all regional languages must be made national languages of Pakistan

[darkinsky]

I am what you can call a dheet paindoo Punjabi and i disagree with your assessment. I doubt that you have ever been to the rural Punjab even for a visit. I have walked those dusty terrains and lived the life of a paindoo. Your opinion about rural punjab is at least 20 years behind.

well in my opinion if we keep punjabi language like how it is treated and all other languages of Pakistan they will loose their importance, to preserve Pakistani regional culture it is important to make all languages official, Punjabis are very patriotic people, but patriotism doesn't necessarily means punishing them for something not needed

only way to save the decline of Punjabi language and culture, as languages reflect culture of a nation, it is important to make all languages equally powerful and meaningful

 

[Kompromat]

well in my opinion if we keep punjabi language like how it is treated and all other languages of Pakistan they will loose their importance, to preserve Pakistani regional culture it is important to make all languages official, Punjabis are very patriotic people, but patriotism doesn't necessarily means punishing them for something not needed

only way to save the decline of Punjabi language and culture, as languages reflect culture of a nation, it is important to make all languages equally powerful and meaningful

I disagree. Taking Punjabi or Pashto or Baluchi for example, what we need to do is to encourage their use and to make them mandatory to be taught at schools. They should be optional in other provinces for any takers. Literature, arts music in indigenous languages must be bolstered. Like dramas and films in Pashto, Balochi, Punjabi, Sindhi etc

This will develop a baseline knowledge of those languages, then we need to offer higher level education in those languages like Masters or even a PhD in indigenous culture and languages. We should also work to make the Music and arts market in those languages more financially lucrative so more and more people cold join it.

 

[darkinsky]

I disagree. Taking Punjabi or Pashto or Baluchi for example, what we need to do is to encourage their use and to make them mandatory to be taught at schools. They should be optional in other provinces for any takers. Literature, arts music in indigenous languages must be bolstered. Like dramas and films in Pashto, Balochi, Punjabi, Sindhi etc

This will develop a baseline knowledge of those languages, then we need to offer higher level education in those languages like Masters or even a PhD in indigenous culture and languages. We should also work to make the Music and arts market in those languages more financially lucrative so more and more people cold join it.

well it already exists in Pakistan, for example in my school days there was Sindi subject which by the way was never effective

 

[Kompromat]

well it already exists in Pakistan, for example in my school days there was Sindi subject which by the way was never effective

We don't see immediate benefits of language studies. Its a gradual process. We are blessed with beautiful languages and cultures, and its a responsibility of our generation to hand it over to the next one.

 

[Ferocious]

Punjabi, seraiki, Balochi, Sindi, Pashto, Hindko, gilgiti, Baltistani, Kashmiri, Brahvi, Darri etc must be made national languages other than Urdu

I disagree. Urdu, along with English, do well as the national languages! Helps bring about more unity in a way!