Afghanistan cannot be put together as one country: Joe Biden

[Kabira]

You think their people are dead?

Whatever you do today...you will see the effects in a decade or two...like cold war effects and WOT. ..

Blunders should be stopped when they are about to happen not when they have happened ...then it is too late. ..

The next generations won't be forgiving ....long term planning is best...

Pakistan isn't going to divide Afghanistan. US will eventually if peace deal isn't reached with taliban.

 

[Dubious]

Pakistan isn't going to divide Pakistan. US will eventually if peace deal isn't reached with taliban.

Pakistan won't but sold out like PPP will...and disgruntled anyone would side them...and if not today...There will be another bhutoo like PPP threat...no one forgets enemy of state easily...BD still hating us despite decades passed....

 

[Kabira]

Pakistan won't but sold out like PPP will...and disgruntled anyone would side them...and if not today...There will be another bhutoo like PPP threat...no one forgets enemy of state easily...BD still hating us despite decades passed....

FATA, Balochistan insurgencies were much worse then BD.

Federal government is going to clean Karachi garbage =its attack on Sindhis lmao Eventually PPP will have to let power devolve to local level.

 

[Dubious]

Eventually PPP will have to let power devolve to local level.

Eventually yea...but till that happens it will be chaotic

 

[Foxtrot Delta]

pashtoon and hazara regions can stay together along with wakhan corridor which i think china wants.
the persian speakers should go to iran rather than tajik or turkemen identity.

although as a pakistani i think pakistan should not be the one talking about dividing afghanistan. it is for the afghan people to decide what they want to do. but fact of the matter is clear pashtoon regions fall under pakistani influence.

 

[TNT]

Pakistan should never let Afghanistan be divided.

 

[Zarmeena Rashad]

I can't believe it , Afghanistan belongs to it's people. They are the ones to decide what to do and I dont think even talking about division is a good idea.
Let us all focus on our own country & try not be a part of foreign agenda again.

 

[YeBeWarned]

If Pakistan still hold that influence over Afghan as Joe Paaji claims , than wouldn't that be considered as US Failure ? after all they are there for over 17 years with their military , CIA , Black Water , NATO , ANA , RAW etc ? or you are telling me one country is actually standing its ground against all these Powerful countries and their Intelligence and militaries to keep a hold on 3 Afghan Counties ?

 

[jamal18]

Pakistan should never let Afghanistan be divided.

I think what Biden is saying is that the absolute priority for the US is to keep troops in the area. If it can't be done with the present Afghan government, let's have a new scenario that makes it easier to keep troops there.

A 'compliant' Taliban, or Pakistani ownership of the land.

Poisonous chalice, don't touch it.

 

[Zibago]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1172329827996618754

Finally someone who says like it is. Future of Afghanistan lies in being 4-5 different countries.

The Pashtun country will be most problematic to deal with the other countries could be easier to have good relationships with

 

[B.K.N]

Divide and conquer.

Afghanistan is already under American rule they are not planning to conquer it
They are planning to get rid of of it Afghanistan as a country is surviving only due to American funding and military support

 

[Yaseen1]

it is policy of west from the beginning to divide and rule

 

[Dubious]

Afghanistan is already under American rule they are not planning to conquer it
They are planning to get rid of of it Afghanistan as a country is surviving only due to American funding and military support

America isnt the only threat on the planet...ANY one advocating any Sovereign state to be split will not be forgotten...Pakistan doesnt need additional burden/ enemies nor for its foreseen future!

And having an angry Afghanistan on our border will be fuel/ ready to be used by Pakistan's enemies...we cant afford such a future!

 

[B.K.N]

we cant afford such a future!

Having a divided Afghanistan at western border would be the best thing for Pakistan
And Afghanistan can't survive as a one country without American support

 

[fitpOsitive]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1172329827996618754

Finally someone who says like it is. Future of Afghanistan lies in being 4-5 different countries.

We Pakistanis will not allow Balkanization of Afghanistan. In fact, we are not in favour of balkanization of any country, including India.