carving out a new province from Punjab

[Islamabad Rulz]

I think smaller provinces is a very weak argument,,, all this is just politically motivated... we know province size in Us, India, Europe, Afghanistan... etc etc... they California is half the size of Pakistan, Provinces in Afghanistan are as big as our districts, Utter Pardesh in India has almost same population as Pakistan, Most countries in the world including India has provinces based on ethnic basis.. etc

 

[M.AsfandYar]

Not one but perhaps 4 or more provinces out of Punjab, would be better, to my thinking or as AM has suggested that we use divisions as provinces - The large provinces are a threat to the integrity of Pakistan - it is only a matter of time that some reckless politician, hoping to enrich himself or his friends will be able to blackmail Pakistan by threatening to seize control of a province and launch a "liberation" movement based on ethnicity or language or some other idea.

3 provinces would be most optimal. Potohar region, Central and South with someparts from central west.