Last edited:
.
Einstein, fleming, tesla contributed just as much to the world of science as Abdus salam and they were non-muslims too like abdus salam. You don't see western countries celebrating them 24/7 and US presidents releasing statements praising them every month. Wonder why some people want pakistan government to do something similar? Islamic empires also produced numerous famous scientists. But muslim intelligentsia of of those times never agitated to give these people some privileged position just because of their scientific works. They took and accepted what's good in their works and discarded the bad aspects. That's what every society should be like. Being a man of science does not give you entitlement to privileged status. Only intellectually colonized people who due to western influence have been bought into scientism think that way. People of science are normal human beings who inherently makes mistakes. They can be as good , as bad and as morally corrupt as lawyers, teachers, labourers, traders etc etc.


I just want to ask a simple straightforward question.
Are ahmadis considered muslim in Pakistan?
Do you have to sign on a paper that states Ahmadis are non muslim while getting passports?
I heard many things on tv, but I dont believe them. Some pakistanis here can enlighten me.

Is it something bad if PAK considered qadiyanis to be non-muslims? Last I checked PAK is an UN designated independent country. Is there a requirement that PAK goverment and its people need to live up to the standards set by some online Indian, a random western journalist or a qadiyani writing an article in huffigtonpost or express tribune?

Iqbal puts it bluntly - 'you are syed, afghan ...., ask your self are you a muslim'. Regretfully his message of having a higher thought has been lost and will remain lost at least for next several decades. Not paying attention to education and giving everything prespective from a religious angle has proven it that Pakistan has become a basket case because the corruption of society by the religious political dogmatics who have fostered these radicalisation views. Anyone who says anything from the holy text is considered worth and others who try to foster a question and answer are under threats.

It is such a shame - your country could have been a leader but has been relegated to the anals of history and will remain so until there are those within the society who are will to stand up and demand justice, equality, education and human rights for all. the elite must step aside for the new era to begin.

I have one of salam's disertation which i had review and read for one of my post grad works; he was far ahead of his time and your country fails and will continue to fail seeing talent even if it was in front of them until the illiterate ruling elite or those wanting to squander money on defence procurements are not dealt with.

Pardon my long writing, i am passionate for education for uplifting people across the world.

Since when exactly did PAK gave importance to religion? The picture I get as an outsider makes me think that its just like the rest of 57 post-colonial muslims states under huge debt, ruled by western educated elite and an education system and middle class whose outlook is socially influenced to some extent by the west. PAK is as good and as bad and suffer from the same social problems as turkey, Indoneshia and malaysia and none of these problems are due to religion but because of lack of religion.
 
.
Back
Top Bottom