What's new

Bangladesh to benefit from India's advancement in Space

This is pure indian propaganda, india even refused to provide river flow data for monsoon. Bangladesh had agreement with China to provide such data. Indians think propaganda and lie could mask real facts.
China Offers Bangladesh River Data For Flood Forecasts

"The data we get from India give us only four hours' time to prepare for a flood, which is not enough to warn people or make adequate preparations. We have demanded data of the Ganges flow in the areas near the Himalayas, but India (they) could not give us the data."

China Offers Bangladesh River Data For Flood Forecasts
Good, another indian propaganda blitz of "benefit" got busted showing real indian face.

A classic example of Chinese A$$ licking as usual from Jamatis like you - you quote an 8 years report in 2006 claiming the Chinese helping you guys by providing river flow data of Brahmaputra but still every year there is a loss of life and property in Bangladesh owing to the drastic floods in the very same Brahmaputra river - either the Chinese data wasn't enough or the you were incompetent enough to unable to prepare yourselves for the same circumstances - the latest one being a couple of months ago only - it happens every year - Ganges is not an exception! - You will guys will go to any extent pretesting for even a little barrage being bulit on the Ganges but won't give a fcuk to those 40 dams all set to be built on Brahmaputra by China -

Bangladesh's once welcome floods are now harbingers of disaster | Alex Renton | Global development | theguardian.com
Major rivers swell to flood new areas across Bangladesh -
bdnews24.com


Seriously the biggest Propagandist on this forum alleging propaganda is pretty ironical! Dumbo!

India has great experience with both LEO sats for disaster management, crop and geological monitoring and weather data and comm sats. We did purchase various services from india in the past, but now the BD gov are looking to build our own through BUET with assistance from France and the EU. Our first Com sat is due for launch sometime in 2017, supplied by a private sector US company.

As moving away from the US GPS system to an indian system or for any military co-op the chances of that is near zero.

India will probably place your first communications satellite in orbit when it's ready in 2017! :coffee:
 
LOL...na the U.S. has already got the contract to do that.........you really should keep up....:omghaha:
So you contracted US to launch a low payload satellite which will cost you almost 5 times than that of indian or chinese lauches.
No suprise that business acumen does not exist in bangladesh.
 
So you contracted US to launch a low payload satellite which will cost you almost 5 times than that of indian or chinese lauches.
No suprise that business acumen does not exist in bangladesh.

It was compulsion otherwise Khaleda Zia and Jamati would have created a hell out of it if contract was given to India for cost saving. samjha kar bhai. ;)
 
LOL...na the U.S. has already got the contract to do that.........you really should keep up....:omghaha:

You given the launch contract to american? Which cost is among highest is world.

Why not Europe, Russia, Ukraine, China or India?
 
You given the launch contract to american? Which cost is among highest is world.

Why not Europe, Russia, Ukraine, China or India?

It was compulsion otherwise Khaleda Zia and Jamati would have created a hell out of it if contract was given to India for cost saving. samjha kar bhai. ;)

So you contracted US to launch a low payload satellite which will cost you almost 5 times than that of indian or chinese lauches.
No suprise that business acumen does not exist in bangladesh.

LOL...na the U.S. has already got the contract to do that.........you really should keep up....:omghaha:

Please provide a source for the same - never heard about it neither was it mentioned -

Development cost of the satellite = Tk32.48bn
Cost of purchasing the orbital slot = Tk217.7bn ($ 28.1M)
Cost of Launching it from US = ???

Out of the proposed DPP cost of Tk32.48bn, the government will bear Tk15.604bn from its own funds.

The other half of the project cost that is Tk16.883bn, will be funded by a supplier’s credit from the Export-Import Bank of USA. Earlier, the Export-Import Bank of USA sent a proposal to the government through the BTRC for funding the project at less than 2% interest.

Source - Bangabandhu 1 satellite project ready | Dhaka Tribune

You are not even funding the project entirely but taking loan on interest which you will have to pay back - if you are launching it from SpaceX then fine enough but if not - then it will only be stupid idea for the cost of your satellite is already soaring high!

BTW India's GSLV is 20% more economical than SpaceX falcon series rockets for launching satellites - In fact the most economical one in the world!
 
Please provide a source for the same - never heard about it neither was it mentioned -

Development cost of the satellite = Tk32.48bn
Cost of purchasing the orbital slot = Tk217.7bn ($ 28.1M)
Cost of Launching it from US = ???

Out of the proposed DPP cost of Tk32.48bn, the government will bear Tk15.604bn from its own funds.

The other half of the project cost that is Tk16.883bn, will be funded by a supplier’s credit from the Export-Import Bank of USA. Earlier, the Export-Import Bank of USA sent a proposal to the government through the BTRC for funding the project at less than 2% interest.

Source - Bangabandhu 1 satellite project ready | Dhaka Tribune

You are not even funding the project entirely but taking loan on interest which you will have to pay back - if you are launching it from SpaceX then fine enough but if not - then it will only be stupid idea for the cost of your satellite is already soaring high!

BTW India's GSLV is 20% more economical than SpaceX falcon series rockets for launching satellites - In fact the most economical one in the world!

My guess is Bangladesh will go for China for cost saving, if its given to India, BNP and Jamatis will create en entire political movement out of it as Hinduphobia is needed for their political survival.
 
You given the launch contract to american? Which cost is among highest is world.

Why not Europe, Russia, Ukraine, China or India?

The consultancy contract was awarded to Maryland based SPI through BTRC, as per tender notification. The selection of a launch vechile is upto BTRC with advice from SPI, who have to take into account various factors including price, capacity, record etc. So far the only reliable info I have is SPI and BTRC (Sunil Bose) are talking to various companies US/Russian/Chinese and the most likely is CGWIC to provide launch services.
 
Please provide a source for the same - never heard about it neither was it mentioned -

Development cost of the satellite = Tk32.48bn
Cost of purchasing the orbital slot = Tk217.7bn ($ 28.1M)
Cost of Launching it from US = ???

Out of the proposed DPP cost of Tk32.48bn, the government will bear Tk15.604bn from its own funds.

The other half of the project cost that is Tk16.883bn, will be funded by a supplier’s credit from the Export-Import Bank of USA. Earlier, the Export-Import Bank of USA sent a proposal to the government through the BTRC for funding the project at less than 2% interest.

Source - Bangabandhu 1 satellite project ready | Dhaka Tribune

You are not even funding the project entirely but taking loan on interest which you will have to pay back - if you are launching it from SpaceX then fine enough but if not - then it will only be stupid idea for the cost of your satellite is already soaring high!

BTW India's GSLV is 20% more economical than SpaceX falcon series rockets for launching satellites - In fact the most economical one in the world!

The selection and pricing of a launch provider is yet to be negotiated by BTRC, and where did you hear the costs are already soaring high, it's well within what has been budgeted. I don't think the GSLV has been under consideration, by SPI, you'd have to speak directly to Shafiq bhai.

how much do you know about commercial projects? Please explain to me how you think that BTRC is not fully funding the project? As far I know we are not receiving any grants or aid to fund this.
 
Last edited:
India has great experience with both LEO sats for disaster management, crop and geological monitoring and weather data and comm sats. We did purchase various services from india in the past, but now the BD gov are looking to build our own through BUET with assistance from France and the EU. Our first Com sat is due for launch sometime in 2017, supplied by a private sector US company.

As moving away from the US GPS system to an indian system or for any military co-op the chances of that is near zero.

its a Com sat.but I don't see any of the Earth Observation Sat is going to be launched soon.that means buying services from another country.

as far as I know,nobody is moving away from GPS,but complementing it with IRNSS.Australia openly announced to buy IRNSS service,and its not for military purpose but for maritime guidance.plus,nobody knows here how these kind of Co-Op gets worked out.declassified documents showed USA helped Vietnam by providing sat images during Sino-Vietnam War.what do you think??smaller countries doesn't get this kind of facility from another country??or do you simply propose the idea that Bangladesh doesn't have or need this kind of Co-OP with India??as far as I know,there is more Co-Ops than what meets the eye.
 
as far as I know,nobody is moving away from GPS,but complementing it with IRNSS.

You are talking about GAGAN not IRNSS, GAGAN is the GPS-Augmented system while IRNSS is an Independent Indian Regional Navigation system.........

& Yes, IRNSS has military implications.
 
You are talking about GAGAN not IRNSS, GAGAN is the GPS-Augmented system while IRNSS is an Independent Indian Regional Navigation system.........

& Yes, IRNSS has military implications.

I know bro.but I'm talking about IRNSS..it will provide two services, with the Standard Positioning Service open for civilian use and the Restricted Service, encrypted one, for authorised users (military).

Australia asked for IRNSS,Oceansat II and RISAT data....

Australia: Keen to Access India’s Space Data to Guard Coastline - International Business Times

and IRNSS is going to be used for Maritime Navigation.and by "Complement",I meant using parallely.
 
The selection and pricing of a launch provider is yet to be negotiated by BTRC, and where did you hear the costs are already soaring high, it's well within what has been budgeted. I don't think the GSLV has been under consideration, by SPI, you'd have to speak directly to Shafiq bhai.

how much do you know about commercial projects? Please explain to me how you think that BTRC is not fully funding the project? As far I know we are not receiving any grants or aid to fund this.

You are yourself confused - first you say U.S. has already got the contract for the launch - if they have got it how can they can outsource it to another firm? There are only speculations as to who will launch it - nothing more than that.

Secondly I have nothing to do your commercial projects - it's not that I am thinking anything! It's your own government which finalized this project last year had planned not to fund the project entirely through BTRC - a link which I had already mentioned in my last post - here it is again -

Bangabandhu 1 satellite project ready
The Tk32.48bn Development Project Proposal (DPP) for Bangabandhu 1, the first satellite of Bangladesh, is ready for being placed before the highest economic policymaking body of the country.

The proposal is likely to be tabled at a meeting of the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council (Ecnec) very soon.

The Bangladesh Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC) has already finalised the proposal from its end and would initiate buying “orbital slot” for the satellite once Ecnec gives approval.

The BTRC will purchase an orbital slot on 119 degree East from Intersputnik, a renowned Russian company, at a cost of $28m (Tk217.7bn) with a single lifetime of 15 years.

Initially, the BTRC applied for a slot on 102 degree East to the International Telecommunication Union (ITU). However, nearly 20 countries including the USA, Russia, France and Australia raised objections that their satellite communication would be disrupted if Bangladesh was given that slot.

“We will have to act fast after getting the Ecnec nod because a lot of time has already been wasted,” BTRC Chairman Sunil Kanti Bose told the Dhaka Tribune.

Out of the proposed DPP cost of Tk32.48bn, the government will bear Tk15.604bn from its own funds.

Of the Tk15.604bn, the government allocated Tk6.91bn in the previous fiscal, Tk3.49bn for the ongoing (2013-14) fiscal and the remaining Tk5.02bn for the next (2014-15).

The other half of the project cost that is Tk16.883bn, will be funded by a supplier’s credit from the Export-Import Bank of USA. That deal, however, is still to be finalised.

A BTRC official told the Dhaka Tribune: “It [the deal with the US bank] has not been finalised at the government level; but most of the communication is already complete.”

Earlier, the Export-Import Bank of USA sent a proposal to the government through the BTRC for funding the project at less than 2% interest.


The BTRC chairman also informed that two parties had been contacting the government expressing their interests in the satellite project.

“Great Wall of China met me last week. They have been showing interest for a couple of years. Russian Ambassador to Bangladesh Alexander A Nikolaev has said that a state-run company from his country is interested in the project,” Bose said.

He added that the government had decided to launch the satellite under Public-Private Partnership (PPP) scheme in order to ensure impeccable maintenance after the launch.

According to documents, the project commenced on July 1 this year and will end on June 30, 2016.

The telecom regulator has chosen Betbunia of Chittagong and the BTCL Staff College in Gazipur for setting up two earth stations for the satellite. There will also be a maintenance office at the BTRC building.

Sources said after purchasing the orbital slot for the Bangabandhu 1, the government would try to book two more slots in advance on 102 degree East and 69 degree East for launching two more satellites in the future.

The government has also reportedly shown interest in purchasing the 135 degree East slot from the ITU, although its location was far away from Bangladesh’s coverage.

“A single satellite will never be viable for business. We need to launch at least one more satellite getting benefitted and making profits,” Sunil Kanti Bose said.

Figures show that Bangladesh spends around $11m annually on satellite rents for running television channels, telephones and radio connectivity.

A successful launching of the satellite is likely to bring $50m annually by renting out the unused portion to neighbouring countries like Nepal, Bhutan and Myanmar.

Fifty countries in the world at present have satellites of their own. India and Pakistan are the only countries in the subcontinent with satellites. Sri Lanka is also in the middle of a process for launching one of its own.

Source:- Bangabandhu 1 satellite project ready | Dhaka Tribune

The fact is nothing till now is clear about this project - hardly any resources available on the net - please share some if you get those -

@Chanakya's_Chant I dont know about Orbital slot are purchased, are from where? And where the money goes?

Don't know much about it but -

Initially, the BTRC applied for a slot on 102 degree East to the International Telecommunication Union (ITU). However, nearly 20 countries including the USA, Russia, France and Australia raised objections that their satellite communication would be disrupted if Bangladesh was given that slot. Hence they purchased an orbital slot on 119 degree East from Intersputnik, a renowned Russian company, at a cost of $28m (Tk217.7bn) with a single lifetime of 15 years.....

Lol.China never shared Brahmaputra data even though lower riparian states are India and BD. So?

That's why still every year there is a loss of life and property in Bangladesh owing to the drastic floods in the very same Brahmaputra river - either the Chinese data wasn't enough or the they were incompetent enough to unable to prepare themselves for the same circumstances - the latest one being a couple of months ago only - it happens every year.

But it's a different story altogether - China never shared that data - what else to expect from these pathetic jammatis!
 

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom