What's new

'Aamir Khan, A Muslim, In Mahabharata': Javed Akhtar Responds To Trolls

thesolar65

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jul 3, 2012
Messages
4,922
Reaction score
-12
Country
India
Location
India
Aamir Khan adapting Mahabharata on the big screen and starring in the film has not gone down well with certain sections of Twitter

  1. There were plenty unsavoury comments attacking Aamir on Twitter
  2. Javed Akhtar lashed out at Twitter trolls
  3. You know nothing about our Indian traditions: Javed Akhtar to trolls
Aamir Khan's ambitious adaptation of the Mahabharata has galvanised trolls into action, in turning prompting writer Javed Akhtar to get involved. Aamir's magnum opus, which might be made in several parts, has been making headlines recently after reports that the film (or films) could be co-produced by industrialist Mukesh Ambani. Aamir's Mahabharata is very much in the planning-ideating stage as of now and almost no details - except that the 53-year-old actor considers it his 'dream' project and the budget is allegedly a whopping Rs. 1,000 crore - are available. Equally unclear is what role Aamir Khan intends to play in the film (or series) - speculation says Krishna or Karna. And this has not gone down well with certain sections of Twitter because, wait for it, Aamir is Muslim.

It began with a tweet from a troll (who appears to be a Frenchman living in India) two days ago which read: "Why should Aamir Khan, a Muslim, play in most ancient and sacred of Hindu epics, the Mahabharata? Would Muslims allow a Hindu to play life of Mohamed?" The tweet also asked if Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government was going to "be like the Congress and just stand by in the name of secularism."

Javed Akhtar was incensed by the post and lashed out in the comments thread, asking "I would like to know which foreign agency is paying you to spread this kind of perverse and poisonous thoughts in our country...You obviously you know nothing about our Indian traditions and culture."



Pressed by another troll on the 'would Muslims allow a Hindu to play Mohammed' question, Javed Akhtar responded:


Javed Akhtar wasn't the only person to defend Aamir in the comments thread, something the original troll complained about later and said that the Hindus disagreeing with him ought to be ashamed:


There were plenty other unsavoury comments attacking not just Aamir but also Mukesh Ambani for reportedly financing the film. Aamir's 2014 film PK, which satirized religion, was invoked as well as his controversial comments on 'intolerance' some years ago.

However, some tweets were more concerned with who was going to be cast in the film. Hrithik Roshan or no one for Arjun, said one.


Earlier this year, it was reported that Aamir Khan had backed out of a biopic of astronaut Rakesh Sharma to focus on a project which would take several years to hit the screens. At that time, it was suggested that Aamir Khan is adapting Mahabharata under his production banner.

Just to be clear, there are no confirmed details about Aamir's adaptation - we don't even know for certain that he is making a version of the Mahabharata. If he does, it might well be the third such. The first is an adaptation of Randamoozham, which chronicles the events of the Mahabharata from Bheem's perspective. Mohanlal has been finalised to play the lead role. The second project has reportedly been proposed by Baahubali director SS Rajamouli. Last year, Aamir Khan had said that he would like to collaborate with Rajamouli if he adapted Mahabharata on the big screen. "I'm a huge fan of Rajamouli's work and if he ever plans to make Mahabharata, I'd love to play Krishna or Karna. I might actually go with Krishna," he told PTI.
 
. .
8-) So sad Indian muslims are scared for their lives now They need to demand a new country

When is Amir Making Bin Qasim ? Project

Mohamad Bin Qasim comes to Indus Valley
muhammad-bin-qasim-mcqs.jpg
 
. . .
Even I would object to Aamir Khan playing Krishna. Not because he is a muslim. But for the fact that Krishna was dark skinned man with curly hair. Aamir Khan does not look like Krishna at all. It's like a blue eyed blonde guy playing role of an African man.

No one objected when Hrithik Roshan played an IVC man in Mohenjadaro.
IVC people did not look like Mr Hrithik Roshan whose ancestory lies in Central Asia.

Upper caste North Indian Bollywood white washing history of my ancestors boils my blood.
 
.
Not interested in bollywood and have not checked the concerned twitter accounts but I'll bet the muslims have a bigger problem with Aamir playing Krishna etc than others.
 
.
:o: I don't know but Amir playing Lord Krishna of Hindu is a provocative move :smokin:
Considering the tense situation in India he might risk his own life unfortunately some hot headed man might get offended

What happened to Mr Om Puri who just praised Pakistan hmm easy to see Amir is playing with fire
 
. .
Foreigners subjugate the indians in all forms.

India shall be liberared.
 
.
Pressed by another troll on the 'would Muslims allow a Hindu to play Mohammed' question, Javed Akhtar responded:

If know them they won’t allow even a Muslim . Have you decided to emulate them .
 
.
where did you get that from ?
It's common knowledge. He is depicted as charcoal skinned dark man with curly in earliest of his paintings.
The word krishna means black.

Young Krishna asks his mother yasodha, why is radha so fair and I am so black?
 
.
Amir should make movie about

  • Jinnah "The Great Leader"
  • Mohammad Bin Qasim
  • Any Mogal Empirors
  • Tipu Sultan
  • Sir Syed , role of education in region
  • Edhi
  • Bhutto
  • Free Kashmir for Pakistan
  • Amir the UK boxer here is a nice project
  • Salah Ud Din Ayubi , Liberator of Jerusalam 8-). Release it also in Israel if you want
lot of projects

Just don't understand logic to portray a religious Indian thing specially with all the negative sentiment existing in that country , playing with tense fire

He is being disrespectful Amir should know better :nono:

Playing a wrestler vs Religious figure are two drastic extremes ...
 
Last edited:
.
When questioned by another one with respect to movies PK :

Let us have a similar comedy scene on Allah and Muhammad dear

Javed Said :
If your ideals are Isis Talibans and fanatic Mullas I can only feel sorry for you .
 
.
It's common knowledge. He is depicted as charcoal skinned dark man with curly in earliest of his paintings.
The word krishna means black.

Young Krishna asks his mother yasodha, why is radha so fair and I am so black?
"common knowledge", really ? :lol:

you are just another rat consumed by his inferiority complex.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom