What's new

Chinese Diplomat: Expect War if US Sends Navy Ships to Taiwan

BHarwana

MODERATOR
Joined
Sep 24, 2016
Messages
24,827
Reaction score
20
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
One of China’s top diplomats to the US warned Washington that Beijing would invade Taiwan should the US ever send a Navy ship to the island nation, which China considers to be a wayward province.

Li Kexin, a minister with the Chinese Embassy to the United States, said during an embassy event on Friday that he had told American officials that China would activate their Anti-Secession Law if US naval vessels were sent to the Taiwan Strait.

The law, passed in 2005, denies Taiwan's statehood and outlines Beijing's methods to make the unification of the two Chinas a reality. But the bill also mentions "non-peaceful action" (that being warfare) if China believes that all possibility of a bloodless unification has been lost.

To Li, the deployment of US Navy vessels would signal just such a thing. "The day that a US Navy vessel arrives in Kaohsiung is the day that our People's Liberation Army unifies Taiwan with military force," Li told Chinese media, referring to Taiwan's largest port.

His words were echoed in an editorial that ran in a Chinese newspaper, the Global Times, owned by the Chinese Communist Party and often used to informally express the views of Beijing. "The Chinese mainland has never given up the option of Taiwan reunification by force, which is clear to people across the Taiwan Strait," the editorial read.

"Li's words have sent a warning to Taiwan and drew a clear red line. If Taiwan attempts to hold an independence referendum or other activities in pursuit of de jure 'Taiwan independence,' the PLA will undoubtedly take action."

The Taiwanese Foreign Ministry slammed Li's words on Saturday, accusing China of using threats and coercion when they claim to desire peaceful reconciliation. "These methods show a lack of knowledge about the real meaning of the democratic system and how a democratic society works," the ministry wrote in a statement.

Formally speaking, Taiwan — the formal name of which is the Republic of China — and China are still one country, as Taipei considers the mainland to be wayward provinces just as Beijing sees the island as a renegade territory. However, an independence movement consisting of left-wing parties that want to declare Taiwan a de jure sovereign state continues to gain traction on the island.

The Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) that currently controls the presidency and unicameral legislature of Taiwan is one such party that supports de jure Taiwanese independence.

Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen has made her support for something like an independence referendum ambiguous. She claims that her ideal is to maintain peace with China and the security of Taiwan, but she also has refused to affirm the 1992 consensus — a semi-official agreement between the two Chinas that there was only one undivided China, although unsurprisingly neither side could agree which China was the real one.

Tsai's refusal has led to a significant degradation of cross-Strait relations since she took office in 2016. In July, China entered Taipei's air defense identification zone with their sole aircraft carrier, the Liaoning. Later that month, Beijing buzzed Taiwanese airspace with fighter jets.

The administration of US President Donald Trump has seen a strengthening of ties between the US and Taiwan, often a sticking point in Washington-Beijing relations. Trump was the first president since Jimmy Carter to directly speak with the Taiwanese president, and in September the US Congress passed the 2018 National Defense Authorization Act which authorized naval cooperation between the US and Taiwanese militaries.

In 1958 and 1996, the US deployed naval vessels to the Taiwan Strait to defend the island during periods of sky-high tensions between Beijing and Taipei. Neither incident ended in World War III.



https://sputniknews.com/asia/201712111059913378-taiwan-naval-vessel-china-invasion/
 
.
The United States should do exactly that, send a naval ship to dock at Taiwan & exercise with the ROCN. We'll see then if China has the guts to enact its "Anti-Secession Law" (and subsequently sign an instrument of unconditional surrender in the bombed-out hollows of Beijing a few years later) or stay put.

I currently think China has a more chance of Invading Taiwan as USA has engaged to many wars around the world and cannot def Taiwan with just one Ship. USA should better listen or this could result badly for USA.
 
.
You are forgetting that india is the new player to ward off china!!
Doubt we would have do to anything.

China has been all CPC and no action for 3 instances

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis

no guesses what the outcome of the fourth one will be


Instead making such big mouth statement, CPC should acknowledge that non-integration of Taiwan is nation-building failure and make attempts to integrate Taiwan by reserving some seats for Taiwanese leaders in its CPC Politburo.
 
Last edited:
.
Hahahaha..56 inch chest!! Like i said never underestimate your opponent.
Where am I underestimating my opponent.

I am stating observed facts of 1971 war, which involved Indian army engaging a hostile army on 2 fronts
and results are publicly available. Creation of Bangladesh where even Pakistan maintains a
90K POWs for which Pak Govt even released a stamp. and signed unconditional surrender by Niazi is also available.
 
.
The United States should do exactly that, send a naval ship to dock at Taiwan & exercise with the ROCN. We'll see then if China has the guts to enact its "Anti-Secession Law" (and subsequently sign an instrument of unconditional surrender in the bombed-out hollows of Beijing a few years later) or stay put.

Indeed I would invite US to do exactly what you said and I would be delight to see what will happen to Sino-US relation: remember in 1970 when China was much weaker than US, we had not hesitation to harm US interest anywhere such as in Asia, we can certainly capable to do more with what we're today, It's time for China to play a real geo-politik with US in all aspect : economy, politk and military containment...crisis is equal opportunity for China.
 
.
Doubt we would have do to anything.

China has been all CPC and no action for 3 instances

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Taiwan_Strait_Crisis

no guesses what the outcome of the fourth one will be


Instead making such big mouth statement, CPC should acknowledge that non-integration of Taiwan is nation-building failure and make attempts to integrate Taiwan by reserving some seats for Taiwanese leaders in its CPC Politburo.

Why we would like to do something just to please the irrelevant India? :rofl:
 
. .
Please try to understand!! India is the new pawn for the US against china. They might not have attacked pakistan but that doesnt indian force is useless.
Oh man you are not understanding the point. Indian Forces are useful to defend India but they are useless to fight for USA. India is not a pawn India is not even in this chess game. USA will have to fight it's own war. If India leaves the western defense what makes you think we will no advance on Kashmir. We are not that good that we will wait for India to return home from war with China.
 
.
Oh man you are not understanding the point. Indian Forces are useful to defend India but they are useless to fight for USA. India is not a pawn India is not even in this chess game. USA will have to fight it's own war. If India leaves the western defense what makes you think we will no advance on Kashmir. We are not that good that we will wait for India to return home from war with China.

Oh Lord!!!
 
.
Oh Lord!!!
Forget lord please send a Ship to Taiwan. Forget US ship try sending Indian Ship. You will shift from "Oh Lord" to "Please Lord". India fighting in SCS is a dream come true for Pakistan. Please send a ship to Taiwan it is a request try sending an Indian ship.
 
. .
Tiwan makes no sense , it is best they are part of China :pakistan::china:
The latest poll shows more than 70% of Taiwanese want the ruling gov to improve relations with China. It is the ruling gov that's causing troubles. They've overestimated their self-worthiness and greatly underestimated CPC's determination to reunify with TW. The ruling gov are run by bunch of cupcakes and cowards with very big mouths. They simply bit off much more than they can chew this time. CPC is no KMT. I guarantee you when a war with China breaks out, them DPP pussies will be the first one to flee or greet Chinese soldiers and offer them assistance to set up a temp administration to run TW.
 
Last edited:
.
Just a handful of small island countries recognize Taiwan as China. I believe two already abandoned Taiwan this year in order to establish relations with China. China can easily force the rest to abandon Taiwan till no country left has any embassy in our renegade province. It's already game over, the political entity might be stubborn but the majority of the people has no issue with Communist China. Their tech transfer to China, Taiwanese moving to Mainland and not to mention their military leaders already working for us for a long time. :rofl:
It's written on the wall there's no need for war and no, America will not come to defend Taiwan if a war does happen. We are already busy smashing US with our trade surplus and own a huge chunk of their debt. Military wise we are rapidly expanding. It's a f00king joke if anyone still believe of US superiority coming over to the rescue. Look at how American power have been responding when DPRK firing ballistic missiles over Japan, just let it fly past over it. :rofl:
 
.
The latest poll shows more than 70% of Taiwanese want the ruling gov to improve relations with China.
That does not mean Taiwanese want to be Chinese.

https://ilhaformosaaltomtaiwan.wordpress.com/2011/11/28/taiwan-dont-identify-with-china-en/
...as cross-strait exchange becomes more and more frequent, the more people of Taiwan learn about Mainland China, the less they associate their identity with the Mainland.
I work with both Chinese and Taiwanese engineers. Neither want to identify with the other. The Chinese respects the Taiwanese to identify themselves as Taiwanese. Once away from work and the alcohol flows, the Chinese do not want the Taiwanese to identify themselves as Chinese if the Taiwanese do not so desire, especially when the cultural chasm is so obvious. And yes, I have been to both China and Taiwan and have noticed the cultural differences between the two peoples.

If you try to tell historians and assorted cultural scientists that Germany and Prussia are the same, they would laugh you out of the room. That is how it is between China and Taiwan, even from the Chinese side. You think Americans and Britons want to be viewed as the same ? Cultural identification is a subtly powerful force. You keep up with the news about Spain and Catalonia ? What about the anti-US crowd on this forum who calls for the separation of California from the US because of the cultural and political divide between the two ? But now for China and Taiwan, Taiwanese are Chinese ?

I guarantee you when a war with China breaks out, them DDP pussies will be the first one to flee or greet Chinese soldiers and offer them assistance to set up a temp administration to run TW.
That is sheer childish emotions talking. Not common sense.

https://glblgeopolitics.wordpress.com/tag/course-book-on-the-taiwan-straits-military-geography/

PLA field manuals basically warned its officers that Taiwan's geography and high quality defense systems necessitates the near total destruction of island life in order to take the island. It is achievable but the PLA would suffer in excess of 100,000 casualties just to take a near lifeless rock.
 
.
That does not mean Taiwanese want to be Chinese.

https://ilhaformosaaltomtaiwan.wordpress.com/2011/11/28/taiwan-dont-identify-with-china-en/

I work with both Chinese and Taiwanese engineers. Neither want to identify with the other. The Chinese respects the Taiwanese to identify themselves as Taiwanese. Once away from work and the alcohol flows, the Chinese do not want the Taiwanese to identify themselves as Chinese if the Taiwanese do not so desire, especially when the cultural chasm is so obvious. And yes, I have been to both China and Taiwan and have noticed the cultural differences between the two peoples.

If you try to tell historians and assorted cultural scientists that Germany and Prussia are the same, they would laugh you out of the room. That is how it is between China and Taiwan, even from the Chinese side. You think Americans and Britons want to be viewed as the same ? Cultural identification is a subtly powerful force. You keep up with the news about Spain and Catalonia ? What about the anti-US crowd on this forum who calls for the separation of California from the US because of the cultural and political divide between the two ? But now for China and Taiwan, Taiwanese are Chinese ?


That is sheer childish emotions talking. Not common sense.

https://glblgeopolitics.wordpress.com/tag/course-book-on-the-taiwan-straits-military-geography/

PLA field manuals basically warned its officers that Taiwan's geography and high quality defense systems necessitates the near total destruction of island life in order to take the island. It is achievable but the PLA would suffer in excess of 100,000 casualties just to take a near lifeless rock.

Old man time to get yourself educated https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Han_Taiwanese

upload_2017-12-12_2-9-0.png


95-98% of the Taiwanese population are Taiwanese Hans, only 2,3% of the population are Taiwanese aboriginals. Unless you want to deny their heritage that is. It's like saying White American people saying we are Americans, we deny our British, Scottish, French, German or whatever ancestry. The chances you working with Taiwanese Hans representing Taiwan rather you working with Taiwanese Aboriginals. Facts are facts, Taiwanese Hans all came from Mainland China.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom