What's new

Bangladesh bans 'Banglish' to protect local tongue

CaPtAiN_pLaNeT

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
May 10, 2010
Messages
7,685
Reaction score
0
Bangladesh bans 'Banglish' to protect local tongue

AFP: Bangladesh bans 'Banglish' to protect local tongue

By Shafiq Alam (AFP) – 1 hour ago

DHAKA — A Bangladesh court has outlawed the use of English slang known as "Banglish" on television and radio stations, a move welcomed by experts who worry about a foreign invasion of their language.

The High Court issued the order on Thursday "to uphold the sanctity of our mother tongue" and stop the "rape" of Bengali and its 1,000-year past, a state prosecutor said.


The history of Bengali, which is spoken by at least 250 million people on the subcontinent, is wrapped up with the creation of Bangladesh as a country in 1971.

The deeply impoverished nation was previously part of Pakistan and its independence movement was fuelled partly by the attempt by Pakistani administrators to impose Urdu as the state language.

The head of the Bangla Academy, a state-run institution that publishes books and conducts research on Bengali, said the verdict was "long overdue".

"These FM radios and televisions were creating a strange language and almost destroyed the dynamics of our beautiful mother tongue," Shamsuzzaman Khan told AFP.

"It is a timely order. It will save our language from destruction. We have already seen how the Filipino language lost its glory due to the imposition of American English," he said.


The court order comes just days before the country celebrates the 60-year anniversary of the Language Movement, a protest in which half a dozen students were shot dead as they protested Pakistan's move to impose Urdu.

Dozens of private television stations and radio stations that feature music and talk-shows directed at teenagers and people in their twenties have sprouted in Bangladesh over the last five or six years.

Use of "Banglish" in which Bengali and English words are mixed seamlessly together is widespread, as is "Hinglish" in India -- a combination of Hindi and English.

"The court has ordered them not to use words which are foreign to our language," deputy attorney general Altaf Hossain told AFP.

"It asked them not to broadcast or anchor programmes using distorted Bengali language or pronounce Bengali words in a distorted form," he said.

The court said this distortion of the language was tantamount to "rape", Hossain said, adding it had also ordered a committee to be set up to oversee how the language should be used by broadcasters.

Several students who spoke to AFP on Friday broadly welcomed the move as a wake-up call that would make them more aware of the importance of preserving Bengali, but none seemed to think "Banglish" would disappear.

"It sounds good and it's something different. This one of the reasons why FM radios are becoming popular," Jion, a 22-year-old student of Dhaka University, told AFP.

"A lot of people also hate this because they can't accept change. People who are fans of classic Bengali writers like Rabindranath Tagore, they won't like it," he added.

The court order followed a newspaper commentary piece entitled "Language pollution is as deadly as river pollution" by English language professor and Bengali fiction writer Syed Manjurul Islam on Thursday.

Professor Islam told AFP that he was concerned about the role the FM radios and television stations played in creating a language that was completely foreign to Bengali.

"I am a teacher and I can see everyday how these youths were distorting the language. Because of these stations, they are now talking in a language that's not Bengali. They can't even talk or write properly in Bengali," he said.

"I am greatly concerned. They are turning Bengali into a street language. It's like a developer constructing a building by uprooting the grave of his forefathers," he said.

Sabbir Hasan, a radio jockey at private Radio Today, also welcomed the verdict, but said the media was not the only one to blame.

"I understand the intention is to uphold the sanctity of our language, for which our students gave their lives," he said in a reference to the pre-independence protesters.

"But the reality is not only the media is responsible. Our young generation likes to talk this way, mixing English words in Bangla sentences. The tendency is more rampant in upper class people and private university students.

"Upper class people think it gives them status," he said.
 
But the reality is not only the media is responsible. Our young generation likes to talk this way, mixing English words in Bangla sentences. The tendency is more rampant in upper class people and private university students.

"Upper class people think it gives them status," he said.
all the english medium must be closed ar english sikkha dite hole ta sudhu school ei sikhate hobe.sei sathe dhakaiader dhakaia,urdu,arabic,bogura,rajsahi,naogaon,sylheter sylhoti bhasa,rangpuri dialect etc procholon er uddog nite hobe ja kina india ,pakistan tader deshe nieche..emon na hole,e ar kichui na ekta kaguje ail/neeti/rull-nishi hoei theke jabe
 
On one hand I want to welcome an action that aids a language live longer, but on the other hand I find it is beyond the competence of a court of justice to decide what does and does not make a language, especially when they show that incompetence by the inaccurate analogy between vocabulary-borrowing and forced sexual intercourse.
 
freedom of speech ok,but speaking a language with banglish style....not acceptable.
 
Watch the following video and specially at 4:48 to see what is Banglish and how these so called English medium boys/girls talk now a days... :lol:

N these same boys n girls are recruited by the radio and tv channels for different talk or tv shows... So what else you can expect. But banning the way of talking is too much as how people should talk can not be enforced apart from news.

If anyone try to talk in a pure bengali manner it will not remain a talk show.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
On one hand I want to welcome an action that aids a language live longer,
I Completely agree with you,but I think the court have no other way,actualy no one likes banglish style,only a few are doing these and saying others dont knw to speak , so ppl ,court all had no other option but to stop it
 
^Yes I think it is a good idea to impose such on the media. Common folk can go on speaking as they wish, but in the long run media will influence their diction back to purer Bangla.
 
Watch the following video and specially at 4:48 to see what is Banglish and how these so called English medium boys/girls talk now a days... :lol:

N these same boys n girls are recruited by the radio and tv channels for different talk or tv shows... So what else you can expect. But banning the way of talking is too much as how people should talk can not be enforced apart from news.

If anyone try to talk in a pure bengali manner it will not remain a talk show.


bro, i personally know one of them, they used to go to AISD and ISD, one is a school run by the american embassy and the other follow iba curriculum. they are both international schools in dhaka and both take their tuitions in dollars, their teachers are also foreigners. so the percentage of these kids are very small alomost insignificant, only the elites of elites in bangladesh go to these schools.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
^Apparently it is acceptable to a part of your society, and let's not forget that you do live in a democracy.
brother,its true that we are.but these english medium ppl are worst then evrything.they neither have respect for democracy,nor for ppl.in their school history means " history of america/england",religion ="anti islamic speech,christianism",doing conspiracy against nation with america ,england.not that only,if a rich persons child have no talent but he has money he can even buy & bring certificate for his child from these medium.these ediotic child dont knw anything but they pretend they are everything.bangladeshi english medium is completely different than E.M OF OTHER COUNTRYS
 
sorry to say,things may be different on foreign countries but in bangladesh english mediums ,their students ,teacher all are not just destroying our language but also socio-islamic culture and by spreading these type of culture they are showing this is bd and we are its ppl when the bangladeshi culture,language everything is different. and why would a bangladeshi have to go E.M just to learn english !
I my self does course on spoken english on du along with my friends & I can say that , it's better then english medium.we have enough talented teachers,so if we become curious ,careful ...no need to go there
 
He seems envy of you guys.

Bro, i went to AISD in dhaka, I just did my bachelors from University of toronto and waiting for my law school acceptance. UofT has been constantly ranked in the top 20 universities in the world, this year it ranked 11th i assume, i have friends from Bangladesh that go to hardvard, stamford, lse, cambridge, you name it they are there, they all plan on going back to bangladeshi, they are very much patriotic to the country and miss bangladesh as much as the most die hard bangladeshi. What syed naved is spreading is pure propaganda, in bangladesh rich are very much hated by the poor and thus they spill out propaganda.
 
Back
Top Bottom