What's new

Dawn Leaks: Government’s next cover-up strategy?

GlobalVillageSpace

Media Partner
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Messages
993
Reaction score
1
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Dawn Leaks: Government’s next cover-up strategy?
Global Village Space |


Ikram Sehgal |

Facing the storm unleashed by the leaking of the Cyril Almeida story, “Act Against Militants or Face International Isolation, Civilians Tell Military,” the Nawaz Sharif government labeled it as being “fabricated and planted”. The PM Office’s initial statement about DawnLeaks that “evidence available so far points to a lapse on part of the Information Minister, who has been directed to step down from office to enable holding of an independent and detailed inquiry” was dismissed vehemently as “fiction”. Sacrificial lamb Pervaiz Rasheed has now come out of enforced hibernation to confirm this.

Headed by retired judge Aamer Raza Khan, a seven-member Committee was supposed to submit their findings within 30 days, what should have taken not more than 72 hours, has taken six months. This cemented the public perception of an attempted “cover-up” to absolve “someone” really close to the PM. As disclosed, at least up till now, the report submitted to the PM on May 23 by Interior Minister Ch Nisar Ali Khan does not indict those universally believed to have done the dirty work fabricating the false story and then leaking it.

Read more: Dawn Leaks notification: Is the PM side-stepping from the real case?

Silence is deafening
The persistent attempt at cover-up by the govt reinforces the public perception of someone important responsible for the treasonable act being protected.

A notification surfaced from the PM’s Office “de-notifying” Tariq Fatemi, Special Assistant to the PM for Foreign Affairs (SAPM). Received with disbelief, the matter becoming even less credible because the de-notifying “notification” was issued by someone suspected of being in the Dawn Leaks chain himself, the PM’s Principal Secretary Fawad Hassan Fawad. PPP leader Qamar Zaman Kaira echoed the mass public perception about the government “protecting someone” and that no sane individual would believe these “findings”.

Maryam Nawaz’s Trump-like tweets notwithstanding, the government seems to have started faltering finding scapegoats in continuing to filibuster punishing the real culprits. Tariq Fatemi refused to fall on his sword. Vehemently rejecting the allegations in a farewell missive to his colleagues in the Foreign Office on leaving his post, the former SAPM followed the Sufi saying, “read between the lines, it tires the eyes less”.

He pointedly failed to even once make any mention whatsoever about his beloved mentor whom he slavishly served day and night for years. This profound silence about Mian Nawaz Sharif was deafening! This reinforced the PTI leaders querying whether the PM, his daughter Maryam and Fawad were interrogated. The persistent attempt at a cover-up by the govt reinforces the public perception of someone important responsible for the treasonable act being protected.

Read more: Tariq Fatemi Rejects Inquiry Committee’s Allegation; Implications?

Strained civil-military relations
The gentlemanly Raheel Shareef balked in the face of Mian Nawaz Sharif’s crocodile tears and unfairly left the mess for Qamar Jawed Bajwa to clean up. The delay in close will damage civil-military relations.


Read full article:
Dawn Leaks: Government’s next cover-up strategy?
 
.
all those involved should be arrested and tried under official secret act of 1923 and sent to minimum 14 years in jail
 
.
Sab eek hain... sab choor hain eek doosray ko bacha rahay hain... ye hey Qaid ka Pakistan inhe logoon kiliye banaya tha... koon is mulk may apnay bachay rakhna chahayga jahan ghar se bahir nikloo koi b goli maarkar chala jaye koi poochnay wala nahi... my foot National Security.. bc Nemogate pr kia pahtlia tha inhonay.. as I said sab eek hain...
 
.
Ch. Nisar may try to sell the PMLN strategy by terming it as "fabricated" news aka Dawn Leaks.

Issue is; after ISPR's rejection of Rao & Fatemi flavoured lollipop, PMLN is in a fix; as posturing revisions are not auguring well on a report which was termed as national security breach by none other than Ch. Nisar himself when pressure on admission of fault was high from CCC on RS.

Now, if no conviction happens and perpetrators are not tried as per Army Act; then no posturing can save PMLN nor Army for it will effectively mean; that stance has been changed and both parties involved have settled on a point, which unequivocally was national security breach.

PMLN has already shot itself several times in handling of this issue; they (senior leaders) are not comfortable as they have lost everything to Army to save one person of Sharif family. One of the hawks in PMLN has stated somewhat like this; even if band aid is applied to this wound; it will temporary and we will always be in blackmailed status as evidence is with not only with MI & ISI, but also with IB, and at some point in future it can be leaked (intentionally or unintentionally) which will finish the party as sedition case could be started on future PM of PMLN.

So even if mellowed down consensus report is published; that does not solve the existing or future issues for Sharifs, and a lot of senior members (6 that I know of) are strongly advocating for in house change without Sharif's as in charge or else face fate worse then PPP.

Whatever will be the outcome; Sharif has been chained due to his resistance to let power go on self admitted and conceded national security breach from PM Office of sitting Prime Minister and saving her daughter and is ready to put on line the fate of entire party to save Maryam.

Sharif is taking a very miscalculated risk on which he has put his own party leaders as opponents to Sharifs. There are very few cards left in the game - worst fact is; all are with the other party quipped another non elected member I had spoken to an hour ago.

Let's see what report comes out for public perception - in reality; Sharifs seems to be fighting not a losing battle - but a lost battle!

Anyone remember; what Pervez Rashid recently stated; it wasn't his duty to block/stop "the planted" news, Rao's request for complete report for his lawyers to challenge in court, and Fatemi's letter strangely published for the world to see that he rejects the charges and had no hand. The choices of sacrificial lambs PMLN for sacrifice are exhausted; they have fired all the three bullets they had in the chamber; what new will come out in Ch. Nisar's report? :big_boss:


Please read the below story reported by Reuters last year to understand the context of my above post. Thanks!!

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

MIDDLE EAST & NORTH AFRICA | Sat Oct 29, 2016 | 9:44am EDT
Pakistan information minister removed over newspaper leak that angered army

By Asad Hashim and Sheree Sardar | ISLAMABAD

Pakistani Information Minister Pervaiz Rashid has been removed from office over a newspaper leak that sparked a rift between the army and the government earlier this month, the prime minister's office said on Saturday.

Two sources from the Information Ministry told Reuters that Rashid had stepped down from his post until an inquiry confirms whether he was the source for a newspaper article detailing the discussion in a top-level national security meeting.

"Evidence available so far points to a lapse on part of the Information Minister, who has been directed to step down from office to enable holding of an independent and detailed inquiry," a statement by the prime minister's office said.

The inquiry is seeking to identify the source of the Dawn article, published on Oct. 6, which gave an account of a tense, high-level security meeting held between military and government officials.

Government and diplomatic sources say the Dawn article soured relations between Sharif's ruling PML-N party and the military, with army officials blaming PML-N for the leak and demanding the source be punished.

Relations between the civilian government and military have often been strained in a country where several prime ministers, including Sharif himself, have been ousted in coups.

Quoting anonymous sources, the Dawn article said civilian government officials called for the military not to interfere if civilian authorities tried to arrest members of anti-India militant groups such as Jaish-e-Mohammad and Lashkar-e-Taiba.

India has long accused Pakistan's military of sponsoring these groups to foment unrest in Indian-administered Kashmir and elsewhere, a charge that Pakistan denies.

The office of Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has repeatedly rejected the article as inaccurate and the journalist who wrote it was at one point temporarily barred from leaving the country.

On Saturday, the prime minister's office said the Oct. 6 story was "planted" and termed it a "breach of national security". Dawn newspaper editors have stood by the story and its author.

The committee being set up to investigate the leak includes senior officers from the ISI, the most powerful intelligence agency in Pakistan. Military Intelligence and Intelligence Bureau agencies will be in involved in the committee.

The military on Friday said top PML-N leaders - including finance minister, interior minister, and Sharif's brother - met the army chief Raheel Sharif, who is not related to the prime minister, to discuss the Dawn leak. The head of ISI was also present

Rashid did not respond to Reuters requests for comment. The military could not be immediately reached for comment.

(Writing by Drazen Jorgic; Editing by Mark Heinrich and Stephen Powell)
 
Last edited:
.
Ch. Nisar may try to sell the PMLN strategy by terming it as "fabricated" news aka Dawn Leaks.

Issue is; after ISPR's rejection of Rao & Fatemi flavoured lollipop, PMLN is in a fix; as posturing revisions are not auguring well on a report which was termed as national security breach by none other than Ch. Nisar himself when pressure on admission of fault was high from CCC on RS.

Now, if no conviction happens and perpetrators are not tried as per Army Act; then no posturing can save PMLN nor Army for it will effectively mean; that stance has been changed and both parties involved have settled on a point, which unequivocally was national security breach.

PMLN has already shot itself several times in handling of this issue; they (senior leaders) are not comfortable as they have lost everything to Army to save one person of Sharif family. One of the hawks in PMLN has stated somewhat like this; even if band aid is applied to this wound; it will temporary and we will always be in blackmailed status as evidence is with not only with MI & ISI, but also with IB, and at some point in future it can be leaked (intentionally or unintentionally) which will finish the party as sedition case could be started on future PM of PMLN.

So even if mellowed down consensus report is published; that does not solve the existing or future issues for Sharifs, and a lot of senior members (6 that I know of) are strongly advocating for in house change without Sharif's as in charge or else face fate worse then PPP.

Whatever will be the outcome; Sharif has been chained due to his resistance to let power go on self admitted and conceded national security breach from PM Office of sitting Prime Minister and saving her daughter and is ready to put on line the fate of entire party to save Maryam.

Sharif is taking a very miscalculated risk on which he has put his own party leaders as opponents to Sharifs. There are very few cards left in the game - worst fact is; all are with the other party quipped another non elected member I had spoken to an hour ago.

Let's see what report comes out for public perception - in reality; Sharifs seems to be fighting not a losing battle - but a lost battle!

Anyone remember; what Pervez Rashid recently stated; it wasn't his duty to block/stop "the planted" news, Rao's request for complete report for his lawyers to challenge in court, and Fatemi's letter strangely published for the world to see that he rejects the charges and had no hand. The choices of sacrificial lambs PMLN for sacrifice are exhausted; they have fired all the three bullets they had in the chamber; what new will come out in Ch. Nisar's report? :big_boss:

Two things are very important on this dawn leaks issue

1) first.. ALL culprits in dawn leaks report should be tried under army act for sedition...and not just only sacked from their positions ( those who were in govt positions). Sacking alone is not enough at all for them...Rather all should be tried under army act, so tht no one else in the futures dares to do such a thing,

2) if..somehow a mellowed down report is agreed upon by the army and govt (which will be extremely bad for army's own image) then...whole original report, esp those pages from MI and ISI's report on which govt had objections...should be leaked to the media straight away...so tht atleast names of actual culprits come out in public.. Actually everryone already knows the actual culprits but, their names in ISI and MI's report will have a different impact altogether.. So whole report should be leaked soon..otherwise anything less than this, it will be seen as another NRO, and will be extremely bad for army's image.. So culprits should be tried under army act, and along with tht whole report should be leaked...
Since, MI and ISI officials in this dawn leaks committee, are the same ppl, who are in Panama JIT also, so their credibility should not be compromised upon...before panama JIT.. Public should have trust on them, and if somehow a perception of NRO on dawn leaks is strengthened..it will be bad for whole instituition, and their presence in panama JIT, will not be seen as good omen by the public... Although, i will say tht these members might themselves not be responsible at all, for the NRO on dawn leaks.. Obviously such deals (if they occur) happen at leadership level and not their level... But still, army should maintain their credibility in the eyes of public, since panama JIT has also started its work..so these two steps, which i mentioned..should be minimum steps to negate any impression of NRO
 
. .
ڈان لیکس کی مثال ایسی ہے کہ ایک گھر میں بہت سے پالتو جانور ہوں اور ایک پالتو کتا کسی گھر والے کو کاٹ لے، گھر کا سیکورٹی گارڈ اس بات کا گواہ ہو، لیکن گھر کا سربراہ اور سیکورٹی گارڈ فیصلہ کریں کہ کبوتر اور مرغی کو گھر سے باہر نکال دینا چاہیے کیونکہ انہوں نے کتے کو کاٹنے سے نہیں روکا.. اور کتے کو گھر کے اندر رہنے کی اجازت دیدیں
 
.
ڈان لیکس کی مثال ایسی ہے کہ ایک گھر میں بہت سے پالتو جانور ہوں اور ایک پالتو کتا کسی گھر والے کو کاٹ لے، گھر کا سیکورٹی گارڈ اس بات کا گواہ ہو، لیکن گھر کا سربراہ اور سیکورٹی گارڈ فیصلہ کریں کہ کبوتر اور مرغی کو گھر سے باہر نکال دینا چاہیے کیونکہ انہوں نے کتے کو کاٹنے سے نہیں روکا.. اور کتے کو گھر کے اندر رہنے کی اجازت دیدیں

:lol:

Baat tu sach hai, magar ruswayi ki :( :( :(
 
.
@PakSword @Farah Sohail Nothing is going to happen, don't waste your time on this dawn leaks or Panama. I do not see a bright future for Pakistan or its people. Unless there is a bloody revolution where the people actually drag all the corrupts in the streets and hang them in public.

I am afraid to say it but to me Pakistan looks like its on the path to being like Afghanistan or Libya or Somalia
 
.
@PakSword @Farah Sohail Nothing is going to happen, don't waste your time on this dawn leaks or Panama. I do not see a bright future for Pakistan or its people. Unless there is a bloody revolution where the people actually drag all the corrupts in the streets and hang them in public.

I am afraid to say it but to me Pakistan looks like its on the path to being like Afghanistan or Libya or Somalia

Abhi tou IK disqualify honay ja raha hai.. uss ke upar discussion horahi hai Panama case walay thread pe..

Yeh tou hamain sab ko maloom hai ke Dawn Leaks ka kuch nahi honay wala..
 
.
The government has played their card with the new PEMRA drama.
 
.
The government has played their card with the new PEMRA drama.

The call where caller could hear the dial tone. When did it happen that receiver can hear the dial tone - as per the call it means the Caller Recorded and sent it to receiver to catch him. What a joke!

Absar Alam took clue from stage drama - should have seen at least a lollywood film to draft a better case.

And when Absar Alam seeks help to catch the perpetrator from COAS - his own master is PM - what is he doing - is N$ not even capable to protect PEMRA's employees.

Is it a no confidence of PEMRA in civilian institutions ?!?
 
.
Two things are very important on this dawn leaks issue

1) first.. ALL culprits in dawn leaks report should be tried under army act for sedition...and not just only sacked from their positions ( those who were in govt positions). Sacking alone is not enough at all for them...Rather all should be tried under army act, so tht no one else in the futures dares to do such a thing,

Never saw such a declaration when contents of Core Commnaders conference were leaked in 2014. I am sure there was no civilian there. Any comments ?

Here the link
http://www.reuters.com/article/pakistan-crisis-army-idINKBN0H015K20140905?irpc=932

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/army-chief-holds-off-generals-seeking-pakistan-pms-ouster.332494/
 
Last edited:
.
@Farah Sohail - you will know others have lost it when they start comparing apples to oranges or worst when trying to justify one wrong with another wrong.

You'll sometimes see comparison between self admitted national security breach and reports based on he said/she said and didn't disclose his/her name.

In the meanwhile; just relish and enjoy those comparisons!
 
.
@Farah Sohail - you will know others have lost it when they start comparing apples to oranges or worst when trying to justify one wrong with another wrong.

You'll sometimes see comparison between self admitted national security breach and reports based on he said/she said and didn't disclose his/her name.

In the meanwhile; just relish and enjoy those comparisons!
https://www.dawn.com/news/1288350

Try to read Dawn story. I doubt if you have read it. Parh to lia karo don't you know PDF rules. Here read its excerpts:

All declined to speak on the record and none of the attributed statements were confirmed by the individuals mentioned.....

Several eyewitnesses to the incredible events of Monday believe that the foreign secretary’s presentation...

According to several government officials ........

According to one official, commenting on the ISI DG’s ......

Another government official offered: “Wait till November ......
 
.
Back
Top Bottom