What's new

Can Nuclear War Be Won?

imho.. Not if the country being attacked has second strike capability.
 
If you mean US vs. Japan in WW2, then it was a one sided strike, and not a fair comparison. Otherwise, what example do you mean?

Additionally, Japan had already lost. They would have surrendered in a matter of weeks if not days even if the US had NOT detonated nukes on them.
 
Additionally, Japan had already lost. They would have surrendered in a matter of weeks if not days even if the US had NOT detonated nukes on them.

Correct. Japan was dealing with the threat of being invading by the soviets as well and decided to submit to one power before being divided by two as in Germany.
 
Additionally, Japan had already lost. They would have surrendered in a matter of weeks if not days even if the US had NOT detonated nukes on them.

This is the narrative that America tries so hard to suppress. Many independent experts believe that Japan was close to being defeated / surrendering anyway... yet they dropped nukes on dense civilian populations. Unbelievably cruel. Pure terrorism.
 
imho.. Not if the country being attacked has second strike capability.

So what are your honest thoughts on Pakistan vs India nuclear war scenerio?

Who would win, who would lose, both would lose, both win, or what?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom