Daughter of an RSS extremist who used to run campaigns against "Love Jihad" marries a Muslim guy

[proudindian20]

Muslim Guy? Muslim is someone who follow Islamic teaching and ruling. Islamic ruling say it very clearly that Muslim man or woman cannot marry mushrik (polytheist) ..Don't judge Islam based on what Shah rukh or salman do in India because they are very much following deen ilahi of Akbar by mixing boht Hinduism and Islam to please boht of them lol They are stars because of fans so they have to make their fans happy which belong to boht religion

That's what I'm saying Indian muslims follow a different version of Islam than Pakistani muslims.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

That's what I'm saying Indian muslims follow a different version of Islam than Pakistani muslims.

Its not about Pakistani vs Indian version. All Muslims suppose to follow the Islamic scripture Holy Quran which make it forbidden for Muslim man or woman to marry with polytheists.

The Quran states:

• Do not marry polytheist woman until she believes; a slave believing woman is better than polytheist women though she allures you; Do not marry (your girls) to polytheist man until he believes: A man slave who believes is better than an polytheist man, even though he allures you. They do (but) beckon you to the Fire. But God beckons by His Grace to the Garden (of bliss) and forgiveness, and makes His Signs clear to mankind: so that they may understand. (Al-Quran 2:221)
• O ye who believe! When there come to you believing women refugees, examine (and test) them: God knows best as to their Faith: if ye ascertain that they are Believers, then send them not back to the Unbelievers. They are not lawful wives for the Unbelievers, nor are the Unbelievers lawful husbands for them. (Al-Quran 60:10)
• It is not lawful by Allah Almighty for Muslim women to marry non Muslim men of any faith. (Quran 2:221 60:10 4:141)

 

[masterchief_mirza]

That's what I'm saying Indian muslims follow a different version of Islam than Pakistani muslims.

Nothing wrong with Pakistan's "version". You keep your versions of whatever.

 

[proudindian20]

Its not about Pakistani vs Indian version. All Muslims suppose to follow the Islamic scripture Holy Quran which make it forbidden for Muslim man or woman to marry with polytheists.

The Quran states:

• Do not marry polytheist woman until she believes; a slave believing woman is better than polytheist women though she allures you; Do not marry (your girls) to polytheist man until he believes: A man slave who believes is better than an polytheist man, even though he allures you. They do (but) beckon you to the Fire. But God beckons by His Grace to the Garden (of bliss) and forgiveness, and makes His Signs clear to mankind: so that they may understand. (Al-Quran 2:221)
• O ye who believe! When there come to you believing women refugees, examine (and test) them: God knows best as to their Faith: if ye ascertain that they are Believers, then send them not back to the Unbelievers. They are not lawful wives for the Unbelievers, nor are the Unbelievers lawful husbands for them. (Al-Quran 60:10)
• It is not lawful by Allah Almighty for Muslim women to marry non Muslim men of any faith. (Quran 2:221 60:10 4:141)

Which doesn't happen in real life. People marry each other based on whether they like each other or not. So pretty much disproves your point. You're talking about the ideal situation which never happens in real life.

Nothing wrong with Pakistan's "version". You keep your versions of whatever.

Exactly! Nothing wrong with each of the version. That's why it's funny to see when Paksitanis jump with joy when a muslim boy marries a hindu girl in India as if it's some kind of victory lol

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Which doesn't happen in real life. People marry each other based on whether they like each other or not. So pretty much disproves your point. You're talking about the ideal situation which never happens in real life.

Depend what is important for people. Religion is not important for some people so they may ignore teaching of their religion but it still don't make such marriage as valid as per Islam . If love for God is more powerful than love for Girl/boy then you will never reject the teaching of God for worldly love.

 

[proudindian20]

Depend what is important for people. Religion is not important for some people so they may ignore teaching of their religion but it still don't make such marriage as valid as per Islam . If love for God is more powerful than love for Girl/boy then you will never reject the teaching of God for worldly love.

Ok I respect your view buddy. For me it's the latter. Ultimately you spend your life with the girl not God. Just my 2 cents.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Which doesn't happen in real life. People marry each other based on whether they like each other or not. So pretty much disproves your point. You're talking about the ideal situation which never happens in real life.



Exactly! Nothing wrong with each of the version. That's why it's funny to see when Paksitanis jump with joy when a muslim boy marries a hindu girl in India as if it's some kind of victory lol

No...the two issues are unrelated. Different interpretations of Islam in Pak and India have nothing to do with Indian Hindus being trolled over a love jihadi's victory. Anyone who is anti-India will take the chance to troll you whether they are wahhabi or atheist or anything in between. You just don't seem to get that.

Let me spell it out for you. I am thrilled over every single love jihadist's victory, not because I (rightly or erroneously) presume the Muslim guy will not do Hindu rituals and will rather take the hindu girl away from hinduism...but because it TRIGGERS you.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Ok I respect your view buddy. For me it's the latter. Ultimately you spend your life with the girl not God. Just my 2 cents.

This life is temporary for Muslims and purpose of this life for Muslims is to live their life as per instructions of their creator. I am also against those Muslim guys and girls who just ask non Muslim to covert into Islam just for sake of marriages . Conversion should be for sake of God instead of any material gains

 

[proudindian20]

No...the two issues are unrelated. Different interpretations of Islam in Pak and India have nothing to do with Indian Hindus being trolled over a love jihadi's victory. Anyone who is anti-India will take the chance to troll you whether they are wahhabi or atheist or anything in between. You just don't seem to get that.

Let me spell it out for you. I am thrilled over every single love jihadist's victory, not because I (rightly or erroneously) presume the Muslim guy will not do Hindu rituals and will rather take the hindu girl away from hinduism...but because it TRIGGERS you.

Okay. And how does that improve your quality of life? You get to sleep better at night I guess after reading such news

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Okay. And how does that improve your quality of life? You get to sleep better at night I guess after reading such news

Nope. I sleep better when Indians are trolled. I don't care who marries whom or what version of what religion anyone follows. But clearly you are the one triggered by love jihad, by admitting you're only cool with Hindu girls marrying Muslim guys as long as the muslim guys do Hindu pooja as per your "version" of islam. I sleep better because you are triggered/trolled - no other reason.

 

[proudindian20]

Nope. I sleep better when Indians are trolled. I don't care who marries whom or what version of what religion anyone follows. But clearly you are the one triggered by love jihad, by admitting you're only cool with Hindu girls marrying Muslim guys as long as the muslim guys do Hindu pooja as per your "version" of islam. I sleep better because you are triggered/trolled - no other reason.

Lol where did I say that? I was making a point about Indian version of Islam. Either way I don't care who marries who. Only lower class people make such a fuss about it. Inter-religion marriage is common among Bollywood celebrities (high class)

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Lol where did I say that? I was making a point about Indian version of Islam. Either way I don't care who marries who. Only lower class people make such a fuss about it. Inter-religion marriage is common among Bollywood celebrities (high class)

Well you are being disingenuous now. You posted a pic of sharukh doing Hindu ritual and clearly implied that this "version" of islam is preferable to Pakistan's "version" ( ostensibly not involving Hindu rituals). So I put it to you that you are in fact bothered by who marries whom - specifically you prefer a marriage between a Pooja-doing Muslim male and Hindu girl, rather than a non-Pooja- doing Muslim male and Hindu girls. Am I right or wrong?

 

[proudindian20]

Well you are being disingenuous now. You posted a pic of sharukh doing Hindu ritual and clearly implied that this "version" of islam is preferable to Pakistan's "version" ( ostensibly not involving Hindu rituals). So I put it to you that you are in fact bothered by who marries whom - specifically you prefer a marriage between a Pooja-doing Muslim male and Hindu girl, rather than a non-Pooja- doing Muslim male and Hindu girls. Am I right or wrong?

Lol you're just making it up man. I was saying that it's very common that inter-religious marriages happen in India. Some guys were claiming it as a victory for Pakistan so I posted it showing that according to that logic Shahrukh Khan is also not a true muslim right?

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Lol you're just making it up man. I was saying that it's very common that inter-religious marriages happen in India. Some guys were claiming it as a victory for Pakistan so I posted it showing that according to that logic Shahrukh Khan is also not a true muslim right?

This has become tiresome. Once again, the victory is that you and other Indians are offended. Nothing else. Nobody cares if sharukh is a true Muslim or not. Please now drop this circular discussion as you appear set in your self-perpetuating narrative that suits your agenda, despite my best efforts at reasoning with you by providing you with the real explanation for your observations.

 

[Gandhi G in da house]

This is so petty. Not a thread worthy for a defence forum.

Muslim women marry Hindu men or other non Muslim men too. Famous examples being Hrithik and his wife Suzanne. Even Jinnah's daughter was married to a Parsi.

PDF Pakistanis will celebrate anything and everything, no matter how inconsequential.