"Disgust' over Muslim wife-beating book

[ephone]

They have such "book" to teach men how to torture women???

They are trying to say it happens everywhere, so there is no need to single out Muslims.

 

[RazPaK]

They have such "book" to teach men how to torture women???

Nobody should hit anyone. However that is not to say it doesn't happen. All Abrahamic religions allow you to hit your wife, but think about the context. It was relevant to the times.

If one hits their wife, they have domestic issues rather than religious ones.

 

[ephone]

You need to make clear the issue.

Here we are not talk about domestic dispute or violence.

Here we are talk about a so-called muslim scholar who publish a book to teach men it is ok to torture your women in certain ways.
No matter how you want to twist it, beautify it, at the end of day, it is still hideous.

Nobody should hit anyone. However that is not to say it doesn't happen. All Abrahamic religions allow you to hit your wife, but think about the context. It was relevant to the times.

If one hits their wife, they have domestic issues rather than religious ones.

 

[King Solomon]

OTTAWA -- Canada's political leaders aren't impressed with an Islamic marriage guide offering tips on ear-pulling and slapping, and the fact it's sold out at a Toronto bookstore.

"The contents of this book are disgusting," said Ana Curic, director of communications for Citizenship and Immigration Minister Jason Kenney. "Spousal abuse is a despicable crime and the person who wrote the book should be ashamed of himself."

The book, entitled A Gift for Muslim Couple, by Maulavi Ashraf Ali Thanvi, advises that a husband shouldn't beat his wife too hard, but pulling her ears and hitting her with a hand or a stick is all right for discipline.

The 160-page book also offers tips on how to confine a wife to the home and withhold cash if she acts up.

Kenney's office notes that the new citizenship guide specifically mentions that savage treatment of women in Canada is forbidden.

"The guide now says, 'In Canada, men and women are equal under the law. Canada's openness and generosity do not extend to barbaric cultural practices that tolerate spousal abuse, honour killings, female genital mutilation, forced marriage or other gender-based violence'," Curic said.

Interim Liberal leader Bob Rae was not comfortable with the book being sold in Canada.

"It's deeply troubling, these are all things that are against the law in Canada and they fly in the face of our common morals, our sense of fairness and equality," Rae said. "We have clear laws about forcible confinement, and with respect to abusive behaviour and physical violence - this is not how life is lived in Canada."

The book is sold out at the Islamic Books and Souvenirs shop, but it's not known how many copies were in stock.

Also on the store website is a book, entitled Fatwas of Muslim Women, by Ibn Taymyah, which describes the best way to circumcise a woman and explains which babies a woman is allowed to breastfeed.

The owner of the store selling the controversial marriage guide said it would be "stupid" to order more copies.

"It would be stupid to get more copies," Shamim Ahmad said, refusing to answer any more questions on the advice of his lawyer. "I'm not going to talk. My attorney ... advised me and that is it."

Ahmad also refused to comment on the international attention -- and outrage -- the story has generated, having been picked up by media outlets both in the United Kingdom and the U.S.

Moderate Muslim voice Tarek Fatah, who, after the story first broke, said Ahmad "should be charged" for selling such a book, told QMI Agency on Monday that while it is "cute" that Ahmad has now stopped selling A Gift for Muslim Couple, many more books sit on the store's shelves and others in the Greater Toronto Area that promote something even more "dangerous" than spousal abuse: war -- or Jihad -- against the Western world.

"There are other books ... that have amazing attacks on Western civilization," said Fatah. "The books that are promoting Jihad are far more dangerous."

'Disgust' over Muslim wife-beating book | Ontario | News | Toronto Sun

This is an utter shame. If the report is true, the writer should be jailed.

 

[RazPaK]

You need to make clear the issue.

Here we are not talk about domestic dispute or violence.

Here we are talk about a so-called muslim scholar who publish a book to teach men it is ok to torture your women in certain ways.
No matter how you want to twist it, beautify it, at the end of day, it is still hideous.

To be fair, you haven't read it and to say he incites torturing women is intellectual dishonesty on your part.

Also he is a scholar with an opinion.

Opinions are like assholes, everyone's got one.

 

[Safriz]

To be fair, you haven't read it and to say he incites torturing women is intellectual dishonesty on your part.

Also he is a scholar with an opinion.

Opinions are like assholes, everyone's got one.

bitc.h please

its a different story when assholes with no logics and no arguments try to impose their opinion.on us by abundant use of abusive language..ephone this comment is about you.

 

[ephone]

The problem is that this asshole has certain influence over other muslim males and also encourage other muslim males to buy it and follow it. Indeed there are many muslim males who bought it as well. That is the problem.

To be fair, you haven't read it and to say he incites torturing women is intellectual dishonesty on your part.

Also he is a scholar with an opinion.

Opinions are like assholes, everyone's got one.

 

[RazPaK]

The problem is that this asshole has certain influence over other muslim males and also encourage other muslim males to buy it and follow it. Indeed there are many muslim males who bought it as well. That is the problem.

Let me remind you in the US, neo-nazis and KKK can publish whatever the hell they want. It doesn't mean squat.

 

[ephone]

Aren't you having a slightest feeling called shame???

I bet even a s.o.b still has some of that. It seems that you are lower than that.

Of course, how silly am I to be surprised???!!! An idiot who think torturing women is ok apparently should be excluded from the term: human being.

bitc.h please

its a different story when assholes with no logics and no arguments try to impose their opinion.on us by abundant use of abusive language..ephone this comment is about you.

Why don't you tell me which book stores currently sell the so-called neo-nazis and kkk books legally???

Let me remind you in the US, neo-nazis and KKK can publish whatever the hell they want. It doesn't mean squat.

So far, I have not even seen one muslim member who dare to stand up to tell their fellow muslim members are wrong on this.

What a shame.

This is an utter shame. If the report is true, the writer should be jailed.

 

[notsuperstitious]

Again champions of logical fallacies are at it.

1st fallacy - It happens everywhere so its OK for us to propagate it

2nd fallacy - Two consenting adults can do many things legally, hence its OK to do the same to non consenting adults too

Why don't these people just clarify this is islamically forbidden then haters will simply stop linking it with their religion.

 

[RazPaK]

Why don't you tell me which book stores currently sell the so-called neo-nazis and kkk books legally???

Go to Barnes and Nobles and buy yourself a copy of Mein Kampf. Neo-nazis even have radio stations and spew their crap on national radio too.

Again champions of logical fallacies are at it.

1st fallacy - It happens everywhere so its OK for us to propagate it

2nd fallacy - Two consenting adults can do many things legally, hence its OK to do the same to non consenting adults too

Why don't these people just clarify this is islamically forbidden then haters will simply stop linking it with their religion.

The only fallacy here is linking one man to about one billion Muslims around the world.

 

[Karachiite]

A Dogs tail can not be straightened.

 

[Safriz]

Aren't you having a slightest feeling called shame???

I bet even a s.o.b still has some of that. It seems that you are lower than that.

Of course, how silly am I to be surprised???!!! An idiot who think torturing women is ok apparently should be excluded from the term: human being.



Why don't you tell me which book stores currently sell the so-called neo-nazis and kkk books legally???



So far, I have not even seen one muslim member who dare to stand up to tell their fellow muslim members are wrong on this.

What a shame.

since too much garbage is being spewed in here by you.....i would ask you are fixated at using the word "asshole" in every comment of yours...may be its your middle name...

before you write any more anti muslim hate....go and google the keyword "sadism" and try Amazon.com and look at the hundreds of thousands of books available on this.....and google will tell you sadism is pure torture...
now will you raise your voice against sadism and ask for a total ban?

 

[notsuperstitious]

The only fallacy here is linking one man to about one billion Muslims around the world.

One person? Islamic court: OK to beat wife if no marks left - World news - Mideast/N. Africa - msnbc.com

Besides if I started selling books in Singapore telling people women should be burned on their husband's funeral pyres (and its not even legal in India, unlike the beating case, where its legal in parts of the world) then what do you think the local population will think of the immigrants?

 

[ephone]

That is so-called auto-biography from a great evil to give the later generation to see how a great evil was developed and came unto power. It is not a daily life teaching book.

We have pearl harbor movies that show how japs bombers bombed pearl harbor during wwii. We have tons of movies to show how nazis tortured and killed jews.

All of those just try to expose those great evils so that the later generations can remember the historical lessons and prevent it from happening again. People do not use Mein Kampf to teach people how to be next hitler. Yours do teach people how to torture women and indicate that is OK.

Your women torturing book can not be discussed together with those.

Go to Barnes and Nobles and buy yourself a copy of Mein Kampf. Neo-nazis even have radio stations and spew their crap on national radio too.



The only fallacy here is linking one man to about one billion Muslims around the world.

Listing other wrongs (e.g. sadism) will make yours (torturing women) correct???

Ask your fellow muslim members to stop spewing garbage first.

since too much garbage is being spewed in here by you.....i would ask you are fixated at using the word "asshole" in every comment of yours...may be its your middle name...

before you write any more anti muslim hate....go and google the keyword "sadism" and try Amazon.com and look at the hundreds of thousands of books available on this.....and google will tell you sadism is pure torture...
now will you raise your voice against sadism and ask for a total ban?