BSF shoots tangled teenager

[StingRoy]

You need to check your eyes immediately. the picture is in fogy winter morning in india bangladesh border .what a ways to defy responsibility .

Fog does not leave snow on the ground. See near the ground where the fence stands. Not denying the article here, just the photo.

 

[Bang Galore]

The point that has not been given sufficient importance is that she was supposedly shot trying to cross into Bangladesh. Other than the fact that she was incredibly unlucky to die from a single bullet(supposedly), it should be noted that the BSF at the time of the supposed shooting would not have known whether she was an Indian national or a Bangladeshi national. The worst that can be said is that the BSF was trigger happy, not that they were deliberately targeting Bangladeshis. There is a reason why that area is called a no man's land & the border fencing is usually well within Indian territory.

HUDA DIGAMBARPUR, India, April 30 (Reuters) - With a towering razor-wire fence and heavily armed guards who kill around 200 people every year, the fence along the India-Bangladesh border is ominous and sometimes dangerous.

The fence, which snakes its way through paddy fields about 140 metres (153 yards) inside India's notoriously porous border with Bangladesh, was built by the Indian government to prevent smuggling and illegal immigration.
http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSDEL206634

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

whats so bloody wrong in it ?????

if somebody try to jump the wire. they can very well carry weapons or wrong intention. shot them

thats why the forces are there .

which one of you smart arse - think one must go to the person ask if she is ok then chek her if she carry a weapon and then taken her to delhi in strech limo???

She was not jumping she was using ladder .. which can be seen from the picture... so stop using such useless claim... even if it is at night hardly people carry arm to illegally enter other country ...n BSF can not deny responsibility for such barbaric act... BSF always has flash light to check whom they are shooting.... this is nothing but a sort of criminal act...

 

[Spring Onion]

Again which part of Photoshop this lady didn't understood?

We never claimed that BSF shot dead a Bangladeshi girl.

Since you happen to be a reporter why don't you shed a light on this?

GB

1. You claimed it is Indo-Pak border so prove your claim. i see no valid object in the picture which shows its Indo-Pak border.

 

[Patriot]

Not sure why people are bitching.They did the right thing.You cross the border ( That's illegal ) you get shot.Immoral and Harsh Yes but Illegal No.You can of course pay them back in the same coin when you get a chance.There is nothing wrong in shooting someone who is illegally crossing your border ( Although it would have been better to detain and then deport).I do feel sad for the family.If Bangladeshis want to stop this humilation ask your government to grow a pair instead of crying here ( I say same thing to my Pakistani Fellows who cry about drone attacks).In today's world, might is right.

 

[doctor_who]

She was not jumping she was using ladder .. which can be seen from the picture... so stop using such useless claim... even if it is at night hardly people carry arm to illegally enter other country ...n BSF can not deny responsibility for such barbaric act... BSF always has flash light to check whom they are shooting.... this is nothing but a sort of criminal act...

so what if she was using ladder or what ever - its illegal to jump the bloody wire. its there for some reason.

if hardly people carry arms - what if she did - and shot a soldier - you mean to say bsf need to just assume is not the one with arms ????

bsf did the right thing shot them next time again - thats why they are bloody given weapons.

you have no brain - if you think its criminal - they are doign their duty. and bsf dont need to check - just shoot is what they are asked to do- protect the country from infiltration


-x-x-x-x i feel sorry for the girl but the fault is - her parents and coutnry.

 

[Spring Onion]

The point that has not been given sufficient importance is that she was supposedly shot trying to cross into Bangladesh. Other than the fact that she was incredibly unlucky to die from a single bullet(supposedly), it should be noted that the BSF at the time of the supposed shooting would not have known whether she was an Indian national or a Bangladeshi national. The worst that can be said is that the BSF was trigger happy, not that they were deliberately targeting Bangladeshis. There is a reason why that area is called a no man's land & the border fencing is usually well within Indian territory.

trigger happy ? is it a professional force or street gangsters ?


why Indian force's trigger happy nature always result in killing of Bangladeshis? when was the last time your trigger happy BSF had killed any bharti crossing into Bangladesh illegally ?

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

Fog does not leave snow on the ground. See near the ground where the fence stands. Not denying the article here, just the photo.

N who told you those are snow??? Do you have any idea what snow is... if that would be snow than that would cover the entire place not a selected row.... Those are the soil where grasses has been trimmed... on both side of the fence... increase your eye power...

Below is an example of snow fall in occupied kashmir

 

[Bang Galore]

trigger happy ? is it a professional force or street gangsters ?


why Indian force's trigger happy nature always result in killing of Bangladeshis? when was the last time your trigger happy BSF had killed any bharti crossing into Bangladesh illegally ?

If you had actually bothered to read & understand my post, you would have realised that I made the point that the BSF could not have necessarily known that the girl was Bangladeshi because she was trying to cross over from India into Bangladesh.

As for the question of why they don't seem to shoot Indians, it's probably because Indians aren't the ones climbing fences. The fence is well over 100 m within India's international boundary.

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

so what if she was using ladder or what ever - its illegal to jump the bloody wire. its there for some reason.

if hardly people carry arms - what if she did - and shot a soldier - you mean to say bsf need to just assume is not the one with arms ????

bsf did the right thing shot them next time again - thats why they are bloody given weapons.

you have no brain - if you think its criminal - they are doign their duty. and bsf dont need to check - just shoot is what they are asked to do- protect the country from infiltration


-x-x-x-x i feel sorry for the girl but the fault is - her parents and coutnry.

Are you naive and have some brain.... BSF could ask to surrender... from safe distance b4 shooting... in every places it has been a rule to give a warning before shooting any one if there is not any imminent danger from him or her and if he/she is an ordinary citizen without any arms... Next time you come up with better idea....and logic..

Even USA which killed innocent civilians like bird in iraq and afghanistan never shoot any mexican who tries to enter USA illegally...

 

[doctor_who]

Are you naive and have some brain.... BSF could ask to surrender... from safe distance b4 shooting... in every places it has been a rule to give a warning before shooting any one if there is not any imminent danger from him or her and if he/she is an ordinary citizen without any arms... Next time you come up with better idea....and logic..

oh my god ----you have just lost it - so you were there - when it happened why didnt you ask them not to shoot ????


BSF LIKE ANYOTHER FORCE DID SHOUT. or prove it otherwise. the girl got shot and bsf did its job.

the girl got what she deserved - india is facing lot of terror perforatign from bungladesh in recent past.

we need to shoot anthing which come out of there without legal channel.

 

[CaPtAiN_pLaNeT]

oh my god ----you have just lost it - so you were there - when it happened why didnt you ask them not to shoot ????


BSF LIKE ANYOTHER FORCE DID SHOUT. or prove it otherwise. the girl got shot and bsf did its job.

the girl got what she deserved - india is facing lot of terror perforatign from bungladesh in recent past.

we need to shoot anthing which come out of there without legal channel.

why do not you proof that bsf shout before killing????do you have any proof... if bsf really would have done it then they would have mentioned it.. so get a life..

 

[Bang Galore]

the girl got what she deserved - india is facing lot of terror perforatign from bungladesh in recent past.

we need to shoot anthing which come out of there without legal channel. [/B]

Please go slow on the ranting. A young girl died. In my book, that is a most unfortunate event. Whether or not we disagree about any culpability, lets not show disrespect at someone's death especially when it is now clear that she was merely a victim of circumstances. There is a family shattered & pain of the loss felt deeply. There is no need to lose humanity when debating this.

 

[LaBong]

You come here to accuse others you do not even know your own country. Go see your own newspaper. What a pitty

Yeah yeah you know the country sitting there in US, This place looks like a desert not north Bengal. Let me read the whole story in my PC where I have dynamic unicode font installed.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

then its a pity came to a point where you need to use women.anyway as Abir said prove it or mods should ban the poster. So the onus is on the bharti member to prove it is Indo-Pakistan border with your woman hanging on the fence

Umm for a "journalist" you sure seem to be living in the dark ages with the highlighted comment. Yes we regard our women as being capable of doing and being anything, including kicking our enemies' azzes. C'mon and live in the 21st century. Get some confidence in yourself as a woman