Ben Affleck gets worked up defending Islam on Bill Maher's show

[Developereo]

Not according to Jewish Orthodox laws

Don't embarrass yourself any further. Readers can read what I actually wrote, as opposed to your desperate thrashing.

I know you are smarting, but it's still painful to watch.
Entertaining ... but painful nonetheless.

 

[gambit]

The point is that, using the rules of "Jewishness" espoused by a significant group of Jews themselves, Maher is Jewish.

Source: Ben Affleck gets worked up defending Islam on Bill Maher's show | Page 7

Then so is this man and his family...

http://www.islamweb.net/emainpage/articles/20069/jewish-american-converts-to-islam

Joseph Cohen moved from the United States to Israel as a devout Jew in 1998, but within three years he had converted to Islam and become Yosef Mohammed Khatib, a supporter of the militant Hamas, according to a report broadcast Thursday on Israel TV.

If those rules are so compelling that Muslims must obey them and must make efforts to point out Jewish origins when there are evidences of Jewish origins in any person, then this Jewish convert to Islam must be considered a fraud by the Muslims.

Don't embarrass yourself any further. Readers can read what I actually wrote, as opposed to your desperate thrashing.

It's painful to watch.
Entertaining ... but painful nonetheless.

Am just going by your reasoning, buddy.

So tell us, is Joseph Cohen a Muslim, or must he forever remain a Jew ?

 

[Chronos]

so, you will tell me now who is real-muslim and who is fake-muslim...


i being a socialist am "islamist"... and "cair" is disinfo agency of cia, just like ned and avaaz and "amnesty international" and the rest.



from all that long post of mine, you decided to copy-paste only statement... not the one below... not the ones above.

socialist and an islamist.

That explains it. At least now I know where socialists get their wealth from to re-distribute. From God of course.

 

[jamahir]

socialist and an islamist.

That explains it. At least now I know where socialists get their wealth from to re-distribute. From God of course.

how did god come into the picture??

 

[Developereo]

Am just going by your reasoning, buddy.

Please don't murder the English language by using the word 'reasoning' to describe your hallucinations.

So tell us, is Joseph Cohen a Muslim, or must he forever remain a Jew ?

You still don't understand the difference between Jewish ethnicity and religion, do you?

 

[gambit]

According to the Muslims, if there is any trace of Jewishness in a person, that person MUST be regarded as a Jew, because Orthodox Jews sez so. Therefore, Bill Maher is a rabid Jew.

Holocaust survivor finds haven as Muslim in Israel - Israel Jewish Scene, Ynetnews

For more than five decades, Leila Jabarin hid her secret from her Muslim children and grandchildren - that she was a Jewish Holocaust survivor born in Auschwitz concentration camp.

"Whenever it is Holocaust Memorial Day, I cry alone...."

Here is proof that no Jew can ever be a loyal Muslim. This woman wept for the Holocaust, which is a fraud anyway, according to the Muslims. So here we have a Jewish convert to Islam who felt for an event that did not happened. This mean no Jewish convert to Islam should ever be trusted.

You still don't understand the difference between Jewish ethnicity and religion, do you?

Here is what YOU said on page 6...

It doesn't matter what anybody else says or believes.

So tell us, is Holocaust survivor and convert to Islam Leila Jabarin a valid Muslim or not ?

 

[Developereo]

Here is what YOU said on page 6...

Ignoring your flights of desperation to find something where nothing exists, what I wrote is crystal clear.

According to Orthodox Jewish traditions, a person is Jewish if their mother is Jewish. Period. It doesn't matter if someone else considers them Jewish or not.

I suggest you go and read what I wrote, and understand why you are so humiliated.

I already answered your question in the earlier post, but you clearly haven't understood.

PS. As predicted, smarting with anger and humiliation, you are out vomiting bile against the evil Moooslims. Never mind the fact that Orthodox Jewish law itself makes a fool out of you.

 

[gambit]

Ignoring your flights of desperation to find something where nothing exists, what I wrote is crystal clear.

According to Orthodox Jewish traditions, a person is Jewish if their mother is Jewish. Period. It doesn't matter if someone else considers them Jewish or not.

I suggest you go and read what I wrote, and understand why you are so humiliated.

PS. As predicted, smarting with anger and humiliation, you are out vomiting bile against the evil Moooslims. Never mind the fact that Orthodox Jewish law itself makes a fool out of you.

So explain to us why is Bill Maher a Jew but not Jewish converts to Islam Joseph Cohen and Leila Jabarin ?

 

[Developereo]

So explain to us why is Bill Maher a Jew but not Jewish converts to Islam Joseph Cohen and Leila Jabarin ?

I already answered the question earlier. The convert are both Jewish and Muslim.

You still remain clueless about the difference between Jewish ethnicity and religion.

 

[gambit]

I already answered the question earlier. The convert are both Jewish and Muslim.

You still remain clueless about the difference between Jewish ethnicity and religion.

But Maher was raised a Catholic. Why must his mother's Jewish origin trumps his father's Irish origin, according to YOU.

It also does not matter if Joseph Cohen and Leila Jabarin are both Jewish ethnicity but Islam in religion. According to YOU, Maher's Jewish ties via his mother immediately made him a Jew and therefore untrustworthy. Do you think Cohen and Jabarin are trustworthy Muslims ?

 

[Developereo]

But Maher was raised a Catholic. Why must his mother's Jewish origin trumps his father's Irish origin, according to YOU.

It also does not matter if Joseph Cohen and Leila Jabarin are both Jewish ethnicity but Islam in religion. According to YOU, Maher's Jewish ties via his mother immediately made him a Jew and therefore untrustworthy. Do you think Cohen and Jabarin are trustworthy Muslims ?

More fabrications from your mind.

Maher lacks credibility because he has demonstrated bias in favor of Jewish extremists. I gave the specific example of his movie Religulous.

Once bias is demonstrated, it is reasonable to look for possible causes. The fact that he is Jewish is a relevant factor when discussing his bias in favor of Jewish fanatics. It doesn't mean all Jews are biased, but it is perfectly reasonable to posit that this individual may be biased.

We start with the demonstrated bias and look for possible causes.

 

[gambit]

More fabrications from your mind.

Maher lacks credibility because he has demonstrated bias in favor of Jewish extremists. I gave the specific example of his movie Religulous.

Once bias is demonstrated, it is reasonable to look for possible causes. The fact that he is Jewish is a relevant factor when discussing his bias in favor of Jewish fanatics.

We start with the demonstrated bias and look for possible causes.

How convenient. Maher is a Jew just because -- in your mind -- he does not criticize Israel as much as he does Muslims and Islam.

That 'it is reasonable to look for possible causes' ? Maher have no relationship to Jewry other than his mother's origin. By insisting such a tenuous tie -- blood -- to be a valid cause for his behavior -- his schtick on the comedy circuit -- make you no better than the Stormfront scum who insists that race determines everything.

Face it, buddy. You do not know Maher for as long as you claimed, however long that is enough to know the man's career in show business. You are a fraud in that matter. It is entertaining for all that you do not know that by flipping Maher to the Jewish side to suit your perception of him in particular, and Jews in general, confirms to all that you are the same type of bigot that you accuse others of being.

 

[Developereo]

How convenient. Maher is a Jew just because -- in your mind -- he does not criticize Israel as much as he does Muslims and Islam.

That 'it is reasonable to look for possible causes' ? Maher have no relationship to Jewry other than his mother's origin. By insisting such a tenuous tie -- blood -- to be a valid cause for his behavior -- his schtick on the comedy circuit -- make you no better than the Stormfront scum who insists that race determines everything.

Face it, buddy. You do not know Maher for as long as you claimed, however long that is enough to know the man's career in show business. You are a fraud in that matter. It is entertaining for all that you do not know that by flipping Maher to the Jewish side to suit your perception of him in particular, and Jews in general, confirms to all that you are the same type of bigot that you accuse others of being.

Yawn.

Once again, since you got humiliated because you didn't have a clue about Jewish ethnicity v/s religion, all you can do is your stock rant about anti-Semitism.

Maher has a demonstrated bias in favor of Jewish extremists, as against other religious extremists.
He has Jewish ancestry.
It is logical to posit a connection between the two.

If an Arab were quick to criticize everyone except Arabs, it would be reasonable to ask why.
If a Pakistani were quick to criticize everyone except Pakistanis, it would be reasonable to ask why.

But if the same pattern applies to a Jewish person, one must not ask why.
Uh huh.

 

[VCheng]

What is needed is the intellectual honesty to admit that Jewish bigots are allowed to make generalizations about non-Jews, especially Christians and Muslims (e.g. Borat, Ali G, etc.) but non-Jews are not allowed to make the same observations about Jewish fanatics.

I don't think there is any significant bar on making and expressing any observations about any major religion in the context of a fair discussion. However, it is the responses from the followers of that religion that are important. Someone can publish a cartoon about Jesus and Moses and live to tell the tale. Indeed, he/she might even get to explain their view point on media outlets. Can we say the same thing about Islam, if we are being intellectually honest here?

Say this is downtown Srinagar and you will be bashed to a pulp.

Why would you think that?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Why would you think that?

Some people are naughty.

No. Seriously, don't try that. Except for Hazratbal (often considered part Sufi) practically all Sufi shrines in Kashmir are now history.