What's new

China Could Teach India How to Clean Its Toxic Air

https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddar...e-emissions-drop-indias-grow-over-last-decade
Nov. 13, 2017
China’s Sulfur Dioxide Emissions Drop, India’s Grow Over Last Decade
A new study by researchers at NASA and the University of Maryland indicates that India may be the world’s top sulfur dioxide emitter.

Sulfur dioxide is an air pollutant that causes acid rain, haze and many health-related problems. It is produced predominantly when coal is burned to generate electricity.


Sulfur dioxide concentrations for India have increased between 2005 and 2016.
Credits: NASA’s Earth Observatory / Jesse Allen
Although China and India remain the world’s largest consumers of coal, the new research found that China’s sulfur dioxide emissions fell by 75 percent since 2007, while India’s emissions increased by 50 percent. The results suggest that India is becoming, if it is not already, the world’s top sulfur dioxide emitter.

“The rapid decrease of sulfur dioxide emissions in China far exceeds expectations and projections,” said first author Can Li, an associate research scientist in the University of Maryland’s Earth System Science Interdisciplinary Center and at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Maryland. “This suggests that China is implementing sulfur dioxide controls beyond what climate modelers have taken into account.”

The study was published in the journal Scientific Reports on November 9, 2017.

China and India are the world’s top consumers of coal, which typically contains up to 3 percent sulfur. Most of the two countries’ sulfur dioxide emissions come from coal-fired power plants and coal-burning factories. In particular, Beijing suffers from severe haze problems because of the many coal-burning factories and power plants located nearby and upwind.

Starting in the early 2000s, China began implementing policies such as fining polluters, setting emission reduction goals and lowering emissions limits. According to the results of the current study, these efforts are paying off.

“Sulfur dioxide levels in China declined dramatically even though coal usage increased by approximately 50 percent and electricity generation grew by over 100 percent,” explained Li. “This suggests that much of the reduction is coming from controlling emissions.”

Despite China’s 75 percent drop in sulfur dioxide emissions, recent work by other scientists has shown that the country’s air quality remains poor and continues to cause significant health problems. This may be because sulfur dioxide contributes to only approximately 10 to 20 percent of the air particles that cause haze, according to Li.

“If China wants to bring blue skies back to Beijing, the country needs to also control other air pollutants,” Li said.

By contrast, India’s sulfur dioxide emissions increased by 50 percent over the past decade. The country opened its largest coal-fired power plant in 2012 and has yet to implement emission controls like China.

“Right now, India’s increased sulfur dioxide emissions are not causing as many health or haze problems as they do in China because the largest emission sources are not in the most densely populated area of India,” Li said. “However, as demand for electricity grows in India, the impact may worsen.”

To generate an accurate profile of emissions over India and China for the current study, the researchers combined emissions data generated by two different methods.

First, the researchers collected estimated emission amounts from inventories of the number of factories, power plants, automobiles and other contributors to sulfur dioxide emissions. These inventories, while important data sources, are often incomplete, outdated or otherwise inaccurate in developing countries. They also cannot account for changing conditions or unforeseen policies.

The researchers’ second data source was the Ozone Monitoring Instrument (OMI) on NASA’s Aura satellite, which detects a variety of atmospheric pollutants including sulfur dioxide. While OMI can collect up-to-date information and spot emission sources missing from the inventories, it can only detect relatively large emission sources. In addition, clouds or other atmospheric conditions can interfere with its measurements.

To overcome these challenges, Li and his colleagues collaborated with researchers from Environment and Climate Change Canada to develop better algorithms to quantify emissions based on OMI data. In addition, University of Maryland Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Science Professors Russell Dickerson and Zhanqing Li, co-authors of the paper, used a weather aircraft to measure the concentrations of sulfur dioxide and other air pollutants over one of the most polluted regions in China. These measurements were used to confirm that the upwind coal power plants were efficiently scrubbing SO2 from their exhaust stacks.

By combining the OMI and inventory data, the researchers generated a more accurate estimate than either data source alone. Previously published studies, which relied on inventory data and published policies, projected that China’s sulfur dioxide emissions would not fall to current levels until 2030 at the earliest.

“Those studies did not reflect the true situation on the ground,” said Li, who is also a member of the U.S. OMI Science Team. “Our study highlights the importance of using satellite measurements to study air quality, especially in regions where conditions may change rapidly and unexpectedly.”


Sulfur dioxide concentrations for China have decreased between 2005 and 2016.
Credits: NASA’s Earth Observatory / Jesse Allen

Li hopes the current study’s results can be used to improve climate and atmospheric models by providing more accurate input data.

This work was performed in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory, Environment and Climate Change Canada, Michigan Technological University and NOAA. This study used data from OMI, which is a Dutch/Finnish contribution to the NASA Aura mission and managed by the Royal Meteorological Institute of the Netherlands and the Netherlands Space Agency.

To read the paper, visit: www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-14639-8


China had been quite successful in reining in its polluting industries over the last decade and will continue to further decrease emissions.
 
Last edited:
.
Sure, China is responsible for all social ills in India! Blaming others is what you lot are good at. :lol:

To be fair, it's Indian that breath the stronger and stronger poison air everyday. In this case, we shall be quite relax. llllooolll. Their mouths can blame China, but their lungs finally will help to realize fact.
 
.
To be fair, it's Indian that breath the stronger and stronger poison air everyday. In this case, we shall be quite relax. llllooolll. Their mouths can blame China, but their lungs finally will help to realize fact.

It will take much longer time for Indians to realize or care about what they are breathing and implement corrective actions, as those who care about the air quality have already got H1-B visa, or on the way to foreign embassies to fill out applications, barring few.
 
.
To be fair, it's Indian that breath the stronger and stronger poison air everyday. In this case, we shall be quite relax. llllooolll. Their mouths can blame China, but their lungs finally will help to realize fact.

屏幕快照 2017-11-18 20.21.14.png


屏幕快照 2017-11-18 20.19.10.png
 
.
https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddar...e-emissions-drop-indias-grow-over-last-decade
Nov. 13, 2017
China’s Sulfur Dioxide Emissions Drop, India’s Grow Over Last Decade
A new study by researchers at NASA and the University of Maryland indicates that India may be the world’s top sulfur dioxide emitter.

Sulfur dioxide is an air pollutant that causes acid rain, haze and many health-related problems. It is produced predominantly when coal is burned to generate electricity.


Sulfur dioxide concentrations for India have increased between 2005 and 2016.
Credits: NASA’s Earth Observatory / Jesse Allen
Although China and India remain the world’s largest consumers of coal, the new research found that China’s sulfur dioxide emissions fell by 75 percent since 2007, while India’s emissions increased by 50 percent. The results suggest that India is becoming, if it is not already, the world’s top sulfur dioxide emitter.

“The rapid decrease of sulfur dioxide emissions in China far exceeds expectations and projections,” said first author Can Li, an associate research scientist in the University of Maryland’s Earth System Science Interdisciplinary Center and at NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center in Greenbelt, Maryland. “This suggests that China is implementing sulfur dioxide controls beyond what climate modelers have taken into account.”

The study was published in the journal Scientific Reports on November 9, 2017.

China and India are the world’s top consumers of coal, which typically contains up to 3 percent sulfur. Most of the two countries’ sulfur dioxide emissions come from coal-fired power plants and coal-burning factories. In particular, Beijing suffers from severe haze problems because of the many coal-burning factories and power plants located nearby and upwind.

Starting in the early 2000s, China began implementing policies such as fining polluters, setting emission reduction goals and lowering emissions limits. According to the results of the current study, these efforts are paying off.

“Sulfur dioxide levels in China declined dramatically even though coal usage increased by approximately 50 percent and electricity generation grew by over 100 percent,” explained Li. “This suggests that much of the reduction is coming from controlling emissions.”

Despite China’s 75 percent drop in sulfur dioxide emissions, recent work by other scientists has shown that the country’s air quality remains poor and continues to cause significant health problems. This may be because sulfur dioxide contributes to only approximately 10 to 20 percent of the air particles that cause haze, according to Li.

“If China wants to bring blue skies back to Beijing, the country needs to also control other air pollutants,” Li said.

By contrast, India’s sulfur dioxide emissions increased by 50 percent over the past decade. The country opened its largest coal-fired power plant in 2012 and has yet to implement emission controls like China.

“Right now, India’s increased sulfur dioxide emissions are not causing as many health or haze problems as they do in China because the largest emission sources are not in the most densely populated area of India,” Li said. “However, as demand for electricity grows in India, the impact may worsen.”

To generate an accurate profile of emissions over India and China for the current study, the researchers combined emissions data generated by two different methods.

First, the researchers collected estimated emission amounts from inventories of the number of factories, power plants, automobiles and other contributors to sulfur dioxide emissions. These inventories, while important data sources, are often incomplete, outdated or otherwise inaccurate in developing countries. They also cannot account for changing conditions or unforeseen policies.

The researchers’ second data source was the Ozone Monitoring Instrument (OMI) on NASA’s Aura satellite, which detects a variety of atmospheric pollutants including sulfur dioxide. While OMI can collect up-to-date information and spot emission sources missing from the inventories, it can only detect relatively large emission sources. In addition, clouds or other atmospheric conditions can interfere with its measurements.

To overcome these challenges, Li and his colleagues collaborated with researchers from Environment and Climate Change Canada to develop better algorithms to quantify emissions based on OMI data. In addition, University of Maryland Department of Atmospheric and Oceanic Science Professors Russell Dickerson and Zhanqing Li, co-authors of the paper, used a weather aircraft to measure the concentrations of sulfur dioxide and other air pollutants over one of the most polluted regions in China. These measurements were used to confirm that the upwind coal power plants were efficiently scrubbing SO2 from their exhaust stacks.

By combining the OMI and inventory data, the researchers generated a more accurate estimate than either data source alone. Previously published studies, which relied on inventory data and published policies, projected that China’s sulfur dioxide emissions would not fall to current levels until 2030 at the earliest.

“Those studies did not reflect the true situation on the ground,” said Li, who is also a member of the U.S. OMI Science Team. “Our study highlights the importance of using satellite measurements to study air quality, especially in regions where conditions may change rapidly and unexpectedly.”


Sulfur dioxide concentrations for China have decreased between 2005 and 2016.
Credits: NASA’s Earth Observatory / Jesse Allen

Li hopes the current study’s results can be used to improve climate and atmospheric models by providing more accurate input data.

This work was performed in collaboration with Argonne National Laboratory, Environment and Climate Change Canada, Michigan Technological University and NOAA. This study used data from OMI, which is a Dutch/Finnish contribution to the NASA Aura mission and managed by the Royal Meteorological Institute of the Netherlands and the Netherlands Space Agency.

To read the paper, visit: www.nature.com/articles/s41598-017-14639-8


China had been quite successful in reining in its polluting industries over the last decade and will continue to further decrease emissions.


Imagine, if india's electricity production and car sales can reach China's half!
What'll happen? @Bussard Ramjet



屏幕快照 2017-11-18 20.48.09.png



What if india's car sales reaches China's in 2016?

屏幕快照 2017-11-18 20.49.48.png
 
.
I love this thread and topic :enjoy:

India has different standard compare to China and rest of the world. :lol:
 
.
Sure, China is responsible for all social ills in India! Blaming others is what you lot are good at. :lol:
China is indeed to blame for their terrible pollution in the phase of primitive industrialisation.
We are too selfish, we have a pollution level on the decline but we have produced way more cars, electricity, expressways, high-speed railways, high-rises, stadiums, schools, hospitals, shopping centres....
We are too selfish, we should have made SP status of 2012 much earlier than 2012!
Sorry, @Bussard Ramjet, don't blame yourself, blame China!
 
.
Imagine, if india's electricity production and car sales can reach China's half!
What'll happen?

Also imagine India eventually having some credible heavy industries and start building up their infrastructure.

Would they utilize latest clean technologies?

Do they have indigenous technologies capabilities?

If not, do they have money to buy expensive technologies?

If they are not going to buy expensive technologies, what kind o impact would industrialization and infrastructure build-up have on India's already unbearable pollution?

Quite distressing, to be frank.
 
.
Sure, China is responsible for all social ills in India!

I never said that. I being socialist know that my country has lot of problems originating from within.

Blaming others is what you lot are good at. :lol:

All I said was China is equally responsible with India in maintenance of global pollution, more particularly the neo-rich middle classes who don't realize that their obsession of cell phones and cars is doing damage to Earth.

And you haven't replied on this :
The biggest pollutant in India is burning of "Organic Mass", including cow dung for fuel. Why are you blaming China for what 50% Indians use to cook their meals?
 
. .
Sure, China is responsible for all social ills in India! Blaming others is what you lot are good at. :lol:
I told you about the typical attitude of most Indian. They are good at blaming other beside looking into mirror to look at themselves. They are the type who will not hesitant to immediately claim credit if good things happen but will not even think twice to shove blame at others if thing goes bad.

The indian attitude is never reflecting on themselves. India is center of the world. The world must obey caste system and India is supreme. :lol:
 
.
My own experience, China's pollutants were the worst in 2013, only one good day during one month in worst winter
2015 and 2016 becomes better and better , only 2 or three bad days during the same time
 
Last edited:
.
My own experience, China's pollutants were the worst in 2013, only one good day during one month in worst winter
2015 and 2016 bocomes better and better , only 2 or three bad days during the same time
2012-2013 was really bad.
Those were the years when 10000+ km expressways were added per year!
It means, 2 months' construction = india's entire controlled-access expressway network

I think 2020-2025 will witness significant and tangible changes in major industrial cities.
Around 2030-2035 will see China back to blue sky every day.
The changes will be in line with the implementation of made in China 2025.

Fig-1-Kuznets-curve-pollution-versus-economic-development-Slanina-2013.png

india's road is off the chart!
pollution has no direct correlation with real development and industrialisation
 
Last edited:
.
I never said that. I being socialist know that my country has lot of problems originating from within.
All I said was China is equally responsible with India in maintenance of global pollution, more particularly the neo-rich middle classes who don't realize that their obsession of cell phones and cars is doing damage to Earth.

And you haven't replied on this :


Here you go, and I was trying to be polite when I quoted "50%":

"Biomass fuel consists of fire wood, dung cakes, agricultural crop residues such as straw, grass, and shrubs, coal fuels and kerosene. Together, they supply 75% of the domestic energy in India. An estimated three-quarters of Indian households use biomass fuel as the primary means for domestic cooking. Ninety percent of rural households and 32% of urban households cook their meals on a biomass stove".

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23229114


"Like Pratibha, over two-thirds of India’s 1.3 billion people continue to rely on carbon-emitting biomass and dung-based fuel for cooking, according to a United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO)report titled ‘Sustainable Energy For All’ – released this month”

http://indiaclimatedialogue.net/2014/07/17/millions-die-indians-still-cook-wood-dung/



 
Last edited:
.
Here you go, and I was trying to be polite when I quoted "50%":

"Biomass fuel consists of fire wood, dung cakes, agricultural crop residues such as straw, grass, and shrubs, coal fuels and kerosene. Together, they supply 75% of the domestic energy in India. An estimated three-quarters of Indian households use biomass fuel as the primary means for domestic cooking. Ninety percent of rural households and 32% of urban households cook their meals on a biomass stove".

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23229114


"Like Pratibha, over two-thirds of India’s 1.3 billion people continue to rely on carbon-emitting biomass and dung-based fuel for cooking, according to a United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO)report titled ‘Sustainable Energy For All’ – released this month”

http://indiaclimatedialogue.net/2014/07/17/millions-die-indians-still-cook-wood-dung/


Actually alot of the pollution is non industrial in nature, it's the crop residue burning, China reduced these burnings significantly over the decades and encourages biomass energy instead.

You can see the difference in competency levels.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom