Complete Ban or limited viewing of the forum for all indian users

[Jungibaaz]

Whilst you have the experience of being a mod, we as members also have eyes and see certain patterns.

All I am suggesting that if certain Indian members stop trolling, most Pakistani members won't have a reason to react. There will be less negativity and more time for actual discussion.

I can swear that since I have been participating in forums I have only seen immense trolling and hate from one side. This experience goes back as far as the days of pakistanidefenceforum.com It has always been the same story. The same old.

Mods are only a few and can't be everywhere. We have mitigating systems to make up for our scarcity as individuals too. If you report the posts you see an issue with, given enough time for mods to respond, they will be dealt with. If they are clearly violating forum rules, their posts will be removed and user warned/banned.

 

[Iltutmish]

I have also started a topic regarding Indian trolling: https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/how-to-handle-indian-trolls-online.668455/

But don’t ban them. PDF is fun due to the fact that it is NOT a Pakistani echo chamber. Different views even from the other side (Indians) are allowed, a concept totally alien to most Indian platforms!

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

PDF has no major issue with Indian trolls as far as I can see. Out of the thousands of Indian origin posts per day, far fewer violate forum rules.

Brother, it is a growing problem and needs to be dealt with harshly. Dubious did much good on this forum, I wish a mod could take up the reins.

They have multiplied since then and gotten emboldened.

They are derailing all topics.

 

[SQ8]

The bhakt trolls nearly destroyed the forum because we had a policy of letting anyone from India join up.

I would prefer an approval process for Indian IPs and flags for multiple IDs and have them restricted to the Indian section.

 

[Dalit]

Is it just me or is it really bizarre that this @Dalit guy is complaining about trolling and hate posts??? I mean come one!!!

And lets be honest. If Indians were not allowed here, pakistanis would just be fighting and trolling each others. You should be happy with the indian members as they serve as collective punching bag that unites pakistanis

Stop daydreaming. Pakistanis have disagreements and at times quite fierce. Is that an exception as you are trying to make us believe? No, absolutely not.

 

[Jungibaaz]

Brother, it is a growing problem and needs to be dealt with harshly. Dubious did much good on this forum, I wish a mod could take up the reins.

They have multiplied since then and gotten emboldened.

They are derailing all topics.

No doubt Dubious is a hard worker and dedicated, I saw it myself and vouch for it. Same goes for many other mods. It takes a lot time to go through member's requests, reports and threads. I agree that mods are scarce, that's always been the case.

All I can suggest is that members keep reporting diligently, and not responding/indulging trolls where you see them. This is the way to make the forum better. I personally don't agree at all with suggestion of banning Indian users on here, it's just not proportionate or productive.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

indian forums have banned all Pakistanis. We should do the same too. indians lower the quality of PDF. It seems like PDF is becoming rss Defence Forum.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

No doubt Dubious is a hard worker and dedicated, I saw it myself and vouch for it. Same goes for many other mods. It takes a lot time to go through member's requests, reports and threads. I agree that mods are scarce, that's always been the case.

All I can suggest is that members keep reporting diligently, and not responding/indulging trolls where you see them. This is the way to make the forum better. I personally don't agree at all with suggestion of banning Indian users on here, it's just not proportionate or productive.

Yes, we need more Mods. In sha Allah we will get a hold on this situation.

Just today one Iranian member insulted Pakistani women and it upset me. Ofcourse Indians and some diaspora Pakistanis were jumping in the background. Actually one Pakistani instigated it.

Indians are not the only problem here.

 

[Morpheus]

@WebMaster I propose a trial run. Limit all indian users to only posting threads and comments to the indian defense section, and member section, for 3 weeks. After 3 weeks, we ask all the stakeholders their experience. This will not be limited to Pakistani members only. Arab members, Iranian, Chinese, Bangladeshi, etc. We will get a complete pic from different nationalities about indian users here.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Yes, we need more Mods. In sha Allah we will get a hold on this situation.

Just today one Iranian member insulted Pakistani women and it upset me. Ofcourse Indians and some diaspora Pakistanis were jumping in the background. Actually one Pakistani instigated it.

Indians are not the only problem here.

You definitely need to be made a MOD. You are articulate, honest and argue against anti Pakistani propaganda really well.

@WebMaster I propose a trial run. Limit all indian users to only posting threads and comments to the indian defense section, and member section, for 3 weeks. After 3 weeks, we ask all the stakeholders their experience. This will not be limited to Pakistani members only. Arab members, Iranian, Chinese, Bangladeshi, etc. We will get a complete pic from different nationalities about indian users here.

I second that.

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

You definitely need to be made a MOD. You are articulate, honest and argue against anti Pakistani propaganda really well.






I second that.

Thanks for the vote of confidence dear brother.

I already declined due to my predisposition to rip Indians to pieces (I can never be impartial to them) and demands of my medical practice and home life.

Can we clone several Dubious, it will solve all problems? Even if Padamchen will cry.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Thanks for the vote of confidence dear brother.

I already declined due to my predisposition to rip Indians to pieces (I can never be impartial to them) and demands of my medical practice and home life.

Can we clone several Dubious, it will solve all problems? Even if Padamchen will cry.

Good luck with your endeavour bro!

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Good luck with your endeavour bro!

Jazak Allahu khairan brother.

 

[Chhatrapati]

One of those days, someone just snaps opens a thread. If you're mod, you'd already ban Indian en masse. Call it purge. Drama

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

We need to limit only the indian posters to the indian section. Any anti Pakistan remark should result in at least a 3 month ban.