16-year-old girl set on fire as 'punishment' by Abbottabad jirga

[A.P. Richelieu]

still we need to do lot of changes in society first of all abolish any jirga, panchayat and made it illegal.For this incident hang all the culprits in public view and in the same village + let the vultures to do the rest job ...don't burry them or honour to have funeral.
Islam allow us to kill animals and even humen under certain cicumstances and conditions but Islam forbade us to kill any body by burning because this punishment is only given by Allah and for those who openly commited adultry and idol worshiping despite they are called for Islam in their life time.
Not only this Jirga commited a crime but also falls under religious Blasphemy.

I think the OP says the girl was killed, and then the body was burned.

 

[Zibago]

There are no biradris in hazara. these casts have no feudalism in KpK. You have no idea of hazara. The people there are more liberal as compared to other parts of the province

Oh bibi my nani amma is from Haripur (Abbasi) there is biradrism in Hazara in Abbotabad people will vote for a candidate just cuz he is Abbasi the biradrism these castes dont have fuedalism but there is biradrism in Hazara others from Hazara can confirm @User

 

[aamirzs]

My personal feeling is that local jirga should be banned (period)!
Time after time they take wrong discussions further more against teaching of Islam.
This is not the end after some time something similar will happen again .. sadly.

 

[django]

Don't know what to say there is no elaj for jaahils they should be hanged

Your right.

 

[Zahoor Raja-Jani]

I think the OP says the girl was killed, and then the body was burned.

offense will not become less

 

[Spring Onion]

Oh bibi my nani amma is from Haripur (Abbasi) there is biradrism in Hazara in Abbotabad people will vote for a candidate just cuz he is Abbasi the biradrism these castes dont have fuedalism but there is biradrism in Hazara others from Hazara can confirm @User

People there vote mostly for Nawaz League irrespective of biradri which BTW is not that strong there

 

[Zibago]

People there vote mostly for Nawaz League irrespective of biradri which BTW is not that strong there

No way many Abbasis will vote for another Abbasi just cuz they are Abbasis this is biradrism

 

[Spring Onion]

No way many Abbasis will vote for another Abbasi just cuz they are Abbasis this is biradrism

Leave this political debate for some other thread concentrate on the current topic.

 

[باپ]

I bet all the 15 attested men will be free once media spotlight turns away.
These cases rarely see any convictions as no witnesses come forward.​

 

[Darth Vader]

Honestly is there no humanity left , don't they fear God
How he feels when you torture his creation
These aholes need to be punished properly so no one else does this again hope courts do justice on this one

 

[Kabira]

There are no biradris in hazara. these casts have no feudalism in KpK. You have no idea of hazara. The people there are more liberal as compared to other parts of the province

Seem like you don't understand difference between biradeism and feudalism. I know people from Hazara division and biraderi thing is part of their culture.

 

[waz]

So these savages have been arrested, let's see what happens. The entire "jigra" should be hung....

 

[EasyNow]

To be honest, these panchayat are quite useful for dealing with domestic matters and for family mediation, however they seem to be grossly overstepping their mark nowadays. Punishment is a matter for the authorities and every panchayat and jirga needs to be reminded of this.

 

[DesiGuy1403]

If any person commits any act of crime either under the influence of under the pretext of that person's religion, it is up to the representatives of that religion to look inward for correction.

Blindly closing ones eyes and shouting our religion does not permit this, DOES NOT address the issue.

Note: This post is targeting all religions and bigots are present in all religions.

There can never be any religious excuse for any crime. And worst crimes are committed on woman by all religions under the garb or religion.

 

[I.R.A]

Seriously i have never heard of a jirga in abbotabad.I only heard about the jirgas in the tribal areas or in the backward interior sindh .Abbotabad is quite a modern city with lot of education centres and a military setup.

This incident did not take place in Abbottabad city. Its one of the surrounding villages where this happened.

Tribal Culture at its best ... Tribal culture is like a Cancer

This has nothing to do with Tribals or Tribal culture. Get your facts straight. Without knowing about the area and its people your comment seems like simply out of hate for Tribals.

jaahil pahktuns, what'd you expect?

These people are not Pashtuns. If you have any hate against Pashtuns at least try showing it in some appropriate place, don't blame them for something which they did not commit.

People there vote mostly for Nawaz League irrespective of biradri which BTW is not that strong there

PTI won from there............................. "Sardar Mehtab Ahemd Khan Abbasi" lost in the last elections held there. Just see his name and try to understand why he adopted such a name, there is a reason for that and @Zibago is right biradri does play a role during elections and fights, it is now that recently youth has started questioning it because they thought Imran Khan was some leader who could bring change (by the way they should have realised by now that he is another idiot).