Alarming decrease in Hindu population in Bangladesh

[Jade]

Are you a born retard to speak of war and destruction? Can India has the power to do wht a retard like you propose? Seems you represnt an equally retard Indian govt. Ask it to invade and wait for the intended results.

If not for that 'retard-ness' from India, Bangladesh would not have been on the map.

This is not a war, but a human issue. If persecution of Hindus lead to refugees into India than it become India's issue. Remember 1971? when west Pakistan persecuting east Pakistanis there was a mass refugees into India and India had to intervene, resulting in Bangladesh.

I though you should have known your History.

If you repeat what west Pakistanis did to you to Hindus. You may have to see again India intervening

 

[DarkPrince]

Buddy, the reason behind the acceptance of Islam by Hindus and their emigration is the matter of discussion. It isn't about the religion's superiority or anything like that, the reason may be completely different.

If I have to pick from being a Hindu or protection/ stopping discrimination of my family and kids, I will rather change to the religion of the majority or leave the society and settle where I can practice the former one. Those who can't emigrate and can't cope up with the daily difficulties they go through , conversion will always be the route out.

One has to understand the Survival mode of the humans too. In Orissa, people who were dying of hunger were converted by Christians for two time meal. Any person will pick Christianity if it avoids the death of his kid due to hunger.

Instead of bashing each other, we have to look at the problem within our own and other countries and discuss about the possible solution.

look i understand what u r trying 2 say but religious violence is rare in BD

i dont think they accpeting islam with out their will

 

[LaBong]

Hindus are not converting to Islam in Bangladesh in any large scale, there might be one or two stray cases but to say they are converting villages after villages is just plain lie and concocting stories.

Every Bengali knows that.

Except Iajduni, none of these bds seem to have atleast recognize that there is indeed a problem. So far all I heard is how Hindus are treacherous and loyal to India, how they convert villages after villages and how they are xenophobic towards Muslims. Well done.

 

[KRAIT]

look i understand what u r trying 2 say but religious violence is rare in BD

i dont think they accpeting islam with out their will

See the forced conversion doesn't require violence. There has been case where a girl from Hindu family was kidnapped and forcefully married to a Muslim guy and when the girl's family dared to go to court, they told the girl not to admit them as her family or they will kill them. Point is we may not find these news unless someone goes to court like that family. Many cases go unnoticed. The case was from Pakistan.

What happened in Orissa was not due to violence. Bible for Bread - That's it.

I admit religious violence is rare but are we aware of the conversion reasons behind ?

May be we should analyze the situation deeply and logically without being biased. Islam offers them peace, stability and easier way to adapt in the society.

Lets suppose I live in BD, if my kid plays with Muslim boys, go to their home, celebrate Eid with them, it will create a soft spot on my kid's mind, more understanding of Muslims and his next generation may opt for Islam as the change in thinking grows to an extent that makes them to accept Islam and feels comfort too.

If a Hindu girl falls in love with a Muslim boy and majority of the society doesn't oppose it, they will get married and she may accept Islam. That means the sons and daughter of that Hindu girl will be following Islam.

See there is detailed sociological, demographical and mathematical study that takes into account all these situations and cases.

I am not saying that they are accepting Islam without their will but we should look at the process too, the trajectory rather than the starting point A (Hinduism) to end point (Islam).

 

[BRICS]

If after 1000 years they have not learnt their lesson, if they have not organised themselves by now, then Hindus deserve everything that happens to them.

 

[asad71]

1. Firstly because of biological / natural causes Hindu population is growing far less than that of Muslim not only in BD but all over SA. Food habit, celibacy, reservations about widow re-marriage, life style, abstinence on certain days, general acceptance of abstinence / celibacy as a religious edict, compulsion of marrying within cast, etc cause Hindus to grow less. Hinduism does not allow conversion.

2. On the other-hand Muslims are biologically all that Hindus are not when it comes to procreation. Being a revolutionary faith championing social reform, equality, brotherhood and social justice, Islam attracts converts who are welcome and straightaway accepted as equals.

3. Beside the above two basics, the other cause is the political mischief engineered by BAL. Night and day they frighten / intimidate them so that they come into their protection to serve as vote bank. This fright causes Hindus to emigrate at an opportunity. This coupled with the non-stop anti-Muslim riots in India cause the BD Hindus to emigrate.

4. Because of all these reasons, the Hindus have truly become suspect when national security is involved. Sensitive jobs are not open to them except perhaps under BAL. Generally speaking all, repeat all, Hindu families have parallel families in India. It has been observed when a young Hindu has done well in academics he shifts to India to settle down. Quite often Hindus are involved in stealing funds from banks or companies to flee across. It will be foolish not to understand that the BD Hindu community is more loyal to India than to BD.

 

[livingdead]

I agree with some of the observations here. The bangladeshi hindus I have met do have a interest in India, they consider India as their spiritual homeland.
Also, they tend to be more educated than others in bangladesh and their birth rate is bound to be less (same in India, hindus in southern states have lower birth rate than bihar and UP, and parsis have very low birth rate).

There was persecution of hindus during BAL period but lot less now, also the extent of persecution is not comparable to other countries nearby.( much less)

 

[dollarman]

Partition and two nation theory should have been absolute. All non-Muslims should have come to India, and all Muslims should have left India. Only then can we finally have a peaceful and prosperous India.

The Muslims in Bangladesh and Pakistan have completely killed off the Hindus in their lands, while in our country they have already increased from 8 to 13%. When these Muslims asked for a separate country in 1947, what was the reason for fools like Nehru and Gandhi to keep fighting for their rights in India? Something that has never made sense to me...

 

[funtoosh]

^^ yes i agree india did a stupid thing by not sending all its sunnis to pak. they are the cause of the problem

 

[TopCat]

Partition and two nation theory should have been absolute. All non-Muslims should have come to India, and all Muslims should have left India. Only then can we finally have a peaceful and prosperous India.

The Muslims in Bangladesh and Pakistan have completely killed off the Hindus in their lands, while in our country they have already increased from 8 to 13%. When these Muslims asked for a separate country in 1947, what was the reason for fools like Nehru and Gandhi to keep fighting for their rights in India? Something that has never made sense to me...

That exactly was the idea. But once India made plan to steal land from Muslim they had legitimize it saying that India is for Hindus and Muslims. Now you are stuck with 200 million muslims. Neither PK nor BD have enough space to accommodate them. Either India has to give away proportional land with its Muslim otherwise it has to swallow all the Muslim that it stuck with.

 

[funtoosh]

1. Firstly because of biological / natural causes Hindu population is growing far less than that of Muslim not only in BD but all over SA. Food habit, celibacy, reservations about widow re-marriage, life style, abstinence on certain days, general acceptance of abstinence / celibacy as a religious edict, compulsion of marrying within cast, etc cause Hindus to grow less. Hinduism does not allow conversion.

2. On the other-hand Muslims are biologically all that Hindus are not when it comes to procreation. Being a revolutionary faith championing social reform, equality, brotherhood and social justice, Islam attracts converts who are welcome and straightaway accepted as equals.

3. Beside the above two basics, the other cause is the political mischief engineered by BAL. Night and day they frighten / intimidate them so that they come into their protection to serve as vote bank. This fright causes Hindus to emigrate at an opportunity. This coupled with the non-stop anti-Muslim riots in India cause the BD Hindus to emigrate.

4. Because of all these reasons, the Hindus have truly become suspect when national security is involved. Sensitive jobs are not open to them except perhaps under BAL. Generally speaking all, repeat all, Hindu families have parallel families in India. It has been observed when a young Hindu has done well in academics he shifts to India to settle down. Quite often Hindus are involved in stealing funds from banks or companies to flee across. It will be foolish not to understand that the BD Hindu community is more loyal to India than to BD.

sorry muslim does not champion equality or social justice. they also have a caste wsystem, and also oppress non-sunnis.
muslims have a strategy to out breed everyone and cause problems after they reach a certain number. Hindus are more responsible than that

 

[dollarman]

That exactly was the idea. But once India made plan to steal land from Muslim they had legitimize it saying that India is for Hindus and Muslims. Now you are stuck with 200 million muslims. Neither PK nor BD have enough space to accommodate them. Either India has to give away proportional land with its Muslim otherwise it has to swallow all the Muslim that it stuck with.

No, third option, which is what bangladesh and Pakistan have done to Hindus is the way to go for India.

 

[funtoosh]

That exactly was the idea. But once India made plan to steal land from Muslim they had legitimize it saying that India is for Hindus and Muslims. Now you are stuck with 200 million muslims. Neither PK nor BD have enough space to accommodate them. Either India has to give away proportional land with its Muslim otherwise it has to swallow all the Muslim that it stuck with.

sorry tht cannot happen, evern today indian muslims have right to go into bd or pak. because thats why these countries were born, if not, then there is no need for pak or bd to exist. and overpopulation in pak and bd is not indias problem.
200 million in bd and 300 million in pak is possible

 

[TopCat]

No, third option, which is what bangladesh and Pakistan have done to Hindus is the way to go for India.

Not that you did not try...

sorry tht cannot happen, evern today indian muslims have right to go into bd or pak. because thats why these countries were born, if not, then there is no need for pak or bd to exist. and overpopulation in pak and bd is not indias problem.
200 million in bd and 300 million in pak is possible

They are always welcome but they got to bring land with them. We did exactly the same in 1947. We brought land with us.

 

[dollarman]

Not that you did not try...

They are always welcome but they got to bring land with them. We did exactly the same in 1947. We brought land with us.

We don't really care about your demands. You can take them, or dump them in the Bay of Bengal (or Arabian Sea in Pakistan's case) if you don't have any space. Enough of this one sided BS where Hindus from Bangladesh and Pakistan run to India for their lives, while Muslims here keep living scratch-free.