What's new

Bangladesh bans Maududi's books in mosques

Brother, they prefer Tagore books over Hadis or Islamic book. Nauzubillah. :angry:

Tagore book is for literature and Quran and Hadit is for religion. Two different subject. Nothing to prefer one over other. Its not only Tagore we have 100s of novelist and poets who were given due respect.

Cheers...
 
.
I would really appreciate such a move in Pakistan as well !

No you do not want fascism. It does more harm then good. How would you feel if some want's to banned Allahma Iqbal book in Bangladesh because he wrote from Islamic prospective.

Do mind that these same people dislike him but love Tagore.
 
.
First off, there doesn't exist anything call Moududi's ideology. He simply EXPLAINED QURAN & Hadidth with the touch of Tech-Industrial-Material era.

Secondly, even after JI chief's arrest and hundred of other's death and torture by AWAMY fascists, not even a single personal property was destroyed by JI members. So, compare to BJP, Bajrang Dal, VHP, LIKUD, Repubs etc they were like angels let alone hate mongers.

Thirdly, no one need to learn peacefullness of Islam from Bharaties as its so-called Muslim Institutes have been regulated by GOVT thus they have surrenderd to Hindutavyas. So, Indian-Muslims have departed from the core of Islam. And reverse psychology would only work against ignorance but there are Idune, MBI, Skies and Al-Zakirs that don't fall in that category IMHO.

Lastly, sun shines, moon provide lights and earth still function for real GOD fearing creatures that don't create monsterous/open ended boggy to build sinful empire otherwise Namrud, Feroun, Karun, Romans, Soviets etc haven't got abolished. Poisonus are those who blindly mis-speak, imotionally support nationalism etc.

Maududi's own intention may be pure but look at what his party is doing in Pakistan, they are supporting terrorists over the common Pakistani, providing them with material, men and asylum, calling their dead martyrs, terrorizing innocent people(they beat a student to death in peshawar for wearing jeans to prayer), that is why I support any move against them......
 
.
No you do not want fascism. It does more harm then good. How would you feel if some want's to banned Allahma Iqbal book in Bangladesh because he wrote from Islamic prospective.

Do mind that these same people dislike him but love Tagore.

These jamaat guys are disliked in Pakistan because they have a soft corner for terrorists, they also support them openly, to be honest with you, they will stab you in the back as soon as they are given the opportunity..........
 
.
Tagore book is for literature and Quran and Hadit is for religion. Two different subject. Nothing to prefer one over other. Its not only Tagore we have 100s of novelist and poets who were given due respect.

Cheers...

So what is wrong with Madudi's book or Jamat politics? If secularist, leftist, communist and atheist can preach their ideology then why not Islamist as well. They have all the right to do so. You are to counter them with counter ideology rather than force by state machinery. Jamat is not same Jamat of 71. You may not like them but they will always be in Bangladesh in the name Jamat or some other name.

Muslim league as a party no more but Muslim leaguers still strong and exist under BNP. They did not merge under Awamis banner. :coffee:
 
.
I dont mind Moududi's book for intellectual research and all but the way Jamaat used it like a text book to radicalize a segment of our people is despicable. So I support ban..
Lie, damn lie and more lie. Making BD's Jamaat worse than monster by associating everything of it with Bad-Moududi(Astagfirullah) is AWAMY "Art of the war". I HAVE SEEN SEA OF CHANGE IN PEOPLE THAT HAS HATED MOUDUDI BY LISTENING FROM COMMIE-MALAUNS INITIALLY BUT GONE 180 Degree after reading his books. Furthermore, BD JI's ex-Amir even disobeyed some of Moududi's controversial remarks. So, who are you trying to fool here? One doesn't need to be Jamatties to understand your type, mission but needs to possess some knowledge of Islam and its parties.
 
.
These jamaat guys are disliked in Pakistan because they have a soft corner for terrorists, they also support them openly, to be honest with you, they will stab you in the back as soon as they are given the opportunity..........

Imran Khan also shown support and always asked for a kind of agreement with Talibans rather than forces. Back stabling is the character of all political party.

Do you remember the honeymoon period between Muslim league(N) and PPP against Musharraf and Muslim league(Q). I will not be surprise if Muslim league (N+Q+M) joint force against PPP on next election. ;)
 
.
So what is wrong with Madudi's book or Jamat politics? If secularist, leftist, communist and atheist can preach their ideology then why not Islamist as well. They have all the right to do so. You are to counter them with counter ideology rather than force by state machinery. Jamat is not same Jamat of 71. You may not like them but they will always be in Bangladesh in the name Jamat or some other name.

Muslim league as a party no more but Muslim leaguers still strong and exist under BNP. They did not merge under Awamis banner. :coffee:

Moududi preached radicalism. We took the same stand against radical leftist. Heard of Cross Fire?

Muslim Leage took the shelter under leftist NAP and Jasad who joined BNP. BNP is struggling now as soon as those leftist influence faded out of BNP. BNP looking more and more like Muslim League now but having a dismal future..
 
.
Lie, damn lie and more lie. Making BD's Jamaat worse than monster by associating everything of it with Bad-Moududi(Astagfirullah) is AWAMY "Art of the war". I HAVE SEEN SEA OF CHANGE IN PEOPLE THAT HAS HATED MOUDUDI BY LISTENING FROM COMMIE-MALAUNS INITIALLY BUT GONE 180 Degree after reading his books. Furthermore, BD JI's ex-Amir even disobeyed some of Moududi's controversial remarks. So, who are you trying to fool here? One doesn't need to be Jamatties to understand your type, mission but needs to possess some knowledge of Islam and its parties.

Shibir cadres, JMB, HUJI who are caught by police found with translation of Moududi books.
 
.
Maududi ideology is based on hatred and religious supremacy for muslims, something that goes against many of the ideals of Islam, I believe it is a good step by the BD govt to ban his works which are poisoning our society...............

Man what you know about Islam and its Ideals? You even don't know what are you talking about.

Maududi's call and writings is Pan-Islamic wheather we like it it or not its a Universal Truth. Mawdudi's influence was widespread. According to historian Philip Jenkins, Egyptians Hassan al-Banna and Sayyid Qutb (Founder of Ikhwan-ul-Muslimeen in Egypt) read him. Qutb "borrowed and expanded" Mawdudi's concept for being a modern as well as pre-Muhammadan phenomenon, and of the need for an Islamist revolutionary vanguard movement. His ideas influenced Abdullah Azzam, the Palestinian Islamist jurist. The South Asian diaspora, including "significant numbers" in Britain, were "hugely influenced" by Mawdudi's work. Mawdudi even had a major impact on Shia Iran, where Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini is reputed to have met Mawdudi as early as 1963 and later translated his works into Persian. "To the present day, Iran's revolutionary rhetoric often draws on his themes." [46] After Imam Ibn Taymiyyah He is the second thinker who influenced the Muslim Political thinking in The Modern day world. He is a Renaissance Man for the politiclal Islamthrought West Asia and remains so.

By Banning... BD govt axe his own foot and nothing else. Its a war of ideas and philosophy which can only be defeated by matching the same and I think by banning actually BD Govt accepted his defeat in this regards. http://www.defence.pk/forums/images/smilies/cute/hang2.gif
 
.
Maududi's own intention may be pure but look at what his party is doing in Pakistan, they are supporting terrorists over the common Pakistani, providing them with material, men and asylum, calling their dead martyrs, terrorizing innocent people(they beat a student to death in peshawar for wearing jeans to prayer), that is why I support any move against them......
Question is who defines another as terrorist? Kashmiries are terrorist in Indian's eyes, Palestinians same as ISROs eyes but even the pseudo secular of PAK wouldn't agree with that kind of definition, would they? You are claiming JI-PAK walas as terrorist supporters but what have they been saying for yrs are becoming true as day-light. Similarly what Moududi said about PAK and Indian Muslims became true as well. Wasn't it secular Mush that back-Stabbed Afghans, which created the seed of current mess in PAK? And there wasn't any suicide bombing in ME before ISRO was created, there wasn't any car boming in IRAQ before Invaders went there and certainly there wasn't any attack in ISI head-quarter before same group of people got cozier with your military-elite (Obviously secular). So, re-define your thoughts on "who are terrorist" first before even go further with this line of discussion.
 
.
Moududi preached radicalism. We took the same stand against radical leftist. Heard of Cross Fire?

Muslim Leage took the shelter under leftist NAP and Jasad who joined BNP. BNP is struggling now as soon as those leftist influence faded out of BNP. BNP looking more and more like Muslim League now but having a dismal future..

you are also a secular radical so there is no different between you and so call radical Jamatis. ;)

It's good that lefties gone. We do not need Munafiq. BNP will come back stronger and more Islamic in near future. Bro you can not demise BNP because there are too many anti Awami Bangladeshi still exist.

Say, what if I like Madudi's book. Can you stop me reading it..:smokin:
 
.
you are also a secular radical so there is no different between you and so call radical Jamatis. ;)

You made my day...
It's good that lefties gone. We do not need Munafiq. BNP will come back stronger and more Islamic in near future. Bro you can not demise BNP because there are too many anti Awami Bangladeshi still exist.
Wishfull thinking.. good luck
Say, what if I like Madudi's book. Can you stop me reading it..:smokin:

No i cant but if i can stop islamic foundation to stop patronizing Moududi books then i could save a whole of youngs..;)
 
.
Tagore book is for literature and Quran and Hadit is for religion. Two different subject. Nothing to prefer one over other. Its not only Tagore we have 100s of novelist and poets who were given due respect.

Cheers...

If you really want to enrich Bangladesh with good literature then you are to read Allama Iqbal, Maulana Rumi and poet like Hafiz. Tagore has no chance against these guys.
 
.
Is there any source confirming that there is a BAN on his books. AFAIK it is only being withdrawn from GOVERNMENT funded masjids.
---------------
Bangladesh orders author's books removed

The Bangladesh government has ordered tens of thousands of mosques and libraries to remove books written by the controversial founder of an Islamic party, an official said on Saturday.

The state-run Islamic Foundation took the decision after Syed Abul Ala Maududi's books were deemed "anti-Islamic" and likely to foster militancy in the Indian subcontinent, its head Shamim Mohammad Afjal told AFP.

Maududi is the founder of Jamaat-e-Islami party, which has a large number of followers in South Asia, home to about 450 million Muslims.

The Jamaat is the largest Islamic party in Bangladesh, with two elected lawmakers in the parliament.

"We have taken the decision to withdraw books written by Maududi from all of the state-funded 24,000 libraries attached to mosques," Afjal said.

Muslim-majority Bangladesh has 270,000 mosques, but only a fraction are directly funded by the government, according to the foundation.

"Maududi's books have given bad name to Islam as they encourage terrorism and militancy. His philosophy is against the basic teachings of Koran and the traditions and saying of Prophet Mohammed," he said.

Although the Bangladeshi and Pakistani branches of Jamaat-e-Islami party are fully independent, their supporters avidly follow Maududi's books and his political and radical interpretations of Koran.

Born in India, Maududi headed the Jamaat in Pakistan for decades. He died in 1979.

A.T.M. Azharul Islam, a spokesman for Jamaat-e-Islami in Bangladesh, called the ban "unnecessary".

"There have been no instances in which Maududi's books have promoted terrorism. The books were written 50 to 60 years ago and are now being read and published in many countries. There have been no complaints," he said.

The government's decision follows arrests in recent weeks of five senior leaders of Jamaat-e-Islami Bangladesh on charges ranging from offending religious sentiments of Muslims to violence during a recent nationwide strike.

Its leaders have also been accused of war crimes by groups investigating Bangladesh's liberation war of 1971, including the killing of dozens of intellectuals during the nine-month war against Pakistan.

Jamaat leaders deny the allegations.

Bangladesh was part of Pakistan until an independence campaign, led by Sheikh Mujibur Rahman, saw the country achieve independence, after a bloody war that the government says killed three million people.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom