What's new

8 days left will GST bill will get passed in the Winter Session.

Grevion

BANNED
Joined
Sep 3, 2012
Messages
2,452
Reaction score
-2
Country
India
Location
India
With just eight working days left in the month-long winter session of Parliament, the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) has decided to give one last push to its reforms agenda in the Rajya Sabha even as it tries to win the Congress party’s support.

The NDA now plans to hold a four-hour-long discussion on the goods and services tax (GST)-related bill in the Rajya Sabha this week, along with three hours on the real estate bill, said senior Union ministers.

Prospects of movement on the GST grew on Friday with the government submitting some proposals to the Congress in expectation of a response by Monday when Parliament was set to meet again.

The winter session is scheduled to conclude on 23 December.

Opposition parties had demanded that the two bills be sent to the parliamentary committees for further discussion.

“A total of 16 bills are listed to be taken up for discussion this week. Out of these bills, GST and real estate bill are on top of the list, and seven hours have been allotted for discussion on the two bills. We hope that there will be debate on these two bills and it will be passed. The opposition must allow the Rajya Sabha to function,” said a senior minister in the government who did not want to be named.

The minister said that foreign minister Sushma Swaraj will give a suo moto statement in both houses of Parliament on her recent visit to Pakistan.

The government, according to senior NDA leaders, has also agreed to hold a discussion on the issue of price rise of foodgrains and essential commodities in the coming week, based on a demand by the opposition, hoping to win its support.

The ongoing winter session of Parliament began on a positive note with Prime Minister Narendra Modi inviting Congress president Sonia Gandhi and former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to meet on 1 December for talks on various issues related to the session, including the GST bill. However, developments in the National Herald case involving Congress party leaders led to several disruptions last week in both the houses of Parliament.

Congress president Sonia Gandhi held a brief meeting with senior party leaders at her residence late Sunday evening.

“The meeting was called to discuss a number of issues, and GST and Parliament strategy were a part of it. These are internal party matters and we will not go into the details right now,” a senior party leader said, requesting anonymity.

“With the kind of statements that are being made by the BJP about our stance on GST, it is difficult right now to discuss the issue with them. Also, as long as there is no concrete proposal from the government for a discussion, it is unlikely to happen,” a senior Rajya Sabha member from the party said, requesting anonymity.

Political analysts say the chances of the GST bill being voted through in this session are bleak. “There is an obvious delay in passing the GST as the Congress party has got a stick with which it is going to beat the BJP. The National Herald case is not just a legal battle now, it’s seen by the Congress party as an attack on the Gandhi family. What is most unfortunate is that the session began with a sort of bonhomie of chai par charcha, between Modi and Congress leaders which seemed like a dialogue between statesmen, of having a mature political class. But, the moment National Herald case came in, the Congress party turned vitriolic in its attack against the BJP, ruling out any constructive business at least in this session,” said Manisha Priyam, a New Delhi-based political analyst.

“The Congress party continues to obstruct the House and block legislation like the GST because it knows that it does not stand to lose anything on the issue,” Priyam said, adding that the party runs the risk of losing out on corporate donations over its stand on blocking the passage of GST
Winter session: NDA in last ditch reforms push - Livemint
 
Finance Minister Arun Jaitley on Monday put on record what most already suspect -- the winter session of Parliament, just like the preceding monsoon session, is threatened with a washout and unlikely to pass the goods and services tax (GST) Bill.

Both Jaitley and Parliamentary Affairs Minister M Venkaiah Naidu criticised the Congress for "inventing some excuse or another" to disrupt the Rajya Sabha. On Monday, Congress members disrupted the Upper House and staged a walkout from the Lok Sabha to protest alleged atrocities on Dalit youths in Punjab under the Shiromani Akali Dal-Bharatiya Janata Party government and the non-inclusion of Chief Minister Oomen Chandy to an event in Kerala where the PM was the chief guest.

But Naidu said he was still hopeful that public opinion would prevail and house would run. "If this is what it will take to ensure the House functions, I, as the Parliamentary Affairs Minister, can even go to (Congress vice-president) Rahul Gandhi's house, along with my finance minister (Jaitley). Rahulji isn't our enemy," Naidu said.

Naidu and Jaitley met Congress leaders Ghulam Nabi Azad, Anand Sharma and Jyotiraditya Scindia over lunch to discuss the Congress support to theGST Bill. This was supposed to be the follow up meeting after Prime Minister Narendra Modi had met Congress President Sonia Gandhi and former prime minister Manmohan Singh at his official residence at 7, Race Course Road on the eve of the winter session on November 25.

The government ministers had also invited Congress leader in the Lok Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge, but he was away in Karnataka. The two sides are likely to have another meeting when Kharge returns in a day or two. Government sources said the ministers apprised the Congress leaders about their position to the three Congress demands on the current draft of the GST Constitution amendment Bill, while the Congress leadership said it would put forth its position in the next meeting.

Government sources also said how senior ministers, particularly Jaitley and Naidu, have met several Congress leaders over the GST issue over the last month. Some in the government are still hopeful that the Congress might support the Bill after Saturday, December 19, the next date of hearing in the National Herald case when Sonia and Rahul Gandhi have to appear in the court.

A senior minister said the session will be left with three days before it concludes on December 23, and it can sit until late, if the Congress and other parties agree, to ensure the passage of the GST Bill.

In his latest blogpost, Jaitley reminded the Congress of the words of first PM Jawaharlal Nehru on the last day of the first Lok Sabha on March 28, 1957. Nehru in his address had reminded MPs of the huge responsibility bestowed on them to decide the destiny of millions of their fellow-countrymen and being involved in the processes of making history.

Jaitley said, "Those who claim the legacy (of Nehru) must ask themselves the question: What kind of history are they making?" He said the reason for the washout of the winter session "keep changing by the hour". He said the nation was waiting for Parliament to legislate and approve a historic constitution amendment enabling the GST. "All this is being indefinitely delayed. The question we need to ask ourselves is: Are we being fair to ourselves and this country?"
Jatiley fears winter session washout | Business Standard News
 
NO..simple
Chinese growth has fallen and is not as strong as it used to be its high time we take up the opportunity and capitalize by introducing reforms. But I wonder why congress including Dr. Manmohan Singh are not taking any stand to support the bill.
 
I hope modi go all out & put whole Gandhi family & chamcha brigade in jail if this bill is not passed

Chinese growth has fallen and is not as strong as it used to be its high time we take up the opportunity and capitalize by introducing reforms. But I wonder why congress including Dr. Manmohan Singh are not taking any stand to support the bill.
China has nothing to do with this just that this bill is a political suicide for a party which passes it ,around the world most parties hasn't won second election immediately after passing GST as inflation will sour to estemated 5 to 8% in Indian case for few years, Malaysia implemented GST this year & inflation rised by 2.5% , congress is intentionally delaying this so that in 2019 they have something useful to target BJP with
 
China has nothing to do with this just that this bill is a political suicide for a party which passes it ,around the world most parties hasn't won second election immediately after passing GST as inflation will sour to estemated 5 to 8% in Indian case for few years, Malaysia implemented GST this year & inflation rised by 2.5% , congress is intentionally delaying this so that in 2019 they have something useful to target BJP with
China's growth is under 7% right now but that was bound to happen as they effectively materialized their growth potential in the past 30 years but even a 6.7 or 6.6% growth is very moderate for an economy like China. Whereas a double digit growth is still a possibility and would be a huge factor in India's economic dream and reforms like these will only encourage investment and will increase the ease of doing business in India by improving the tax structure.
GST is a reform over CST it will help the business with problems faced during realizing the tax credit and the double taxation I don't know how you are relating it to increase in inflation.
 
China's growth is under 7% right now but that was bound to happen as they effectively materialized their growth potential in the past 30 years but even a 6.7 or 6.6% growth is very moderate for an economy like China. Whereas a double digit growth is still a possibility and would be a huge factor in India's economic dream and reforms like these will only encourage investment and will increase the ease of doing business in India by improving the tax structure.
GST is a reform over CST it will help the business with problems faced during realizing the tax credit and the double taxation I don't know how you are relating it to increase in inflation.
Moody has already warned government on passing GST as soon as possible due to things happening in east specially south east with trade packs etc, hope it will be passed in this session
 
Can they call a joint session immediately after the Winter Session and just pass the damn thing?

GST needs to be passed this fiscal.
 
And what about land acquisition bill ?
They are not even talking about t anymore.
 
Chinese growth has fallen and is not as strong as it used to be its high time we take up the opportunity and capitalize by introducing reforms. But I wonder why congress including Dr. Manmohan Singh are not taking any stand to support the bill.
Politics dude...since when national interest is above politics...where have you been living??

Can they call a joint session immediately after the Winter Session and just pass the damn thing?

GST needs to be passed this fiscal.
GST needs constitutional amendment and can't be passed in joint session...LAB could have been....
 
Politics dude...since when national interest is above politics...where have you been living??
Well yes its all politics. GST concept was introduced by congress but the BJP that time disrupted the parliament and didn't allowed it to work the same way congress is doing it right now.
 
Well yes its all politics. GST concept was introduced by congress but the BJP that time disrupted the parliament and didn't allowed it to work the same way congress is doing it right now.
There is slight difference...BJP was disrupting parliament because of real issues...unlike congress which is working overtime to concatenate issues...nevertheless politics over national interests is what all the political parties prefer...
 

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom