Differences in the professionalism of Indian soldier and a Pakistani soldie

[Lonely Hermit]

no its not me who is dragging whole army i ve concentrated only soldier in question.it you guys who are generalising.

Then if you take the deeds of individuals to genralize them i can also start quiet a lot threads ranting about illogiacl things. Have you even considered in what circumstance did the officer in question made such a statement. Probably he lost a close friend or something after all they where in the middle of a war.

socialism will remain in india till there will be poor in india.socialism is still thriving and kicking in india.

Even though the rest of the world has abandoned it and also failed miserably in India. The only country which was successfully able to implement socialist system was Cuba. But my reservation against it are the same it goes against human mentality

Plz rea-read from post one.i dont wana type same thing again and again.

Sorry Lady i don't understand gibberish.

bollywood is mirror to the society it reflects what happens in society.

Yeah right Item dance and guys surounded by hot chicks are the mirror of our society.

President is just ceremonious post also known as rubber stamp.The day you have muslim PM then boast untill then keep quite.

Yeah agree remember Punjab insurgency 84 Sikh riots i dont know if you have noticed it but we happend to have a Sikh PM, any way most of the time India has been ruled by Nehru Gandhi family.

what above all has to do with secularism. these people watever they did due to their talents.

Yes they did that without any hostile or discriminatory policy of the majority Hindus. I forgot to add Bollywood do you think if the average Indian was Obsessed about religion as you are then the Khans of Bollywood would have been as sucessfull as today.

 

[KRAIT]

because islam teaches us to be kind to all, a difference in faith can be a difference in after life but in this world we have to live together and are all the same, where is some honour to be so rude especially the likes of indian soldier who should have been very kind for the generous offer to treat the enemy soldier

He did say wrong but he admitted his fault, isn't it enough....The End

 

[Ajaxpaul]

then what u doing in this thread????

Now you are questioning my presence in PDF thread ?

If defence.pk is yours, then You can order me to stay away. If not, it is my duty to comment on topics related to India and all countries.

As for your sentiments...Its BS and nobody cares..Its the truth, you dont have to get angry with me

 

[Meluhan]

bollywood is mirror to the society it reflects what happens in society.

lol .. but the same bollywood produce movies like Loc , agent vinod , kurban ,azaan ,a wednesday etc etc ..

 

[KRAIT]

I wanted to focus on that particular attitude which has long persisted and still do in indian society and u all pounced on me like wolves and diverted the whole thing.

Here you go, yo stated a story and then eventually wanted to discuss about entire Indian society....whereas you accused me of generalizing rather than admitting that you did it....You knew generalization will follow and it did.....if you want to discuss such subjects start with introduction at broader scale then quote examples at related part and sum it up with some conclusion that we can reply in that fashion.....not playing word games...pouring out anything that comes in your mind.

You want to convey your POV and ideas, observation, first change presentation....No offence

 

[acetophenol]

http://www.defence.pk/forums/indian-defence/146384-i-cut-my-leg-ordered-bury-war-heroes-tale.html


I was reading the above thread where fellow indians call it truly inspiring story of 1971 war.But i call it low level of professionalism from Major General Ian Cardozo says...



Even enemy shows respect but when major general says he dont want to be treated by the pakistani surgeon and he dont want any pakistani blood then it shows his gutter level thinking.On ther other hand Major Bahseer the pakistani surgeon treats major general as his pairient rather than his enemy even during war time and does his duity as human being for which he took oath as doctor to treat his paitient to best of his abilities.

I wonder What those cliches' they show in indian movies about attitudes of indians towards muslim fellow indian like...

"i dont want to be treated by muslim"
"i dont want dirty muslim blood"

etc are not merely as cliches' but sadly a dark truth of indian society which got out in this incident.

Really there isn't words to describe your level of common sense.

 

[Fazlu]

Isn't 'cardozo' a Christian ? Just out of curiosity.

 

[OrionHunter]

i want to ask something to all indian members here...
is there a way to we can ask mods to check whether somebody is a false falger????

I totally agree! This OP is nothing but a false flagger. An Indian can't be that idiotic to write such baloney. It should be yanked off the forum pronto. But probably the mods are loving this clap trap and therefore doing zilch about it.

 

[shrivatsa]

Isn't 'cardozo' a Christian ? Just out of curiosity.

yes he is a christian, a great soldier. Taking treatment or refusing it is his personal matter. For us its important whether he fought bravely or not by the looks of it he did.

 

[KRAIT]

Lets not insult her....she has freedom of speech even if she seems completely wrong....She has her own POV and can openly point out bad things of our society...even if her way is not acceptable. Over and out from this thread.

 

[Lonely Hermit]

I totally agree! This OP is nothing but a false flagger. An Indian can't be that idiotic to write such baloney. It should be yanked off the forum pronto. But probably the mods are loving this clap trap and therefore doing zilch about it.

Oh no the OP is very much an Indian but she is of the sort who are pathetic attention seeker like Arundhati Roy. Who live in their own fantasy world with impractical ideas. People like OP call others bigots but are themselves the biggest hypocrites in our country.

Lets not insult her....she has freedom of speech even if she seems completely wrong....She has her own POV and can openly point out bad things of our society...even if her way is not acceptable. Over and out from this thread.

What right does OP have to talk **** about our soldiers, when these are the same soldiers who are protecting as against the likes of Ajmal Kasab hell bent on destroying our fabric of our society.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

PA is highly professional unit....they have four successful coups under their belt....IA doesn't have any

Hope indian soldiers also sto shooting their superiors and commiting suicides... rapes and murders...

 

[majesticpankaj]

Hope indian soldiers also sto shooting their superiors and commiting suicides... rapes and murders...

when that happened ? and for information your Army had killed more than 3 millions Bangladeshis and uncountable balouchis...

 

[ajtr]

because islam teaches us to be kind to all, a difference in faith can be a difference in after life but in this world we have to live together and are all the same, where is some honour to be so rude especially the likes of indian soldier who should have been very kind for the generous offer to treat the enemy soldier

That was the main point i was trying to point out but it got all trolled on every subject except this.

 

[SEAL]

Both armies are professional in my opinion such attitude and poor professionalism exists only in brain washed right wing soldiers. For example the master mind behind Samjhota express blast was Lt Colonel in IA but he was brain washed with terrorist ideology.