30 injured in clash between police, locals in Panchagarh

[El Sidd]

That's correct, we have our oldest Sangam literature from the region

So is it foreign in Madras or in Simla?

 

[Cheepek]

So is it foreign in Madras or in Simla?

Neither foreign in Madras nor in Simla

 

[Areesh]

Why do you or I have to oppose them by lynching or murdering? Why do not you Sunnis leave them in their way of life and let Allah decide whether you or they are better Muslims?

Why not wait until the Day of Judgement?

Why judge others? Who authorized this power to Sunni Muslims? If you have an authorization letter please send us a photocopy. If not, just shut up.

It isn't about good or bad Muslim

These people are not Muslims. Period

Anyone who believes in prophethood in any form after Prophet Muhammad is a not a Muslim

BD government should listen to majority of its nation and should stop giving permits to these nonsense jalsas by such cults

 

[El Sidd]

Neither foreign in Madras nor in Simla

So now distance of a thousand mile don't hold? Strange

 

[Areesh]

View attachment 918897

Seedha nikal seedha

 

[Cheepek]

So now distance of a thousand mile don't hold? Strange

What's stranger is how you deduce in your head I used "foreign" as euphamism for "thousands of miles away", when I clearly stated "foreign religion created thousands of miles away"

 

[El Sidd]

What's stranger is how you deduce in your head I used "foreign" as euphamism for "thousands of miles away", when I clearly stated "foreign religion created thousands of miles away"

What strange is that you superimpose this principle on what you consider as geographical India. It's the misplaced revanchism that is just not strange but hypocritical.

 

[Cheepek]

What strange is that you superimpose this principle on what you consider as geographical India. It's the misplaced revanchism that is just not strange but hypocritical.

That's because we were talking about India, or the geographical entity that India is. Nothing to do with your delusions what India is!
Anything that's not native is foreign, in your head you may believe Arabs and Pakistanis share the same geography and hence Islam is native to Pakistan, but... things don't work that way.
Hope you are done clutching at straws.

 

[El Sidd]

That's because we were talking about India, or the geographical entity that India is. Nothing to do with your delusions what India is!
Anything that's not native is foreign, in your head you may believe Arabs and Pakistanis share the same geography and hence Islam is native to Pakistan, but... things don't work that way.
Hope you are done clutching at straws.

Why don't you elaborate on that a little? It seems you want to put geographical boundaries on theological principles.

 

[bluesky]

These people are not Muslims. Period

How about the Shias? Are they not also Muslims? Ahmadiyas may also be regarded as Muslims similarly.

Is it someone else's problem to decide who is Muslim and who is not?

Only Muslims do this way.

 

[Black_cats]

How about the Shias? Are they not also Muslims? Ahmadiyas may also be regarded as Muslims similarly.

Is it someone else's problem to decide who is Muslim and who is not?

Only Muslims do this way.

Who told you Shias are not Muslim? Do they believe there is another prophet after prophet Muhammad who is both the reborn of Jesus Christ and Mahadi? Do they also believe Jesus Christ came to Punjab and died there?

 

[bluesky]

Who told you Shias are not Muslim? Do they believe there is another prophet after prophet Muhammad who is both the reborn of Jesus Christ and Mahadi? Do they also believe Jesus Christ came to Punjab and died there?

Learn before attacking others for making a point. Have you ever met one Irani Shia person and talked about Shiaism? I have met many of them and all even deny Muhammed as the last Prophet but accept Ali as their Imam and the last Prophet.

Grow up and learn from what I write below. By the way, do you really know that the real Quran written chronologically by Hazrat Ali is stored now in a museum in Turkey and is not open for anybody to read? Hazrat Ali was the full-time Sahaba of Prophet Muhammed, perhaps an ignorant guy as you may not even know this fact.

It was not accepted by the Committee formed at the time of Hazrat Abu Bakr and later by Hazrat Uthman. The version of the Quran we read was collected from the scatters after the death of the Prophet.

Abu Bakr's Quran team collected the verses and compiled them into their first form with many verses rejected. This first form is no more available. The version we read now was compiled by a team at the time of Hazrat Uthman.

But, the Shia people follow the old/ real Quran compiled by their Imam Ali though the real one is no more available.

My initial question is why so much fuss over religion?

 

[Pakistani E]

How are you going to police the private lives of Ahmadis? I "pose" as a Muslim even inside my house in Pakistan by reading Qur'an and praying namaz. How are you going to police that lol? Same as with this Jalsa. This is an internal Ahmadi event, if you get triggered by Ahmadis "posing" as Muslims in their private settings, why do you go out of your way to go there and get offended?

You don't consider Ahmadis as Muslims, that's fine. Ahmadis are just practising their religion, mind your own damn business.

 

[Areesh]

How about the Shias? Are they not also Muslims? Ahmadiyas may also be regarded as Muslims similarly.

Is it someone else's problem to decide who is Muslim and who is not?

Only Muslims do this way.

Let me make it simple for you

Anyone who doesn't believe in finality of prophethood is not muslim

That's it. We are not forcing anyone to change their religion but we would also not accept any nonmuslim as muslim

 

[bluesky]

Let me make it simple for you

Anyone who doesn't believe in finality of prophethood is not muslim

That's it. We are not forcing anyone to change their religion but we would also not accept any nonmuslim as muslim

If the Shias are regarded as Muslims, the Ahmadiyas should also be regarded as Muslims whatever may the latter's political clout.

And in any way, no one has the right to hurt or kill anyone because he is an Ahmadiya. The killers must be tried in a Court of Justice and the vandalized properties must be compensated.

Why does a Sunni Muslim think it is a problem if someone is Shia or Ahmadiya?