25 Congress Lawmakers Suspended From Lok Sabha

[Star Wars]

so for how long are they suspended

5 days

 

[GURU DUTT]

So people ask questions around Vasundhara Raje, Vyapam and Sushma's illegal dealings, so the government just suspends them enmasse....I hope he comnitues to show that he is politically a lame duck PM. modi will be out in 5 years (and that's 5 years too long).

f*cked up the economy, f*cked up the budget- in one state he loses a stupid election and in return wastes all his time taking 'revenge', now this.

25 Congress Lawmakers Suspended From Lok Sabha, Sonia Gandhi Says 'Black Day for Democracy'

in 5 years modi will be out, that much is for sure. About time this clown stopped this nautanki.

 

[ranjeet]

So people ask questions around Vasundhara Raje, Vyapam and Sushma's illegal dealings, so the government just suspends them enmasse....I hope he comnitues to show that he is politically a lame duck PM. modi will be out in 5 years (and that's 5 years too long).

f*cked up the economy, f*cked up the budget- in one state he loses a stupid election and in return wastes all his time taking 'revenge', now this.

25 Congress Lawmakers Suspended From Lok Sabha, Sonia Gandhi Says 'Black Day for Democracy'

Just 25? why they spared the rest of 19 MPs?

 

[GURU DUTT]

Just 25? why they spared the rest of 19 MPs?

taki hum per ilzaam na aaye

 

[Josef K]

You think so? Same logic was not used when BJP was stalling parliament.

Says more about how clueless and useless the Congress party and it's speaker where. Well, after all they were clueless about governance too. No wonder they were scared of resorting to serious actions

And Vyapam is the worst scam India has seen till date. Shows quite clearly that hardcore BJP supporters are basically morons.

MP elected Shivraj Singh even with the Vyapam scam storm blowing. Says a lot about how much Congress and Doggy Singh screwed up MP, that the people would keep voting BJP even with the Vyapam scam

 

[Guynextdoor2]

Just 25? why they spared the rest of 19 MPs?

BJP ka atyachaar. Agar Congress ka land bill hi pass karwana tha to legislators ko kyun bahar kiya????!!!


Breaking News ! Government backs down, may revert to Congress's 2013 land bill

@Bang Galore

Says more about how clueless and useless the Congress party and it's speaker where. Well, after all they were clueless about governance too. No wonder they were scared of resorting to serious actions



MP elected Shivraj Singh even with the Vyapam scam storm blowing. Says a lot about how much Congress and Doggy Singh screwed up MP, that the people would keep voting BJP even with the Vyapam scam

 

[ranjeet]

BJP ka atyachaar. Agar Congress ka land bill hi pass karwana tha to legislators ko kyun bahar kiya????!!!


Breaking News ! Government backs down, may revert to Congress's 2013 land bill

@Bang Galore

You are mixing issues but you have a right to cry foul

 

[Guynextdoor2]

You are mixing issues but you have a right to cry foul

I'm not mixing issues, if they were going to adopt the congress version anyway, then why did they boot out the legislators? Vyapam has to be discussed, you can't avoid it.

 

[Josef K]

I'm not mixing issues, if they were going to adopt the congress version anyway, then why did they boot out the legislators? Vyapam has to be discussed, you can't avoid it.

It was discussed and people of MP said "screw you" to Congress.

 

[Bang Galore]

You think so? Same logic was not used when BJP was stalling parliament. And Vyapam is the worst scam India has seen till date. Shows quite clearly that hardcore BJP supporters are basically morons.

@Bang Galore your take?

I actually pointed out that this is what would happen (payback by Congress) when the BJP was being obstructionist in the previous parliament. The problem for the Congress is that they didn't heed Shashi Tharoor's warnings - their numbers at 44 are so small as to allow for such a situation which BJP's numbers in the previous parliament protected them from.

Government Backs Down on Major Amendments to 2013 Land Bill: Sources

I have repeatedly made the argument that the government was nuts to go down this path. Not because the UPA bill was good but that the Congress & the rest of the opposition would completely stall this. So much expending of political capital with zero return. Arun Shourie had the brains (he was the one who suggested that Modi should not touch it & get the states to do the work since land was anyways a state subject), for all of his lawyer skills, Jaitley is quite clearly not able to help. Modi went with the wrong Arun.

As for the point you made, while the call was nominally that of the Speaker's, you make a valid point that bad blood now is guaranteed. Unless the government has completely given up on the Congress & is prepared to go through the rest of the tern without the Congress's help, it makes very little sense. The government seems completely at sea and does not inspire the same confidence as it did even 6 months back. The government has the fiscal situation under control & is doing okay on the foreign front (minus Pakistan)but are pretty much pissing into the wind everywhere else.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Should have been done before. In fact I am for making this a permanent and House independent decision. Any misbehaving MP should be eliminated and fined/LOP-ed.

Congrats- your PM is so incompetent that he alienates the opposition and fails at the legal measures too. USELESS CLOWN. if he knew he'd have to withdraw, why did he throw out the legislators then?

Congressi, who is thy PM?

 

[Star Wars]

Congressi, who is thy PM?

Mistress Sonia Gandhi

 

[Guynextdoor2]

I actually pointed out that this is what would happen (payback by Congress) when the BJP was being obstructionist in the previous parliament. The problem for the Congress is that they didn't heed Shashi Tharoor's warnings - their numbers at 44 are so small as to allow for such a situation which BJP's numbers in the previous parliament protected them from.



I have repeatedly made the argument that the government was nuts to go down this path. Not because the UPA bill was good but that the Congress & the rest of the opposition would completely stall this. So much expending of political capital with zero return. Arun Shourie had the brains (he was the one who suggested that Modi should not touch it & get the states to do the work since land was anyways a state subject), for all of his lawyer skills, Jaitley is quite clearly not able to help. Modi went with the wrong Arun.

As for the point you made, while the call was nominally that of the Speaker's, you make a valid point that bad blood now is guaranteed. Unless the government has completely given up on the Congress & is prepared to go through the rest of the tern without the Congress's help, it makes very little sense. The government seems completely at sea and does not inspire the same confidence as it did even 6 months back. The government has the fiscal situation under control but are pretty much pissing into the wind everywhere else.

They're thick skinned man, I think they'll brush off the suspension. I actually think the land bill is an indication of Modi's political incompetence, he knew even when he became PM that with the congress covering RS in a big way it'll be difficult to get things through. Instead of doing what COngress' Pranab Mukherjee did (open lines with BJP), Modi threatened and bullied them, got PM in front of courts, said I'll screw you f*ck you etc. So an already tense situation went out of control. Anyway I think the discussion should continue in the following thread.

In Huge Defeat, Government Will Remove All Changes to Land Bill

 

[GURU DUTT]

Says more about how clueless and useless the Congress party and it's speaker where. Well, after all they were clueless about governance too. No wonder they were scared of resorting to serious actions



MP elected Shivraj Singh even with the Vyapam scam storm blowing. Says a lot about how much Congress and Doggy Singh screwed up MP, that the people would keep voting BJP even with the Vyapam scam

problem with congress is that it lost its connect with the masses deu to thier ecsessive corruption and centralization where making new "leaders" was discouraged and making "courties" was the order and it began after emergency when one after another proper mass leaders of congress were send packing and a new breed of ghandi family loyalists were promoted and they were also wiped owt once they started there quest for power (madhav rao scindia, rajesh pilot are just few exampels ) they survived so long as oppostion was divided and indians were missing a good leader

but now they have leaders like "rahul ghandi" need i say more

 

[Guynextdoor2]

Should have been done before. In fact I am for making this a permanent and House independent decision. Any misbehaving MP should be eliminated and fined/LOP-ed.


Congressi, who is thy PM?

technically modi is my PM but I'd like disown him if I could, he's a moron. Discussion to continue in following thread.

In Huge Defeat, Government Will Remove All Changes to Land Bill

Mistress Sonia Gandhi

problem with congress is that it lost its connect with the masses deu to thier ecsessive corruption and centralization where making new "leaders" was discouraged and making "courties" was the order and it began after emergency when one after another proper mass leaders of congress were send packing and a new breed of ghandi family loyalists were promoted and they were also wiped owt once they started there quest for power (madhav rao scindia, rajesh pilot are just few exampels ) they survived so long as oppostion was divided and indians were missing a good leader

but now they have leaders like "rahul ghandi" need i say more

In Huge Defeat, Government Will Remove All Changes to Land Bill