does israel have the right to exist?

[Leviza]

First of its a illegal state, made on stolen land by force ,....

Secondly , after what they have done to people of this land ... they should not be allowed to rule anywhere in the world ever again ...

they are mass murders of humanity ...

 

[T-Rex]

Some thinktank you are Fauji, Pakistanis or any other Muslim country will support Israel's right to exist the day the partition is done properly....30% gets 56% land and people who are in majority i.e 70% get 46% land, what were you expecting them to do, celebrate? Its people like you who never understood the Palestinian or the Muslims reason to support Palestinians, people like you who allow Israel to create a nuclear bomb but if someone else starts you have a problem with it, people like you who don't know the meaning of justice. Think about it my friends had the partition had been done properly would this problem be ever there? No, Muslims who say they don't support the right of Israel to exist say this mostly in anger due to the unjustice done to Palestinians, they never would have, had the UN played fairly, don't forget UN is a child of America what America says UN follows.

This Fauji impostor is a proud turncoat, he simply can't get over the humiliation of his ancestors. He has very limited analytical ability, this is why he thinks that Islam is responsible for that humiliation.This is his way of taking revenge.

 

[GURU DUTT]

the title was just to get your attention..
now lets discuss.

israel was founded in 1948 on the pretense as the homeland for jews and since then jews from all over the world have migrated to this country because it has been made as homeland for the jews.

-who are the jews?? and where do they come from?
jews are people who are born into jewish families or practice the jewish faith.
they come from all over the world like any major religious group.

-did the jews originate from israel??
we know that the religion was founded in modern day israel, but the modern jews at least the vast majority of them have no connection to the land of israel besides the fact that their religion was founded their.
jews are not an ethnicity as many would like us to think nor do they all originate from the tribe or judah or any of the other tribes.
few examples to show the different jews in their original countries.

chinese jews

persian jews

russian jew

nigerian jews

ethiopian jews

indian jews

yemeni jews

we can clearly see that all these jews are different and their ancestors most likely just converted to the jewish faith, non of these people can most likely trace their ancestry to israel.

with that being said.

the most important question….

should israel have been created???
-why?
-why not?

what can we say about the modern conflict " israel vs palestine"?
who has the right to the lands in modern day israel and palestine?
if these modern day jews don't originate from israel then why do they claim ownership of israel?
if you believe these jews are the original inhabitants of these lands then who are the palestinains?
and what shall be done with the palestinians?
what can be the solution for the both people?
does one of the 2 groups have to leave?

Israel has full right to survive and answer to all the agression it has been subjected to ...we indian willalways support israel .. no matter what

 

[BDforever]

Israel has full right to survive and answer to all the agression it has been subjected to ...we indian willalways support israel .. no matter what

interms of killing civilian too ?

 

[Ahmad1996]

Israel has full right to survive and answer to all the agression it has been subjected to ...we indian willalways support israel .. no matter what

Yes that's what we need, another blind supporter.

 

[GURU DUTT]

interms of killing civilian too ?

well if hamas is using civillians as shield to carry owt agression against civillians of israel (firing rocket from civillian areas and using amulences for tranporting rockets and using schools and hospitals as launch sites ) then israel has every right to deal with hamas and answer them back in the same language as they are putting questions to israel thereshould be no mercy & remose in dealing with supporters and perpetrators of terrorism directed against islraeli citizens

 

[PlanetWarrior]

In a thousand years, if Mecca and Medina has been conquered by Christians and is inhabited by a large population of Christians, would Muslims accept that Mecca and Medina are Christian territories? I am raising this question in an attempt to draw a correlation between the Jewish claim and a parallel religion

 

[Ahmad1996]

Will you guys just stop? Just read what I wrote earlier or what Burgerboy wrote. Stop comparing things, just look whether justice has been done, how the conflict could be avoided or how Israel helped in the creation of Hamas, Yes Israel created Hamas so it could stop Hezbollah, one of the strongest military groups in ME.

Some thinktank you are Fauji, Pakistanis or any other Muslim country will support Israel's right to exist the day the partition is done properly....30% gets 56% land and people who are in majority i.e 70% get 46% land, what were you expecting them to do, celebrate? Its people like you who never understood the Palestinian or the Muslims reason to support Palestinians, people like you who allow Israel to create a nuclear bomb but if someone else starts you have a problem with it, people like you who don't know the meaning of justice. Think about it my friends had the partition been done properly would this problem be ever there? No, Muslims who say they don't support the right of Israel to exist say this mostly in anger due to the unjustice done to Palestinians, they never would have, had the UN played fairly, don't forget UN is a child of America what America says UN follows.

 

[BDforever]

In a thousand years, if Mecca and Medina has been conquered by Christians and is inhabited by a large population of Christians, would Muslims accept that Mecca and Medina are Christian territories? I am raising this question in an attempt to draw a correlation between the Jewish claim and a parallel religion

christian ? since when ?

well if hamas is using civillians as shield to carry owt agression against civillians of israel (firing rocket from civillian areas and using amulences for tranporting rockets and using schools and hospitals as launch sites ) then israel has every right to deal with hamas and answer them back in the same language as they are putting questions to israel thereshould be no mercy & remose in dealing with supporters and perpetrators of terrorism directed against islraeli citizens

we are talking about Palestinian civilian, so are agreeing to kill civilian ?

 

[PlanetWarrior]

christian ? since when ?

Dude read my post before commenting. I raised a hypothetical question

 

[KRAIT]

Yes. Just like any other country.

 

[BDforever]

Dude read my post before commenting. I raised a hypothetical question

Kabba area will not be Christian territory since it is Muslim Holy land just like Vatican City

Yes. Just like any other country.

welcome back

 

[PlanetWarrior]

Kabba area will not be Christian territory since it is Muslim Holy land just like Vatican City

So, the Jews regard Israel as their holy land ? Or am I wrong in my assumption ?

 

[BDforever]

So, the Jews regard Israel as their holy land ? Or am I wrong in my assumption ?

No, because they could live in holy land being Palestinian and even visit, do not need to create Israel. got the point ?

 

[ashok321]

yes but which of these jews are originally from israel?
80 percent of modern day israeli jews are from russia, poland, germany and surrounding countries in europe…
so should israel have been created???

And the rest 20% ?
Did they fall from sky?