What's new

The Decline Of Bengali Hindus

Kandari-Hushiyaar

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Nov 14, 2016
Messages
582
Reaction score
0
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
Written By : Aryadip Mridha

Kolkatan Hindu Bengali are fastest declining community in entire India. Yaah you read that Right . And the West Bengali’s as a whole are as well declining in an alarming manner.

Thanks to Over liberalism, Over secularism, Over cowardice, Lack of self esteem . We never realised that Hindi has already killed 20 percent of Bangla. If you think I am wrong. Read on.

Kolkata has currently only 58 percent Hindu Bengalis. Only 58 percent !!!

( By Hindu Bengali I mean our Mahalaya - giving chills of arival of Durga puja , dhunochi naach, pithe puli, kite flying on saraswati and Viswakarma puja. Kali puja, Sakha pola culture that are our identity !)

We never realized that we are directly fed upon Hindi and Hindi is invading us . Linguistic cultural invasion is what is going on( Via Bollywood) . The invasion of the mindset of our women folks is going on all in the name of “Bengali’s are most liberal “

I am in Kolkata and so many of the shopkeepers have came from Jharkhand and Bihar and speak in Hindi. They never make an attempt to learn Bangla. But we are forced to talk in Hindi. Let them go to southern states and then we hear from them that “ Tamil’s are shallow”. No, they are not!! They value their culture and their language and have a self -respect .

One of My Friend's 3 sisters from extended family married non- Bengali's and now do not want to go the village’s of their hubby’s but rather stay in Kolkata. they found the guy dashing and now do not want to speak in Bojpuri!! The culture of Bengali’s are asthetically different. I have interacted with Assam , AP, Gujrat, Punjab and so many Bengali girl’s have inter marrige, making as a begger genetically.

Now, when the Bengali girl marries this replaces with Karwa cauth, jitia, chattapuja !!!

The Bengali guy is not finding a girl to marry. We never did female infanticide like the Haryanvis, Biharis, Punjabis, Rajasthanis etc. still in 2017 report the male female ratio is WORST in Bengal.

What went wrong ? Well , due to two very simple reason we overlooked since 50 years.Firstly,We were over liberal and allowed our daughter’s to study and gave freedom. They chose who ever they wanted as life partner. Afterall ,constitution has given them rights!! And due to decades of inter-community marriages we are now the most threatenedwe are now the most threatened community.

We never realized that we are directly fed upon Hindi and Hindi is invading us . Linguistic cultural invasion is what is going on( Via Bollywood) . The invasion of the mindset of our women folks is going on all in the name of “Bengali’s are most liberal “

I am in Kolkata and so many of the shopkeepers have shaont wrong ? Weo du marriageable age being increased to 26 - 30 years !!

If the statistics are to be pondered upon , 70 years down the line we might become extinct or would be on the verge of extinction.

Was that the reason our forefather’s sacrificed for the union of India??

I never see any comment’s that Bengali’s had a immense contribution in freedom struggle where so many where literally hanged or tortured to death. But what we hear is “Bong girl’s are hot” !! As,though , we are the supplier’s of women to gratify the lust of other community in India. They are quite clever in preserving their culture at the cost of our’s and they actually did just the right . YASH Jain in his comment to pointed that the Bengali girl’s are hot. As though , the jain marwari girl’s aren’t good looking?? I had taken a screenshot and informed him. Subsequently, he edited his comment. This speaks volumes about the mindset.

Look at the number of Bengali actress who have married non Bengali!

Number of Bengali males marrying non -Bengali girls - We need a microscope!!

Number of Bengali females marrying non Bengali guys- No. of hairs on your head!!

If you have watched the movie “Vicky Donor” , you might have noted how the movie mocks at the Bengali community . They tell like “ Bengali is known by the fish”. I have been to Bihar in childhood and there they look on us as “Bangalia”, “Bangali boka”, Bongali and wot not !! Kindly also note,that Bengali's have met with violence and riots. There have been jobs in Kolkata where the marwari firms clearly mentions in Indeed that non-Bengali's are preferred.

How I feel about non-bengali?

I am NOT pleased with the migration of non Bengali peoples in Kolkata. We are a land starved state and some of our forefather’s left Bangladesh for West Bengal. Our state’s were created on the basis of linguistic majority. But migration of non Bengali's to WB in particular Kolkata is changing all that, all in the name of unity of India.

Kolkata posh areas viz., Salt lake, Bangur , Ballygunge, Bawanipore is hijacked my marwari’s and from North India and migration from Orissa and jharkhand and Bihar has drastically changed the demography and culture.

If we all are one, why not remove the territorial barrier? Why not create just a single civil service, rather than state civil service exams? Why not make English the national language rather than Hindi the official language? After all we study in English and most jobs that are created are in English nowadays.

I feel Bangladesh did a good job in 1971, as now it is 16 million and have progressed a lot,because they are within their terrotiay. There women folk’s cannot be exported to another community. Additionally, they have already converted 35 percent of hindu’s into their faternity, by brainwashing, or forced convertions, love jihad. I have personally discussed with Hindu Bengali’s residing in a village of Bangldesh where the guy admitted that only 5 Hindu family’s remain,rest got converted. The bangladeshi’s are attracting foreign investment now .

Bengal is a Kolkata centric. Bengal minus Kolkata is nothing. Bangladesh has huge territory and number of Bangladeshis abroad are far in number than Indian Bengali’s.

Seems we have lost our battle due to foolishness of Over liberalism, Over secularism, Over Cowardice, blindly following the text books without a originality of ideas, giving of too much liberty to women folks has what is what we are now . I accept that we are not that handsome due to genetic trait’s but so are many of North eastern states. But I never hear there women folks betraying in such a big number.

My grandfather laid his 7 yrs in British prison due to freedom struggle. I have seized to proudly claim myself a Indian ,when I see my Bengali community in such a miserable state. I am a Bengali, and I DO NOT wish any more of the infiltration all in the name of Bhaichara. We have a Bengali culture and help us retain it. The nostalgic Kolkata is no more due to massive infiltration.

 
Inter state migration and inter cultural marriages are good things for national integrity of any multi cultural/ethnic country.
 
Yeah then people complain about Hindu population decrease in Bangladesh. But nobody can convince them about the real scenario. How come they decrease in West Bengal as well. They lack self esteem as the writer mentioned. But yeah keep on complaining the douche bag BD. If Hindus didnt migrate from this side, then Bengali Hindus would be minuscule in India now. While Bangladeshis migrate to all over world, Bengali Hindus migrate to all over India.

I feel leaving Kolkata/WB during partition was a mistake. East Bengal became a chithole because all main urban/industrial areas remained in WB. Still in continuation WB is culturally strong. For nation building both the community could greatly contribute. And their self rights could be guaranteed separately. If communities wanted greater cooperation could happen with India as well. But they lost respect as they decided to join India. Bengali Hindus enjoy great freedom and incentives right now in BD. Compared to WB Muslims. I mean if white collar jobs are compared. May be because Muslims dont easily assimilate with society that much and Hindus are easily manageable. They will always have place in BD. One Hindu guy was saying if have to die have to die in motherland (BD) not in chithole (India) after getting scammed there. Yes the loyalty and devotion for motherland is in Hindus as their culture revolves around this region, unlike Muslims which is in Arabia. But its actually hard from national perspective to think of Hindus as equal citizens in national sensitive areas. I cant imagine a Hindu PM/defence chief in BD, same we cant be seen in WB/India. Bangladesh as I see of now is of Muslims, everyone has right to stay here under laws. I myself is irreligious person and I feel threatened if Bengali Hindus get immense power (as happening now) they will make it a playground of UP/Bhikhari Hindi belt, like the blunder they made in WB.
 
Bengali Hindus sealed their own fate by going against Bangali nationalism by joining with India. Subcontinent should have been partitioned with with a multi religious Bengal on this side with Pakistan and India to the west. It would have ensured stability and all three countries would have been in an higher growth trajectory.

History can not be changed. Bengali Hindus need to struggle for their own independence if they want to survive.

But soul of Bengal is Bangladesh with all its people irrespective of religion. Indian Bengal is just an unimportant and ill fitting adjunct to the Indian federation.
 
I came across a Bengali Hindu man who was in his late 60's in a vehicle recovery shop recently, long story short he was so adamant in speaking Bengali. The whole time I spoke in a very polished Sylheti and he chose to reply in Indian English without fail.
 
Written By : Aryadip Mridha

Kolkatan Hindu Bengali are fastest declining community in entire India. Yaah you read that Right . And the West Bengali’s as a whole are as well declining in an alarming manner.

Thanks to Over liberalism, Over secularism, Over cowardice, Lack of self esteem . We never realised that Hindi has already killed 20 percent of Bangla. If you think I am wrong. Read on.

Kolkata has currently only 58 percent Hindu Bengalis. Only 58 percent !!!

( By Hindu Bengali I mean our Mahalaya - giving chills of arival of Durga puja , dhunochi naach, pithe puli, kite flying on saraswati and Viswakarma puja. Kali puja, Sakha pola culture that are our identity !)

We never realized that we are directly fed upon Hindi and Hindi is invading us . Linguistic cultural invasion is what is going on( Via Bollywood) . The invasion of the mindset of our women folks is going on all in the name of “Bengali’s are most liberal “

I am in Kolkata and so many of the shopkeepers have came from Jharkhand and Bihar and speak in Hindi. They never make an attempt to learn Bangla. But we are forced to talk in Hindi. Let them go to southern states and then we hear from them that “ Tamil’s are shallow”. No, they are not!! They value their culture and their language and have a self -respect .

One of My Friend's 3 sisters from extended family married non- Bengali's and now do not want to go the village’s of their hubby’s but rather stay in Kolkata. they found the guy dashing and now do not want to speak in Bojpuri!! The culture of Bengali’s are asthetically different. I have interacted with Assam , AP, Gujrat, Punjab and so many Bengali girl’s have inter marrige, making as a begger genetically.

Now, when the Bengali girl marries this replaces with Karwa cauth, jitia, chattapuja !!!

The Bengali guy is not finding a girl to marry. We never did female infanticide like the Haryanvis, Biharis, Punjabis, Rajasthanis etc. still in 2017 report the male female ratio is WORST in Bengal.

What went wrong ? Well , due to two very simple reason we overlooked since 50 years.Firstly,We were over liberal and allowed our daughter’s to study and gave freedom. They chose who ever they wanted as life partner. Afterall ,constitution has given them rights!! And due to decades of inter-community marriages we are now the most threatenedwe are now the most threatened community.

We never realized that we are directly fed upon Hindi and Hindi is invading us . Linguistic cultural invasion is what is going on( Via Bollywood) . The invasion of the mindset of our women folks is going on all in the name of “Bengali’s are most liberal “

I am in Kolkata and so many of the shopkeepers have shaont wrong ? Weo du marriageable age being increased to 26 - 30 years !!

If the statistics are to be pondered upon , 70 years down the line we might become extinct or would be on the verge of extinction.

Was that the reason our forefather’s sacrificed for the union of India??

I never see any comment’s that Bengali’s had a immense contribution in freedom struggle where so many where literally hanged or tortured to death. But what we hear is “Bong girl’s are hot” !! As,though , we are the supplier’s of women to gratify the lust of other community in India. They are quite clever in preserving their culture at the cost of our’s and they actually did just the right . YASH Jain in his comment to pointed that the Bengali girl’s are hot. As though , the jain marwari girl’s aren’t good looking?? I had taken a screenshot and informed him. Subsequently, he edited his comment. This speaks volumes about the mindset.

Look at the number of Bengali actress who have married non Bengali!

Number of Bengali males marrying non -Bengali girls - We need a microscope!!

Number of Bengali females marrying non Bengali guys- No. of hairs on your head!!

If you have watched the movie “Vicky Donor” , you might have noted how the movie mocks at the Bengali community . They tell like “ Bengali is known by the fish”. I have been to Bihar in childhood and there they look on us as “Bangalia”, “Bangali boka”, Bongali and wot not !! Kindly also note,that Bengali's have met with violence and riots. There have been jobs in Kolkata where the marwari firms clearly mentions in Indeed that non-Bengali's are preferred.

How I feel about non-bengali?

I am NOT pleased with the migration of non Bengali peoples in Kolkata. We are a land starved state and some of our forefather’s left Bangladesh for West Bengal. Our state’s were created on the basis of linguistic majority. But migration of non Bengali's to WB in particular Kolkata is changing all that, all in the name of unity of India.

Kolkata posh areas viz., Salt lake, Bangur , Ballygunge, Bawanipore is hijacked my marwari’s and from North India and migration from Orissa and jharkhand and Bihar has drastically changed the demography and culture.

If we all are one, why not remove the territorial barrier? Why not create just a single civil service, rather than state civil service exams? Why not make English the national language rather than Hindi the official language? After all we study in English and most jobs that are created are in English nowadays.

I feel Bangladesh did a good job in 1971, as now it is 16 million and have progressed a lot,because they are within their terrotiay. There women folk’s cannot be exported to another community. Additionally, they have already converted 35 percent of hindu’s into their faternity, by brainwashing, or forced convertions, love jihad. I have personally discussed with Hindu Bengali’s residing in a village of Bangldesh where the guy admitted that only 5 Hindu family’s remain,rest got converted. The bangladeshi’s are attracting foreign investment now .

Bengal is a Kolkata centric. Bengal minus Kolkata is nothing. Bangladesh has huge territory and number of Bangladeshis abroad are far in number than Indian Bengali’s.

Seems we have lost our battle due to foolishness of Over liberalism, Over secularism, Over Cowardice, blindly following the text books without a originality of ideas, giving of too much liberty to women folks has what is what we are now . I accept that we are not that handsome due to genetic trait’s but so are many of North eastern states. But I never hear there women folks betraying in such a big number.

My grandfather laid his 7 yrs in British prison due to freedom struggle. I have seized to proudly claim myself a Indian ,when I see my Bengali community in such a miserable state. I am a Bengali, and I DO NOT wish any more of the infiltration all in the name of Bhaichara. We have a Bengali culture and help us retain it. The nostalgic Kolkata is no more due to massive infiltration.

I do not see any future of Bangla language and culture in India.May be 50 years from now, Bangla language and culture will be exclusively be identified with Bangladesh.Perhaps that would be better.
 
Though we share the same ethnicity (surprisingly), there is an immense difference in the mentality and mindset between Bangladeshis and West Bengalis. We Bangladeshis are confident, proud and have a high self-esteem, otoh West Bengalis suffer from deep inferiority complex and have a pretty low self-esteem with a submissive mentality.

Just compare the history of East Pakistan and West Bengal. Bangla was made one of the national languages of Pakistan alongside Urdu, Pakistan had three Bengali PMs between '47-'71 and the Pakistan military was forced to radically raise the number of Bengali military personnel after our bravery in the 1965 war. For West Bengal, it's totally the opposite, it's a marginalised, backward and one of the poorest provinces of India, with the Bengalis losing their own territory to immigrants from other provinces.

The cultural onslaught from North India has already made West Bengal more like an extension of Bihar and UP. Now the job discrimination against the Bengalis is a further blow to their existence. The only way forward is to embrace the North Indian culture wholly and forget their Bengali past, they are more like refugees in their own land.
 
Last edited:
Though we share the same ethnicity (surprisingly), there is an immense difference in the mentality and mindset between Bangladeshis and West Bengalis. We Bangladeshis are confident, proud and have a high self-esteem, otoh West Bengalis suffer from deep inferiority complex and have a pretty low self-esteem.

Just compare the history of East Pakistan and West Bengal. Bangla was made one of the national languages of Pakistan alongside Urdu, Pakistan had three Bengali PMs between '47-'71 and the Pakistan military was forced to radically raise the number of Bengali military personnel after our bravery in the 1965 war. For West Bengal, it's totally the opposite, it's a marginalised, backward and one of the poorest provinces of India, with the Bengalis losing their own territory to immigrants from other provinces.

The cultural onslaught from North India has already made West Bengal more like an extension of Bihar and UP. Now the job discrimination against the Bengalis is a further blow to their existence. The only way forward is to embrace the North Indian culture wholly and forget their Bengali past, they are more like refugees in their own land.
Marwari beniyas are putting ''Bengalis are not allowed'' in their job noticeboard in Kolkata city.:lol::lol:
 
Now they West Bongs will understand whats happening in wb as the writer is West Bengali. I said it somewhere theyve become hindified. I dont care if their are Indian, but like other states in south holding onto on their own lingo and culture, why westB people letting go their culture/language like so easily. They seem mentally weak and even if non-westbengalis diss them and say stuff about them they’re fine with it. Being Indian, also South people are but they have their own respect for their culture and wont give in to any others. How about Hindis speak other language like Bengali when they go WestB? Or TamilNadu? Why cant they adapt? Why does it has to be other way around?

West Bengalis, keep you blind patriotism going, and serving your women to non-west/bengali mens, lose you lingo and culture and West Bengali men wipe and wipe for a spouse in his own region, hard to come by. So much for what your forefathers did for independence, now you’re becoming an outcast in your own region.
 
Hindu bengalis unlike their muslim bretherns in the east have always been cowards.

this has nothing to do with religion, i only use hindu/muslim because the article in question does.

Even when bangladesh was east pakistan. there was very few urdu influence. Unlike the WB, Bangladeshis know how to things done
 
Last edited:
Though we share the same ethnicity (surprisingly), there is an immense difference in the mentality and mindset between Bangladeshis and West Bengalis. We Bangladeshis are confident, proud and have a high self-esteem, otoh West Bengalis suffer from deep inferiority complex and have a pretty low self-esteem with a submissive mentality.

Just compare the history of East Pakistan and West Bengal. Bangla was made one of the national languages of Pakistan alongside Urdu, Pakistan had three Bengali PMs between '47-'71 and the Pakistan military was forced to radically raise the number of Bengali military personnel after our bravery in the 1965 war. For West Bengal, it's totally the opposite, it's a marginalised, backward and one of the poorest provinces of India, with the Bengalis losing their own territory to immigrants from other provinces.

The cultural onslaught from North India has already made West Bengal more like an extension of Bihar and UP. Now the job discrimination against the Bengalis is a further blow to their existence. The only way forward is to embrace the North Indian culture wholly and forget their Bengali past, they are more like refugees in their own land.

Absolutely true. Agree 100%. Amazing that they are going to let their culture go down the drain like this. Meanwhile @Roybot and the other 'bongs' on this forum are too happy to be addressed by epithets like 'bong'.

I've got one suggestion for non-Bangladeshis. Don't you ever (ever!) call us 'bongs'. :-)

Whither Bengali culture and 'parampara' (tradition)? Soon to be extinct.
 
Back
Top Bottom